4 ms·
"The MP3 player that they called iPod was, and is, considerably inferior to other MP3 players in terms of sound quality." This has not been my experience. Any
by sgt 13y ago
"The MP3 player that they called iPod was, and is, considerably inferior to other MP3 players in terms of sound quality."
This has not been my experience. Any opinions?
- masklinn 13y agoWell, it's probably true when "other" is used to designate very specific high-sound-quality models (e.g. Cowon a few years ago, not sure where they stand now), you can always find better and ipods are of average sound quality at best, they've never been an audiophile's PMP (or a PMP for driving high-impedance cans). It's a completely pointless statement though.
- shurcooL 13y agoI think it's more accurate to say the iPod (which one?) was not superior in all aspects of an MP3 player (especially in price). But IMO it had a very healthy balance of well done properties and good design. It was a device easy to love because unlike most other devices, it had way fewer glaring flaws and frustrating UI decisions. TL;DR: It's better to be great overall than excelling at just some features while also having crappy downfalls.
- frou_dh 13y agoAs someone who used to be in to audiophilia, debates on sound quality of equipment and the supposed night and day differences are an incredible exercise in futility and purchase justification. Smoke some cannabis and $5 earbuds fed by a no-name MP3 player will deliver more detail than the custom modded Sennheisers fed by an amp and DAC stack imported from a boutique in Belgium would have gotten you otherwise.
- LiseWeiss 13y agoDo you actually smoke weed ever? That's the wrongest thing I've ever heard. Smoke weed and now you can hear just how bad those shit earphones are, and just how much better the $500 earphones are. I've done this experiment about 100 times with half a dozen people and the results are always the same. Weed makes shit headphones less tolerable, not more tolerable.
- frou_dh 13y agoI'm ecstatic to be regarded the wrongest ever by someone still interested in lambasting "shit" sound equipment rather than just listening to music.
- LiseWeiss 13y agoyeah you know so much about me. I'm not lambasting shit sound equipment. I'm lambasting YOU for being WRONG. And I'm providing helpful information based on actually taking the pepsi challenge while high on "cannabis" as you put it (I've never met an actual weed smoker who calls it cannabis so I can tell you're not much of one). If you want to make terrible gear feel good, drink alcohol. That actually does help. But it's not because you're hearing it better... it's because your senses are impaired.
- pjmlp 13y agoI have one that never used, besides the first days as it was a gift and I already had a mp3 player. I always found the menu wheel too fragile.
- WalterBright 13y agoOne advantage to growing older is that since you can no longer hear the difference between lo-fi and hi-fi, audio equipment gets a lot less expensive!
- ciderpunx 13y agoBut what you save in speaker cable you lose on hearing aids, surely?
- JonnieCache 13y agoThe DACs are pretty much the same as you could find in any other mp3 player. The cowon ones and so on were somewhat better, but not massively so. You can see a battery of tests performed on various ipods as well as professional DACs costing thousands of $ here: http://www.daefeatures.co.uk/rmaa.php http://www.daefeatures.co.uk/rmaa.php They don't kick out a lot of power, so they don't cope well with fancy headphones. The bad reputation of the ipod's sound stems largely from those white earbuds that came in the box, which are genuinely abominable. That and confirmation bias/placebo/etc.
- podperson 13y agoIt's a complete crock. Most MP3 players today, and iPods for their entire history, offer pretty much perfect audio reproduction (modulo lossiness in MP3). Plenty of folks don't like the earbuds and, to be sure, the iPod was not technically superior to its rivals on first release -- the thing that made the iPod successful was end-to-end near seamless experience including purchasing of music, redownloading lost content, ripping music, managing library, syncing to devices, and so forth, which Apple's rivals repeatedly and ineptly failed to reproduce (Microsoft came close, with Zune, but it was too little too late). And yes, iTunes on Windows is a slug, etc., but rival products were always in some crucial respect worse.
- ladzoppelin 13y ago"much perfect audio reproduction" Yea any digital signal has to pass through things called "DAC's" that obviously come with different quality and price. DAC's along with the power supply/design greatly effect the sound of digital audio.
- faddotio 13y agoNot true. iPods were regarded as having crummy DACs until the Shuffle, which was a paradox in that it had incredibly limited features but also very good audio quality.
- ladzoppelin 13y agoI said DAC's+Power+Design = "audio quality" and I have no idea how good or bad the ipod sounds. My point was that saying all digital devices sound exactly the same is false.
- podperson 13y agoYou're right -- I stand corrected. A bit more research shows that some iPods have had weak bass output and other issues but -- again -- no more so than rivals, and most iPods have pretty much flawless output (again, modulo the quality of the encoding and the output device). More to the point -- making a blanket claim about iPods having always been inferior reveals the writer to be an anti-Apple troll.