10 ms·
Startup Ideas Every Nerd Has (That Never Work)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lisper 13y agoThis is a three-year-old blog post about a three-year-old HN comment about a different three-year-old blog post. Just sayin'.
- varelse 13y agoMore proof that everything comes in threes. Just like the Ramans...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- einhverfr 13y agoOr my theory on the etymology of Ramen (La mian from Hokkien meaning hand-pulled noodles -> Ramyun in Korean being a loan word -> Ramen in Japanese, as borrowed from the Korean).
- dalek_cannes 13y agoRendezvous with Ramen, Clarke's lesser known SF work that explores alien civilizations and the mythos of the flying spaghetti monster.
- einhverfr 13y agoPerhaps this explains the relationship between Ramen, the Mi-Go and the Flying Spaghetti Monster which also goes by the darker name of Chthulu.
- Jormundir 13y agoHah, I usually don't like when people repost old articles, but I didn't see this comment originally, and it is super awesome.
- AznHisoka 13y agoposted by a three-year old!
- swombat 13y agoI'm very tempted to write a blog post pointing to this comment, so that it might be reposted in 3 years - but I think it'll be neater if someone else does!
- larrys 13y agoYou could also re purpose that old content by updating with further thoughts and a new URL. Similar to what they do on "48 Hours" or with "60 Minutes" on CNBC "we last ran this story in..." [1] Just throw a coat of paint over it and let everyone feast. [1] Analogies are just repackaged ideas.
- rfnslyr 13y agoAt which point does History become irrelevant or ill suited for discussion? Please aware us all as you seem to hold the key.
- johnchristopher 13y agoWell... This is Hacker News not Hacker History.
- Raphael 13y agoThat's a great startup idea...
- larrys 13y agoThat expression peaked a few years ago: http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=just%20sayin&cmpt=q http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=just%20sayin&cmpt=q
- prostoalex 13y agoGoogle Trends is based on searches, so it implies it actually started up three years ago, and a bunch of n00bs had to find out what it means. It grew into simple and powerful everyday expression that everybody knows a meaning of.
- Houshalter 13y agoThat just shows how many people were searching for it, not how many people are using it. And most those people were probably searching for the song, not the expression.
- iopq 13y agoAnd it's about every idea being old! So fitting!
- misnome 13y agoThanks, that confused the hell out of me.
- HeyLaughingBoy 13y agoAnd his blog post is just as relevant now as it was then; what's your point?
- unono 13y agoCurrent thinking on this matter is to avoid the tired old web 2.0 hipster stuff. The current batch of YC is all about solving real problem for real people. Spoonrocket got the most applause ($6 meals delivered within 10 minutes).
- untilHellbanned 13y agoi'm all for real ideas but the 7000th web food delivery service shouldn't get people that excited, especially not the most select group of entrepreneurs in the world.
- unono 13y agoSpoonrocket is pretty unique. You'd have to go to the 3rd world like India to get similar levels of service. Spoonrocket's cars have builtin heaters that keep food warm, only 2 menu items a day, and really quick delivery. If they actually expanded nationwide they'd kill burger/pizza joints, or at least force them to innovate.
- nickpinkston 13y agoNeat implementation details and 'disruption' aren't what make a startup unique / important. For example: 'InstaToiletPaper is doing really unique things like drone delivery of toilet paper and a huge selection! If these guys succeed, they'd be out disrupting the $20B toilet paper market, or at least forcing the to innovate.
- unono 13y agoBy that standard few startups are 'important'. Twitter (sms on web), Facebook (another myspace), Microsoft (another OS). InstaToiletPaper is a pretty good startup if existed. When you run out of toilet paper you really want it quick. A drone could fly through a small window and it get it to you. You'd pay $10 for a single roll.
- 13y ago
- knowtheory 13y agoDerek Siver's observation back in 2005 that ideas are a modifier on execution is a slightly better recounting of this point: http://sivers.org/multiply http://sivers.org/multiply People can bitch and kvetch about elevator-pitch/vision level descriptions of products, but such analyses are always shallow, and particularly for interesting products almost always miss the point. Always look to the execution. (on the flip side, the flaws of poorly executed projects can often be very easy to sum up)
- phreanix 13y agoDoes YC have a collection if post mortems for their failed startups? I would find that very interesting.
- Xcelerate 13y agoAssuming your goal is to have a successful startup company, I've often wondered what the optimal trade-off between time-per-startup idea and number of startup attempts is. For instance, I could spend a year working on two really big, elaborate ideas that I have, but if they fail (likely), then I've wasted ("learned what not to do" if you're the optimistic type) a year working on only two ideas. Or... I could invest my time in a bunch of little startup ideas. Make one simple webapp a week, and out of 52 of them, one should stick, right? But the problem is that in general, the more time and effort you invest into any particular idea, the higher quality the product of your idea will become, and the better a chance it has for success. So, I'm not sure what the best route is. If you look at which companies have historically been successful (FB, Twitter, Instagram), you see that the founder spent almost all of their time on that one idea. But, this may be an example of selection bias. It could be the case that the biggest successes require a huge time-investment in one project, but the probability of success for any random project is very low. In a sense, they won a lottery of a sort. Perhaps your chance of success -- but not mega-success -- becomes more realistic if you focus on many smaller ideas.
- namenotrequired 13y agoHopefully you've found one of the 52 ideas awesome enough to spend a little longer on. How enthusiastic / passionate you are about it is a big factor in how successful will be.
- icpmacdo 13y agoI really like the idea of making a web app every week and seeing whats sticks. Its seems like it would be a much more diverse learning experience.
- telephonetemp 13y agoA web app a week sounds like a pretty brisk pace to me -- but then again my knowledge of web development is rather outdated. What technologies would you use to build a web app in 7 days in 2013?
- ethanazir 13y agoNo two ideas are ever the same; in the details... Sure Abraham Lincoln filed for a patent on the essence of 'friendster' and other followed suit; but the details make the difference.
- jonnathanson 13y agoTrue, though the Abe Lincoln social-networking thing was a hoax. (Lincoln held a patent, but it was for a method for helping boats navigate sandbars).
- cstejerean 13y agoIt's interesting that both Twitter and Facebook evolved quite a bit from where they started. The newsfeed and chat have both altered how I use Facebook and made it much more like twitter for me. When twitter first came out though I don't really see how anyone could have claimed it was a Facebook clone.
- pestaa 13y agoBy this logic... Facebook is actually a Twitter-clone? My head spins.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y agoThe problem with so many "startup ideas" is that they are a solution to the problem, "I want to create a startup and don't have an idea." Not surprisingly, this tends to produce copycat concepts, products with no real market fit, services that target sexy but oversaturated markets, etc. There are lots and lots of problems that are either unsolved or are being solved in ways that are less efficient and cost-effective than they could be, particularly outside of the consumer space. In many cases, these problems can be solved with relatively unsophisticated applications. But the folks who sit around thinking about the usual consumer internet suspects (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.) never discover these problems because more often than not, they have no domain expertise. Sadly, it seems to me that many technical wantrepreneurs have no real interest in developing domain expertise because they believe there's more value in mastering the framework du jour than focusing in on a vertical and developing a real understanding of it over time.
- joshhart 13y agoYes, of course if you have domain expertise and there is a need you can recognize a niche to fill with a company. I think getting domain expertise is easier said than done and could probably require quitting one's day job to go work in industry X for 5 years. Possibly just to find out that filling a niche is hard.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago1. I didn't suggest that domain expertise is easy to develop. Nobody gains expertise overnight. That's the point. 2. You don't have to quit your day job to develop domain expertise. Be strategic and try to make sure your day jobs are related to a specific industry. Far too many people hop from random startup to random startup. That's not surprising: the pay can be excellent, you get to work with the latest and greatest technologies, and you get a lottery ticket in the form of equity. But many of these jobs won't provide enough exposure to a vertical to actually gain meaningful knowledge of it. 3. If you get involved in an industry, you should take the time to establish relationships, especially with folks who are non-technical. If you nurture those relationships and keep your eyes open, you will often meet highly-knowledgeable, well-connected non-technical individuals who make for perfect non-technical co-founders. These are not the "non-technical co-founder seeking technical co-founder" wantrapreneurs with no domain expertise of their own who you run into all the time in Silicon Valley. 4. If you're not prepared to invest the time in understanding a specific market, that's fine. Be the best engineer you can be, try to maximize your income and consider whether it's worth continually beating your head against a brick wall to find an "idea" so that you can create a "startup."
- bliti 13y agoI stopped looking for ideas, and focused on solving problems. There is a difference. Ideas come with a lot of fluff. Meaning that under the right conditions they might work. Solving problems focuses on talking to people who have problems, and figuring out a way to solve it. I now spend at least an hour every week talking to people who have problems I want to solve: people who can pay. (:
- powerpuffgirls 13y agofuck you and your happy face.
- abrichr 13y agoHow do you choose whom to talk to, and where do you find them?
- bliti 13y ago1. I realized that a product is not built in a vacuum. Meaning that I had to go out and figure out what products where needed. This led me to reach a simple understanding: I would focus on building products that made people money. Selling such products seems to be simpler (I am still testing this at the moment). 2. With #1 in mind, I focused on what businesses need to make money: clients. Thus, I set out to learn how business generated new leads, or followed up on clients. 3. Now that I had focused on solving a type of problem (lead generation and client follow up), I set out to research markets. Every business out there needs leads. But some can be easily automated. Using patio11's appointment reminder app as inspiration, I started to ask people how such app would help their business. Turns out there is a big demand for such a simple application. Who knew that sending text messages and making automated phone calls would be such a life saver? 4. Who did I talk to? Well, who needs to keep constant contact with their client list? Dentists, insurance agents, private schools, auto mechanics, etc. 5. Once I knew the who, finding the where was as simple as looking in my cellphone. I called my dentist, and insurance agent to talk about the application (before writing any code). They gave their feedback and I set out to write it.
- muratmutlu 13y agoI saw a talk recently called 'everything is a remix' which said that every idea is formed in some part by something that's been done before http://everythingisaremix.info/watch-the-series/ http://everythingisaremix.info/watch-the-series/
- oscargrouch 13y agosomebody, somewhere must come with something for the first time.. this copy/mix stuff is more reasonable in more common line of thinking (average people) how many people would be thinking at relativity when einstein did, or calculi for newton(actually two with ), or marx thougts in "the capital", a music piece by mozart or a painting by van gogh.. they created great things because their toughts were above average, and they where not losing too much time with ordinary things.. like "what will i eat?" "were are the kids" .. "i wanna a big iate" .. etc.. etc.. this kind of tought, that nothing is really original, only diminish the human nature.. and if we mix and copy.. the problem are ourselves.. we can do better, and improve with effort.. than some day.. that something really original, that no human being could ever thought can come into reality if people wanna think different things, they must first start to look to different horizons, where nobody or almost nobody are looking at.. the innovations starts in the way you think.. you need to observe yourself thinking, and be your own harsh critical
- dpanah 13y agoAnother smart twit. So he thinks.
- igorgue 13y agoMy advice is, chill, have fun, you don't need to be an entrepreneur. I really don't understand why being an entrepreneur is so "sexy" (only to other dudes, being sexist for a moment here) these days, it's lame. P.S. I know, wrong forum to say that.
- sergiosgc 13y agoIt's the thrill of creation. You see, many people are creators. They feel a need to pour their imagination into something that lasts, possibly something that outlasts themselves. There are quite a few routes for fulfilling this desire: arts, engineering, parenting, and, you guessed it, entrepreneurship. And yes, this being a hacker forum, where everyone is the creator kind of person, the percentage of possible entrepreneurs here is bound to be high.
- igorgue 13y agoIt's not the only way to create stuff, I make music on the side, and hack on open source project. You don't need to be a CEO to make something.
- sergiosgc 13y agoI never said it is. Quite the opposite. I was just placing the choice of entrepreneurship against your advice of "chill, have fun". For many(most?) entrepreneurs, creating an organization, and using it to create stuff in a larger scale, is fun.
- powerpuffgirls 13y agoHow is that even remotely interesting? wtf.
- shubb 13y agoI have a startup idea that I'm not going to execute. I currently live with a senior social worker, and my mother was a social worker. Over the years have been deeply troubled by what I've heard. I think this tool could help them, even if it's a bit creepy. Social workers in the UK have a big problem. Different teams, professions (police, medical, housing), deal with the same people, and often collect all the pieces required to understand and prevent a tragic situation. But they can't put them together. There is an obsession with interpofessional meetings to tackle this, but every serious case review shows that the knowledge was there but not put together, leading to dead children. My perception is that often knowledge is mentioned, but when discussing a different related case, or isn't formally written down and passed to the right person. My solution is inspired by the part of the CALO project that dealt with capturing and exploiting knowledge from meetings. There are some great ideas. If you do this, read up on it. The product records all meetings, using existing meeting room Teleconference hardware. The meetings are put through automatic speech and speaker recognition on a best effort basis to produce a searchable index for that meeting. So you get something like a transcript and can skip to the point where Mr A is mentioned. Supervisors, who in that field are criminally liable for mistakes by subordinates, already review minutes for meetings. Now they can search for any mention of Mr A, and see in what context he was mentioned and listen to that part of the meeting. Obviously there would be control of who could listen to what meetings, but these people already have big intrusive databases, so I don't think they are too worried. Ideally, you could then build graphs from there of who is mentioned together, and do some Palantir style stuff to spot associations between people. But the start is, very much, implementing a meeting transcriber by sowing together a few brands of speech recognition engine, a web interface for administrating and searching meetings, and selling it into social services.
- frozenport 13y agoSounds like a good idea, but i'm not sure how this relates to conversation.
- mcintyre1994 13y agoWithout relevant domain or speech recognition expertise, it seems that names might be one of the more common areas to get errors while transcribing using such a system, particularly if the system isn't trained for a name and/or it is said by many different voices?
- graycat 13y ago> As I pointed out before, there are no new ideas. Everything of value has been done before in one form or another. Let's see: Take idea some X and the set A of all efforts for idea X. Then take the effort in set A that was earliest in time (probability of exact ties 0). Call that effort T. Then when T was done, idea X was a "new idea" and not "done before" in contradiction to the quote. For there being "no new ideas", the research libraries are stuffed with journals of peer-reviewed original research, and the usual standards for publication are "new, correct, and significant". So, those libraries are stuffed with "new ideas" that the quote says don't exist. Are there new ideas in business? Sure: The transistor, the integrated circuit, the Multics processor architecture (heavily borrowed since), security via capabilities, access control lists, and authentication, the microprocessor, RSA encryption, speculative execution, out of order execution, penicillin, cardiac stents, and on and on. 'Nuff.
- Lerc 13y agoContinuing in the face of a stream of "Your idea sucks" presents quite a challenge. You can tell yourself that the best ideas and most successful ventures had similar detractors, but it doesn't always help. You are aware of your own project more than the casual observer. The weaknesses and hurdles to pass are more apparent to you, and you can't help wondering if the comments are insightful and your project really does suck and you are just too invested in it to see the truth. I have done a lot of things where upon presenting them to people, they would say "What's the point?", "That can't be done", or commonly "There's no point in an alternative to X. Even if it does work, people won't change from X". I have even had "that's the stupidest thing I have ever seen" The chances of those things becoming enormous successes are tiny, and I'm aware of that. But the chances for those who _did_ become enormous successes were also tiny. It's a hard road, but only people who walk the road have a chance. Please, rather than criticize the attempt, or the implementation, or the presentation, or their use of apostrophes. Try offering directions that could help them in the direction they want to be going. There's no point in saying "Turn back now." Even if you think they are going in the wrong direction, they have made their choice and the journey will be informative.
- einhverfr 13y agoI would suggest a slightly different framework. Never say "turn back now." However, I try to divide my criticism into three groups: 1. Major show-stoppers need to be discussed and brought to light early on. The point is not to say "don't get started" but rather to say "do you have any idea what you are up against?" Having an idea is the first step to planning, and planning is mostly valuable for mapping out obstacles and potential solutions. 2. Once one is past the commitment and planning phase, I think it is fine to criticize implementation. The goal here is to bring up problems that might not need to be solved right away but need to be on the radar. 3. These need to be coupled with constructive support. Heavy criticism along with solid support is golden. Heavy criticism without solid support is like a lead weight.
- novaleaf 13y agolooks like the OP couldn't take the heat, and removed the original content. Weak.
- deerpig 13y agoMost of the comments here are twice as long as the original post, which wasn't so much a post, but just a comment, on.... HN comments....