4 ms·
Umm, what makes you think there isn't a lot of very good data? Start with http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm#dtap http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/
by dalke 13y ago
Umm, what makes you think there isn't a lot of very good data? Start with http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm#dtap http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vac-gen/side-effects.htm#dtap . I linked to DTaP but there are many others on that page.
To report a problem, go to http://vaers.hhs.gov/index http://vaers.hhs.gov/index , which is the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System.
Did you get any paperwork about the immunization? There should have been a flyer or handout like http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/vis/vis-statements/dtap.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/vis/vis-statements/dtap.pdf . This has information both about VAERS, as well as about the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program.
The "ap" in DTaP vaccine means "acellular Pertussis", which means it uses antigens of the pertussis pathogen rather than whole cells. There should be no infectious material that could cause a bad cough a week later. (It also has fewer side-effects than, but is also less effective than the whole cell vaccine.)
I read that newspaper article you mentioned. It said "Infants under 2 months of age are at the highest risk, accounting for five of Texas' [six] deaths this year" and "80 percent of those were children under 2 months old, who are too young to be vaccinated against the disease."
This is a very different situation than what you are describing, where a cough starts a week after the vaccination. I don't think you can make the inference that it's a side-effect of the vaccination itself based on that article.
The article points out that the new vaccine formulation doesn't seem to be as effective for as long as the old one. What's likely happening is that adults whose immunity has worn off are acting as carriers for the disease, and infecting babies and children who haven't received any immunization for the disease.
This is probably one of the reasons that the Td immunization (DTaP is for children) recommends "All adults should get a booster dose of Td every 10 years."
(While it doesn't confer a life-long immunity, the goal is to prevent pertussis in children; they have the highest risk of death if infected.)
I don't know what to say to you, other than that I, some anonymous person on the internet, agrees with your doctor that "it probably wasn't Pertussis."
> "even considering the low expected rate of serious adverse vaccination events, it is not possible that this clinic has never had a reportable event"
There are different styles of reporting. First off, 25% of the children who receive the DTaP vaccine get a fever, 25% get redness or swelling where the shot was given, and 25% get soreness or tenderness where the shot was given. Your doctor has almost certainly seen those side effects.
But they aren't reported because they are expected. Again, they should be in the handout you got as part of the information about immunization. No doctor is going to report such mild problems.
Then there are the "moderate problems", like seizure, non-stop crying, and a fever of over 105°F. These occur in less than 1:1000 children, which means there should have been a couple of children in your clinic who have had these reactions.
However, it's up to the doctor to decide if this is severe enough to report. The
VAERS guideline include "clinically significant adverse health events following vaccination", "vaccination error [that] may pose a safety risk", "or that the error would be preventable with public health action or education" but "accepts all reports."
These moderate problems are likely not 'significant adverse.' The severe cases seem to happen in 1:1 million cases or rarer for the vaccinations I looked at. Even across all of the vaccinations, it's unlikely that your doctor's office would have had that happen to one of their patients.
So, that's one style of reporting. Another style occurs when they get the above statistics in the first place. In that case, they enroll doctors into the program, and have the doctors report all problems that arise after the vaccination. This can be compared to a baseline reference from children who haven't yet had the vaccine. (Eg, the three weeks before the vaccine compared to the three weeks after.) That's used to weed out coincidental correlations. After all, kids do get sick even with vaccines.
This second style of reporting is what's used to list the known risks of the vaccine, with the first style of reporting use to get information about the very rare cases.
What should the doctor have done to improve your sense of confidence? Run a test for pertussis even though your child didn't have the symptoms for the disease? Make a report even though it wasn't a severe adverse effect? The information you wanted - what to do if there was a severe affect - should have been information you already had. I'm somewhat surprised that the staff didn't know that, since I (an anonymous stranger on the internet) knew it existed, but I also only know your side of the story.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago>Umm, what makes you think there isn't a lot of very good data? Because there isn't. Good data on vaccine outcomes would mean that blood samples would be taken and used to assess the effectiveness of vaccines. Good data would require a follow-up tests post vaccination. Good data means I'd get a report in the mail, and maybe every once in a while the report might say to come and get another X because the test indicates that the last X vaccination was ineffective. Thanks, I've been all over the FDA's and the CDC's websites. >To report a problem, go to http://vaers.hhs.gov/index http://vaers.hhs.gov/index , which is the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System. Yes, VAERS is voluntary reporting system that is sporadically used by practitioners, and may also be filled with reports from randoms, some of which may be junk. It has some value, it is better than nothing; but, we certainly aren't going to draw many conclusions from it. I was very dissatisfied with baby's first pediatrician for failing to mention VAERS when I asked, as anyone should be. >Did you get any paperwork about the immunization? Of course, parents are showered with CDC pamphlets; and showered with them again every time you tick a box on forms that say your child isn't up to date on ALL vaccinations. >There should be no infectious material that could cause a bad cough a week later. I know there shouldn't! I described an experience as I remembered it. I did not draw a conclusion, I cannot. I do not have my own immunology lab. But, neither can I dismiss the possibility that the cough was related to the vaccination (maybe baby was exposed in the waiting room). Nobody else should draw a conclusion from a secondhand anecdote, either. Baby could have been exposed several other ways, either to Pertussis or something else. >I don't know what to say to you, other than that I, some anonymous person on the internet, agrees with your doctor that "it probably wasn't Pertussis." Nor do I know what to say to you other than, you're probably right. You'll probably always be right because both Pertussis infection, and vaccine adverse reactions are fortunately rare. I didn't ask the ped to make a VAERS report over the visit. I asked what would happen in the event of a serious problem, following a vaccination. If you're my child's pediatrician, and your response to my question indicates a lack of knowledge, or possible willingness to mislead me for your own convenience; then you probably aren't going to be my child's pediatrician much longer. > The severe cases seem to happen in 1:1 million cases or rarer for the vaccinations I looked at. Even across all of the vaccinations, it's unlikely that your doctor's office would have had that happen to one of their patients. Unless death is the only thing you qualify as serious, you are mistaken. Even with the shabby state of data collection, and the even shabbier state of medical studies, severe adverse reactions are evidently more common than 1:1e6. Look at pretty much any vaccine label for evidence to support that. I haven't access to our former ped's books, but I would expect them to have given tens maybe hundreds of thousands of vaccinations per decade as a conservative estimate. Consider the number of vaccines recommended by the CDC schedule http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/parents/downloads/parent-ver-sch-0-6yrs.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/parents/downloads/parent-ver-sch... >What should the doctor have done to improve your sense of confidence? Run a test for pertussis even though your child didn't have the symptoms for the disease? The child did have the symptoms of the disease[1][2]. Additionally, as I stated, about that time, there was a "Massive Pertussis (fear mongering) Outbreak" in the news, with periodic reporting and shaming of vaccine refuseniks. Yes, absolutely, the ped. should have run a test. But the main thing that any ped. can do to inspire confidence is not to be dismissive of parents' concerns or questions. If instead of waving more CDC pamphlets at us, she had mentioned VAERS, or anything resembling even a vague and non-specific something like VAERS she would probably still be our ped. Is it not enough that I vaccinate my kids for infectious diseases, despite my suspicions that all may not be right in the world of vaccines[3], but you expect me to do so with unreserved faith in the manufacturers of vaccines, and the government? [1] http://www.cdc.gov/pertussis/about/signs-symptoms.html http://www.cdc.gov/pertussis/about/signs-symptoms.html [2] Pertussis symptoms are quite like the symptoms of Influenza, and many other childhood ailments. [3] I don't question the science of immunology or epidemiology. I question the claim that in practice, vaccines are manufactured, distributed, and administered with a near miraculous failure rate.