5 ms·
The headteacher, in addition to reporting Zaloom to the police, phoned Glasgow University, where the student had applied to study, in an attempt to dissuade the
by rhizome 13y ago
The headteacher, in addition to reporting Zaloom to the police, phoned Glasgow University, where the student had applied to study, in an attempt to dissuade them from accepting him.
Not the best way to counter charges of endemic corrpution in society, I must say. In the US, this kind of interference would pose a great deal of trouble for the ambitious functionary.
- mezmor 13y agoThe UK has pretty strict libel laws. I wouldn't be surprised if approaching Glasgow U falls under that category.
- switch007 13y agoThe costs involved with libel cases are nothing short of eye-watering [1]. Strict libel laws are pointless if you can't afford to bring a case. (Though, there are "no-win, no-fee" agreements available) [1] http://pcmlp.socleg.ox.ac.uk/research/project/comparative-study-costs-defamation-proceedings-across-europe http://pcmlp.socleg.ox.ac.uk/research/project/comparative-st...
- AimHere 13y agoDefaming a third party by telephone would more likely be slander than libel, but it's certainly not clear that what went on here would be defamation at all. A defamatory statement must be a false factual allegation. As long as what the headmaster claimed was true, he should be safe from libel or slander lawsuits - saying "I don't like this guy's politics and you shouldn't take him on as a student." is a fair expression of opinion, however silly that opinion is, and despite the rather insidious attempt to harm someone's career over a personal/political disagreement. Mind you, I'd guess that in these sorts of circumstances, Glasgow University would likely thank the headmaster for his concern and file the note of this communication in the waste paper basket, where it belongs. Universities are no stranger to having to fend off third parties - parents, police, stalkers and whathaveyou - attempting to meddle in the affairs of their students; if their admin staff are halfways competent, they already have 50 tactful ways of telling outside interferers to fuck off.
- carbocation 13y agoTruth is an absolute defense to the claim of libel or slander in the US, but not in all worldwide jurisdictions.
- walshemj 13y agoEven if its the truth its still gross misconduct by the head in my book - I bet this is a "free" school with no proper governing body.
- Zuider 13y agoIt is a Comprehensive, or state school.
- AimHere 13y agoIt's also the case in the UK. What makes you think I was thinking of US libel law? I'm not American
- carbocation 13y agoEnglish libel law is substantially more friendly to the plaintiff than to the defendant. I referenced US libel law as a counterpoint to the rest of the world because I thought you were not thinking of the US. There have been several high profile cases of journalists and scientists saying true but defamatory things in the UK about quacks and charlatans and being hounded in the courts. In response to this, the UK has actually passed legislation attempting to remedy the situation, but this has not yet taken effect.
- Zuider 13y ago>...saying "I don't like this guy's politics and you shouldn't take him on as a student." is a fair expression of opinion... Mr. Szemalikowski appears to be claiming that he considered the student, Kinnan Zaloom, to be a potential terrorist: >He said he had 'major concerns and was duty bound under legal acts for the prevention of violent extremism' and that he was 'erring on the side of caution' in taking action. >'It is fairly worrying stuff,' he added. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2414197/A-level-student-reported-police-criticising-school-online-blog.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2414197/A-level-stud...
- rz2k 13y agoEarlier this year [1]: >Then there is Katelyn Campbell, 18, whose objection to a factually dubious sex-education assembly at her high school bubbled over into a confrontation with her principal, which bubbled over onto the Internet. > As a senior at George Washington High School in Charleston, W.Va., Ms. Campbell complained to the American Civil Liberties Union about an April assembly featuring an abstinence advocate, Pam Stenzel. > [...] Irritated by her actions, Ms. Campbell said, her principal threatened to tell Wellesley College, where Ms. Campbell had been accepted, that she was a troublemaker. Ms. Campbell filed an injunction against her principal, seeking to prevent him from “discriminating against me in any way,” and told the news media her story. > [...] Several days later, Wellesley used its Twitter account to make its position known: “Katelyn Campbell, #Wellesley is excited to welcome you this fall.” [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/03/science/young-and-against-bad-science.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/03/science/young-and-against-...
- mathattack 13y agoI don't know what's better, that she used a lawyer to get the principal to back off, or that Wellesley stood up for her. It really bothers me when petty admins abuse their position, because they prey on the weak.