4 ms·
Neither group is weird. It's totally reasonable for individuals to prefer a fecal transplant over surgery. But doctors are part of a complicated system that pr
by wpietri 13y ago
Neither group is weird. It's totally reasonable for individuals to prefer a fecal transplant over surgery.
But doctors are part of a complicated system that prevents wild-ass medical experiments from being tried on humans. If you go in front of a review board [1] and say, "Hey, we'd like to try experimenting on live humans by giving them an unknown collection of microorganisms in hope that unspecified good things will happen", I can't imagine that it will go well.
Like it or not, the best currently proven treatment is the band. To prove that something else is better is a lot of work. I strongly share your suspicion that fecal transplants would be better, and if I were desperate that's what I'd try with my own body. But medical history is littered with treatments that looked promising but didn't work out, often because of hideous unexpected side effects.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_review_board http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_review_board
- stretchwithme 13y agoIts also a system that sometimes takes forever to change even when there is evidence. I read recently that it took 25 years to stop x-raying pregnant women after a British doctor found that it lead to birth defects. And the unnecessary surgeries and medication and scans. I really find it hard to think of this as a conservative industry governed by "first, do no harm". These are all well-tested, according the establishment. Fecal bacteria may not be well tested by the establishment, but its something we have been living with for millions of years. Many animals are constantly exposed to fecal matter. And so are you if you ride public transportation. Maybe what this approach needs is someone like Craig Venter to sequence all the bacteria found in generally healthy people and people with specific problems. He did this in the oceans and found all this previously undiscovered genomes. That same tech could probably determine what strains of bacteria to start testing just from their absence in the unhealthy. At the same time, their presence in the perfectly healthy indicates that the bacteria in question probably isn't dangerous. Of course, how specific individuals will react is always an unknown. But that remains an unknown even after something is well tested. When I hear all the possible side effects of accepted drugs, which often include death, I have to wonder if there isn't some bias in favor of things created in a lab and where someone stands to make large profits. These drugs are recalled all the time and class action suits are common. None of this inspires much confidence in how treatments are evaluated.
- quasque 13y ago> Maybe what this approach needs is someone like Craig Venter to sequence all the bacteria found in generally healthy people and people with specific problems. There are quite a few well-funded projects doing this on a large scale, see http://www.human-microbiome.org/index.php?id=30 http://www.human-microbiome.org/index.php?id=30 for a comprehensive list. Not just the gut but other bacterial sites like skin, mouth, nasal cavity, urinary tract, etc.
- stretchwithme 13y agoawesome, thanks.