4 ms·
Misconduct That's where you and Gorman disagree. His point is that, yes, people screwed up; but no, they didn't do it deliberately. We don't throw people in
by cperciva 13y ago
Misconduct
That's where you and Gorman disagree. His point is that, yes, people screwed up; but no, they didn't do it deliberately. We don't throw people in jail for being bad at their jobs; we throw people in jail for deciding to do something wrong.
- ronaldx 13y agoThis argument is a good way of justifying systematic incompetence. If you claim that an individual was just doing their job, their superior should be held responsible for creating that job (up to and particularly including the CEO).
- njr123 13y agoWe absolutely do throw people in jail for being bad at their jobs. If an engineer signs off on design work which then fails and injures/kills someone due to their incompetence they can and are charged with professional negligence and sent to jail. Although financial incompetence doesn't kill anyone, it does effect a much much larger number of people, so I don't see why we shouldn't take the same approach and make the directors of financial firms personally liable for the outcomes of their actions.
- masklinn 13y ago> If an engineer signs off on design work which then fails and injures/kills someone due to their incompetence they can and are charged with professional negligence and sent to jail. And medical misconduct and malpractice often involve federal investigations, that tells you it's not considered trivial.
- kaonashi 13y agoIt doesn't directly kill anyone, but it affects macro factors such that more people will die as a result.
- madaxe 13y agoUsed to work on several trading desks. Bribing your risk desk wasn't just common - it was expected. I doubt anything has changed.
- pfortuny 13y agoDeliberately assumming a position in which you act and bet (yes, bet) with other people's money and in which you assume NO RESPONSIBILITY is an unjust position which you accept deliberately. Yes, it is hard to say but no, you cannot behave unjustly even if other people want you to. You cannot get a slave even if the other person wants you to get him as a slave. You cannot harm an inocent person even if he wants you to. The problem with Lehman was, essentially, that of lack of responsibility. And this is inherently unjust. So: with the letter of the law, they "do not need to go to jail" (say Lehman's board of directors), but with a reasonable understanding of justice, they acted in an unjust way. Wittingly.
- leoc 13y agoThe problem is that his claim just isn't very plausible. It takes a great deal of optimism to believe that everything that happened in (in particular) the origination, packaging and rating of US subprime mortgages (including the stated-income mortgages which industry types were referring to as "liar's loans", at the same time they were making and processing them) was a product of simple ignorance and incompetence.