4 ms·
You have made an implication, without basis, that the immunization policies in the US are "unconditionally pro", or at least that the people here are "unconditi
by dalke 13y ago
You have made an implication, without basis, that the immunization policies in the US are "unconditionally pro", or at least that the people here are "unconditionally pro."
This is not the case. Read any of the CDC, NIH, or WHO history of vaccinations and you'll see the reasons for the decisions. You'll see the numbers of how much it costs to vaccinate, how much it costs to treat, the likelihood of disease, the likelihood of death, and the effect of side-effects. You'll see research to reduce those side-effects, like improved treatment methods for those with egg allergies.
You'll see treatment policies change over time. The polio vaccine in the US use to be the more effective Sabin vaccine, which used attenuated vaccine strains that occasionally mutated to a more virulent form that gave 144 known cases of vaccine-associated paralytic polio (VAPP) between 1980 and 1999.
Since polio doesn't exist in the US, we switched to the deactivated form in 2000. This isn't as effective, which is why there's now one more shot in the vaccination series, but the old treatment, if continued, would have been deadlier.
There has always been a policy to allow people to opt out of vaccines, usually for religious reasons. (The last outbreak in the US was among Amish groups. The virus came from the Netherlands.) A reason why is because there will always be resistance to any mandate, and vaccines don't require 100% coverage to be effective in a population. It's better to let a few not be vaccinated than to use the indiscriminate and blunt threat of government intervention against them.
This means the CDC and others have to be very cautions and sensitive. For example, even though there's no evidence that mercury preservatives in vaccines cause side effects, you'll see that the vaccines were reformulated to remove thimerosal. The general policy is to minimize objections to the process, and not to force people to comply.
This is absolutely not an "unconditionally pro" policy, so you are downvoted because you're speaking out of ignorance and a blithe appeal, as jlgreco rightly points out, to an argument to moderation.
- raphinou 13y ago> You have made an implication, without basis, that the > immunization policies in the US are "unconditionally pro", > or at least that the people here are "unconditionally pro." You have interpreted this. Read my comment without considering me as anti-vaccines and maybe you'll understand you over-reacted.... My reflection was about pushing administration of vaccines against for example stomach ulcers (vaccine in development) or rotaviruses in developed countries. Would you be for mandating, in high-income countries, the administration of a vaccine against rotaviruses knowing their efficiency is only 45%? Rotavirus is evaluated at 1% of children deaths in these countries [1] (from CDC, a source you mention yourself). Will you also push for a vaccine for the 99 other percent? [1] http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/9/5/02-0562_article.htm http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/9/5/02-0562_article.htm
- dalke 13y ago"Read my comment without considering me as anti-vaccines" I didn't regard you as such in the first place. I regarded you as making the incorrect appeal to argument by moderation. Now you have switched the topic, from the implication that the US health policy and/or supporters in this forum are "unconditionally pro" vaccination, to a question about a specific vaccine and disease. I do not wish to discuss this new topic.
- raphinou 13y agoI don't understand why you think I'm discussing US policy... It seems we don't understand each other and ending our discussion is indeed the best option.
- dalke 13y agoI never said you were talking directly about US policy. I both times used the word "implication." You say there are two camps. I point out that the majority view, which includes the views of the CDC and WHO, and described in their publications, is in neither of those camps that you proposed. Specifically, you say "Sadly both camps (pro and anti vaccines) have too extreme positions to have a constructive debate." The US health policy is decidedly pro vaccine. Therefore, I can use it an exemplar to determine if it has "extreme views" which are "too extreme positions to have a constructive debate." I then showed that there is a lot of debate and cost/benefit analysis on the use of different vaccines, including a change in the vaccination policies over time as conditions change. Nothing about the debate looks "extreme". Therefore either you don't understand the majority view or you are using an very different reference frame than the others on this forum, without explaining the context shift. That's the likely source of the downvotes that you complained about.
- raphinou 13y agoNow I understand your reasoning. Stating there are two camps with no one in-between was maybe indeed too... extreme. I meant to say that there are a lot of people with strong opinions, and few with a balanced view acknowledging there are both risks and benefits.