4 ms·
I agree that you can't tell where a user behind a proxy is located, so I'm willing to give the NSA the benefit of the doubt on that issue. But the vast majority
by greenyoda 13y ago
I agree that you can't tell where a user behind a proxy is located, so I'm willing to give the NSA the benefit of the doubt on that issue. But the vast majority of domestic internet traffic does not go through a VPN or proxy, so you can tell just by looking at the originating and terminating IP addresses that the packet is going from one place in the U.S. to another. Also, you can probably assume that a VPN that's on a domain registered to a company inside the U.S. that is not selling VPN services to the general public (e.g., a bank) isn't being used by random terrorists outside the U.S.
But the whole business of "parallel construction" where the NSA shares warrantlessly intercepted data with the DEA and keeps it secret from defense lawyers is pretty good evidence that "minimization" is a sham and the NSA is not honestly trying to keep itself within legal and constitutional bounds.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI live in the US, but I'm not a US citizen, so I'm definitely a foreign person. Now suppose that I were a spy or a supporter of terrorism, are you saying the NSA shouldn't be able to monitor my activities because I am inside the US? I've had occasion to think about this before, here and in other countries. I'm Irish, and as I'm sure you know there was a lot of anti-British terrorism originating in Northern Ireland for a long time. Terrorism was carried out within the UK, and for that mattter a good bit of it was funded from the US by people who considered that terrorism a noble cause (including, famously, Republican representative Peter King - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_T._King#Support_for_the_IRA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_T._King#Support_for_the_I...). But the whole business of "parallel construction" where the NSA shares warrantlessly intercepted data with the DEA and keeps it secret from defense lawyers is pretty good evidence that "minimization" is a sham and the NSA is not honestly trying to keep itself within legal and constitutional bounds. No dispute with that point. I just want to clarify that the NSA's legitimate scope is not defined purely geographically.
- mpyne 13y agoActually, by virtue of being on U.S. soil you are also fully protected by the 4th Amendment, despite not being a U.S. citizen. That's why the NSA is generally careful to refer to "U.S. persons" instead of "U.S. citizens" when they talk in technical terms about things like minimization.
- anigbrowl 13y ago'US person' includes citizens, green card holders, and US-based associations or corporations consisting/employing largely of the first two. I don't have a green card, so I'm not a US person. See USC 1801.i. The 4th amendment's protections even extend to people such as tourists, whereas they are not considered US persons under FISA. See also http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1302&context=facpub http://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?ar... BTW can you drop me an email at some point? Username at gmail.
- mpyne 13y agoAh, interesting point of clarification, thanks.