8 ms·
I'd say the design, keyboard and trackpad are rather subjective if you think they're "systematically better". The Retina display currently is better than other
by MichaelGG 13y ago
I'd say the design, keyboard and trackpad are rather subjective if you think they're "systematically better". The Retina display currently is better than other offerings, but even the Nexus 10 offers similar DPI. Give me a ThinkPad with a N10 display over a MacBook anyday.
Also, there's no real reason Lenovo, Dell, etc. can't start shipping higher quality displays, keyboards, etc. While Apple's products are apparently solidly engineered, most of it is perception and design.
- kposehn 13y ago> Also, there's no real reason Lenovo, Dell, etc. can't start shipping higher quality displays, keyboards, etc. While Apple's products are apparently solidly engineered, most of it is perception and design. I disagree with this statement entirely, for one big reason: you're leaving out Apple's mastery of the supply chain. There are certainly component makers out there that will build stuff and slap it together for you, but Apple is the champ of running the whole stack with a relentless eye towards quality control. Think about the design and manufacturing of an iPhone, iPad or MacBook Pro. These are not things that you can compete with easily. There is a massive amount of effort involved in order to build a machine of comparable quality to an Apple device, and that remains one of their key advantages in the market. This is also an advantage they are dead-set on keeping. Most competitors don't have anywhere near the supply chain controls that Apple commands, and often don't even design their own devices (Dell). Finally, quality is a very important component of design. The prettiest laptop in the world is bad design if it falls apart or feels flimsy. Think less about design being the way something looks - instead, add how it feels, sounds, smells even, and every other part of the way you interact with it. That is design.
- lapa 13y agoFunny you mention quality. The Retina MBP has been plugged with issues such as image retention and hanky scrolling. Not something you expect when paying $2,000+ for a laptop. Stop by the MacRumors forum to see all the complaints.
- lurkinggrue 13y agoWow, Apple is good at their marketing/brand loyalty. Reminds me of the Apple brand loyal friends I had in the late 90s. He would go on about the build quality but had to point a fan at his laptop to keep it from overheating.
- MichaelGG 13y agoDunno about your experience, but mine and everyone I've talked to seem to think IBM ThinkPads had top notch build quality (minus the gripe about the screens). The keyboards, even on the 12" X-series are as good as any full-size kb save the Ergo 4000. Trackpad with 3 buttons is amazingly useful. Then again, ThinkPads are in another realm, and aren't cheap for good configurations. So Lenovo certainly could pull it off if they don't screw it up.
- lapa 13y agoThe new Lenevo Yoga 2 has a higher resolution than the MacBook Pro with Retina display. http://www.geek.com/chips/lenovo-yoga-2-pro-steals-highest-resolution-laptop-title-from-macbook-pro-1569639/ http://www.geek.com/chips/lenovo-yoga-2-pro-steals-highest-r...
- MichaelGG 13y agoYeah, but it's not a real ThinkPad... it's just another laptop.
- lurkinggrue 13y agoI admit I never saw the quality of Apple products. They were well done but the sort design ideas where if they could get away with it they would be a solid block to prevent you from peeking. I guy I know put it best with Apple products: With Apple things are either easy or near impossible. I am the sort of person that will constantly but heads with the design choices so I avoid the products.
- jinushaun 13y agoBut that's the point. Dell and company could, but they don't and instead choose to go further down market chasing thinner margins. They don't compete in the high end market so the perception is that Apple products are high quality, and PCs are low quality.