4 ms·
"No, their official response is to suggest that encrypting your communications makes you indistinguishable (at their end) from those who encrypt for criminal ac
by greenyoda 13y ago
"No, their official response is to suggest that encrypting your communications makes you indistinguishable (at their end) from those who encrypt for criminal activity."
However, it is not within the NSA's authority to pursue criminal activity within the U.S. — they're only mandated to spy on communications between the U.S. and a foreign country, or entirely outside the U.S. If I'm in the U.S. and send an encrypted message to somebody else in the U.S. (like my friend or my bank), they have no legal excuse to spy on me. If I'm under criminal suspicion for a crime committed in the U.S., the FBI or local law enforcement agencies need to get a warrant to intercept my communications. But, as the article states:
In fact, the NSA's "minimization" techniques — touted as methods for restricting spying to foreign terrorists instead of U.S. citizens — are often transparently and insultingly ridiculous.
- tjr 13y agoIf I'm under criminal suspicion for a crime committed in the U.S., the FBI or local law enforcement agencies need to get a warrant to intercept my communications. There is evidence that the FBI also engages in warrantless wiretapping. See http://mitpress.mit.edu/books/privacy-line http://mitpress.mit.edu/books/privacy-line
- mpyne 13y agoYes, minimization was one of his good points. But the architecture of the Internet also seems to make it very difficult to determine conclusively that a given communication has nothing whatsoever to do with someone outside the U.S. Consider a VPN/proxies for instance, or even an email from an American to AQ_Recruiter at gmail (where the owner of AQ_Recruiter logs in from Yemen via a series of proxies, the endpoint of which is wholly-domestic). I guarantee you that NSA wishes that problem was easy... they could pawn off the mere "domestic" stuff wholly on the FBI and focus on the "interesting" work of international spying and counter-terrorism (because again, in bizarro-world they aren't simply spying on people just because, but because they have a specific mission to attend to as directed by Congress and the DoD, which having to filter USPERS detracts from).
- jacquesm 13y ago> I guarantee you that NSA wishes that problem was easy... they could pawn off the mere "domestic" stuff wholly on the FBI and focus on the "interesting" work of international spying and counter-terrorism If that were true then http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction would not be part and parcel of this whole story.
- mpyne 13y agoParallel construction is much more relevant to things like DEA's SOD or the FBI itself though. In the NSA's heyday there was simply never a need for parallel construction as it wasn't as if they were going to be bringing up Soviet diplomats on indictments. They explicitly didn't touch people on American soil so the whole idea of 'chain of custody' was almost completely moot. Even now parallel construction is only a thing because it's that much easier for NSA to run across domestic communications commingled with international comms. Nowadays the analyst may see evidence of a major upcoming crime in the process of their actual duties, which puts you back in Churchill's Coventry quandry.
- jacquesm 13y ago(1) Churchill's Coventry quandary is a myth. See: http://theweek.com/article/index/237427/history-detective-did-churchill-sacrifice-a-city-to-protect-a-secret http://theweek.com/article/index/237427/history-detective-di... And lots of other places. (2) The NSA is way out of line in this respect and no matter how much they do/did it that stands and you should not apologize for it. If you do you are essentially advocating for broadening the official reach of the NSA's powers rather than to rein them in because they clearly can not stick to their mandate. The balance here is not to get to perfect security without privacy, the balance point is to get to an optimal level of security with a maximum of privacy. Anything less won't do, lest we all end telling another generation how terribly sorry we were. Power corrupts, it's never been any different historically.
- mpyne 13y ago
- anigbrowl 13y agoHowever, it is not within the NSA's authority to pursue criminal activity within the U.S. — they're only mandated to spy on communications between the U.S. and a foreign country, or entirely outside the U.S. Completely untrue. The NSA is in the business of gathering national foreign intelligence, which includes intelligence on the signals activity of foreign persons within the US. Suppose we know there are two Belgian spies in New York, are you telling me the NSA isn't allowed to listen into their conversations? Of course they are. This notion that they're not supposed to listen to any calls that begin and end within the US is just absurd. Foreign intelligence doesn't just encompass other places, it encompasses persons from those places who may be acting within the US. I can't believe I have to explain this. See http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/codification/executive-order/12333.html http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/codification/execut... 1.12b EDIT: It amuses me that people downvote posts with citations to primary sources. Have some more! Here's the definition of US persons (who the NSA is not supposed to spy on): http://www.nsa.gov/sigint/faqs.shtml#sigint4 http://www.nsa.gov/sigint/faqs.shtml#sigint4 per http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1801 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1801 which defines exactly who is a US person, an agent of a foreign power etc. basically, individuals who are citizens or hold green cards are US persons (also some associations and corporations, but you can read it yourself), any other individual is not regardless of whether they are in the US or not.
- greenyoda 13y agoAccording to Wikipedia: "NSA's domestic surveillance activities are limited by the requirements imposed by the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution; however, these protections do not apply to non-U.S. persons located outside of U.S. borders, so the NSA's foreign surveillance efforts are subject to far fewer limitations under U.S. law."[1] As you mentioned in another one of your comments, the Fourth Amendment applies in the U.S. even to people who are not U.S. Persons. So this would seem to imply that warrantless eavesdropping on people's communications within the U.S. by the NSA is not permissible. Also, regarding FISA: "In sum, a significant purpose of the electronic surveillance must be to obtain intelligence in the United States on foreign powers (such as enemy agents or spies) or individuals connected to international terrorist groups. To use FISA, the government must show probable cause that the “target of the surveillance is a foreign power or agent of a foreign power."[2] This does not seem to permit going after ordinary criminals such as drug dealers, and it does not seem to permit indiscriminate gathering of all internet communications (since there would be no probable cause for the vast majority of these communications). "Suppose we know there are two Belgian spies in New York, are you telling me the NSA isn't allowed to listen into their conversations?" Sure they are, if they go to the FISA court and get a warrant. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nsa#Domestic_activity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nsa#Domestic_activity [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Act_of_1978#Scope_and_limits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveilla...