2 ms·
This is completely the wrong direction for us to take. We cannot and should not be living in digital fortresses any more than we are living in physical fortress
by nkurz 13y ago
This is completely the wrong direction for us to take. We cannot and should not be living in digital fortresses any more than we are living in physical fortresses at home. Our homes are safe from thieves and from government not because they couldn’t get in if they wanted to but because the law and its enforcement prevents them from doing so. All we have to do is minimal physical security (lock the doors when you are out).
Perhaps as a result of growing up in places where locking doors is usually unnecessary, I've never quite understood this argument. If the basis for security is societal norm and legal enforcement, what's the significance of the locked versus unlocked door?
I feel like this attitude is usually an excuse to blame the victim, and disguises the fact that most people are more reliant on the lock than they wish to admit. When your locked car is broken into or stolen, the argument often quickly changes to point out your additional responsibility to use an alarm, a physical theft deterrent device, keep anything that might look valuable out of sight, carry appropriate insurance, and if possible avoid parking on the street.
I worry that the analogy between locked doors and encryption doesn't yield the conclusion the author draws. While in theory privacy can be maintained through change of law, in practice it may need to be guarded with measures appropriate to the level of security desired.