9 ms·
Hmmmm... I'm sure it'll need a linked scientific study to actually back up the claim. (And every speed-reading product I've seen has usually had a decrease in c
by crazygringo 13y ago
Hmmmm... I'm sure it'll need a linked scientific study to actually back up the claim. (And every speed-reading product I've seen has usually had a decrease in comprehension rate...)
It's a clever idea, but anecdotally, from my experience, I'm finding it slows down my reading -- I'm having a hard time processing the blurbs because I don't read "linearly" -- I scan content to find the relevant parts, and the color changes are making it difficult to scan (because my eye can no longer use color to determine what is scannable and what isn't), and multiple columns is actually making it even more difficult (it looks like the blue in column 1 leads into the blue in column 2, instead of the blue at the next line of column 1). By trying to force me to read line-by-line, instead of scanning efficiently, it's making me read slower.
But that's just for short-form stuff. It could turn out to be faster for some layouts, and slower for others. But honestly, I've never felt I had difficulty locating the start of the next line... is this a problem that needs solving? But nevertheless, it's certainly a good example of clever out-of-the-box thinking.
- gnicholas 13y agoA research lab at a well-known university has a study underway.
- johndavidback 13y agoI found my eyes 'jumping' from word to word. I didn't miss any, and I went to the correct lines, but I did seem to be reading at a much slower clip. But that's from spending 30 seconds reading the webpage, so not very scientific.
- bigiain 13y ago"Jumping from word to word" is a pretty slow way to read - "speed reading" involves chunking blocks of words or even entire lines - if you watch some people when speed reading their eyes don't scan left-right at all, but just stop briefly on each line as they scan down the page. I felt (without experimenting in a measurable way) that particularly the blue-red transitions _really_ slowed down my "normal" reading…
- thejacenxpress 13y agoI did find it easier to read faster, however I do believe the JFK portion was chunked with a lot of bigger words/data like years, cities, full names whereas the SBA paragraphs were simpler (IMHO).
- aquark 13y agoWould be great if they could A/B test the text used. I found the JFK portion harder to read/understand and I don't think it was entirely the colouring. Still, I think it is a cool idea and will give the bookmarklet a try for a while.
- gnicholas 13y agoThe reading test is randomized—different people get different stories in color or black. The order of black/color is also randomized. It's not perfect, but it'll have to hold us over until the larger study from the university research lab is completed.
- Blahah 13y agoIt might not be a problem for you - it isn't for me either - but many others suffer from this problem. My other half struggles to read because she has so many line transition errors. And she has to spend all day reading. I see a huge market for this.
- joering2 13y agoBut how you make money? Whatever they believe is patentable, I don't see it holds in the court. Good luck patenting colors of text. Further, the major places where you would see this going major: schools, libraries, law school, law field, etc, most of those places are extremely reluctant to new technologies. To them its not a matter of doing it better, its a matter of doing it the way we know how to do it and been doing for years. Lots of libraries still use typehead machines because those in charge are very old and don't trust/hate technology.
- Blahah 13y agoIt doesn't have to make money. Sometimes people do things for the benefit of others :) edit: although in this case, they have a patent pending and apps in development, and are offering licensing agreements.
- 3pt14159 13y agoI normally read around 600 to 1000 wpm (depending on how dense or vapid it is). This speeds up my reading wayyyyy past that. 1500 wpm? And I was barely trying. It does look super fucking ugly, but it totally works for me. They need to bring in an army of designers and make software geared towards legal assistants / lawyers because they need this desperately.
- bvi 13y agoWhat techniques do you use? I read at around 600wpm, and increasing it by 50-100% seems pretty daunting.
- jol 13y agoI trained a bit speed reading when I was in higschool from some book that was translated from Russian (sorry, no idea what was the book) the main idea there was to: 1) not saying words with inner voice 2) not reading letter by letter (seeing whole word at once) 3) reading by connected words not only word by word 4) there was eye training exercise, the idea was that you had to train vision a bit to be able to read more text with less eye movement, i.e. to read word by word you have to be able to see whole word at once (so your brain recognizes word with 1 lookup, not letter-by-letter lookup) whether this helped - I don’t now but that spreeder says that I can read more than 1500 wpm on casual texts (when there is a lot of material I want to realy comprehend, ofcourse it is slower even by factor of 3)
- anentropic 13y agoI have no idea what speed I read at but it's weird seeing this stated... I never imagined anyone but a 4 year old would do 1 and 2 and would have thought that 3 and 4 were basically just normal adult reading. I did read a lot when I was a kid
- 3pt14159 13y agoIt is a normal transition for childhoods filled with reading. I read about 10k pages a year until I graduated university. For a hacker, it is normal to not subvocalize. I think it is also one of the reasons that we hate meetings so much. An email can be written at about 40 wpm, and read much, much, much faster. So past 2 or 3 people, the dominant strategy should be text, unless sidechannel meaning is needed (where emotions are involved or whatever).
- cbsmith 13y agoI don't understand why you'd change foreground colours instead of background colours.... Either way, quick experiment shows it to be horrid for me.
- anotherbadlogin 13y agoAmen. The continued use of the asinine, glaring white background with dark text on it doesn't make sense. It's a failed product of the late-'80s/early-'90s "desktop publishing" fad in which developers sought to make the screen an analogy for a piece of paper. The error here is that a piece of paper doesn't EMIT light. Current default GUIs are the equivalent of reading text off the surface of a light bulb all day. Stupid. At least every GUI except the Mac's lets you set up a readable system-wide color scheme. Sadly, Microsoft's engineering has degraded to the point where they don't remember how simple color settings work; many of their UIs are unusable now because of hard-coded colors and invisible text: http://www.flickr.com/photos/forensicpics/5115887665/in/set-72157600304785497 http://www.flickr.com/photos/forensicpics/5115887665/in/set-...
- tomkarlo 13y agoThere's an existing, broadly used method for solving the line transition errors - you background color every two lines in an alternating set of colors. There used to be ribbon-feed printer paper pre-colored with this for certain applications that involve reading across lines a lot (like database output.) Seems like that is a more practical solution. Here's what I mean: http://www.stationerytrade.com/upfile/images/big/2012222111249256.jpg http://www.stationerytrade.com/upfile/images/big/20122221112... What about using eye tracking? A device could just detect you're at the end of a line, and put a small marker at the start of the next line.
- Groxx 13y agoI'm not aware of eye tracking setups that are reasonably priced and that accurate, but I like the idea quite a bit :) I'll have to test it out some time - should be relatively fake-able by just moving a marker up/down with keys.
- 13y ago
- saraid216 13y agoI suspect that there's a threshold effect going on: if you naturally read faster than a certain speed, certain design tricks will actually make you read even faster. If you naturally read slower, then those same tricks slow you down. Would love to see it confirmed or falsified. (As a note, I am probably under this hypothetical threshold; I'm not a slow reader, but I find that efforts to speed up my reading speed generally push it down instead.)
- cam_l 13y agoI cannot understand why it would slow you down, why do you think it might? Anyway, my experience from this is that it was much easier to differentiate, parse, and scan with the ugly colours (43% faster apparently). However, my natural slowness in reading is in both understanding and committing to memory. I get the feeling that this did not help much with regard to this..
- kellishaver 13y agoI cannot understand why it would slow you down, why do you think it might? For me, I found the changing color to be too distracting. My eye was constantly being drawn away from the text I was reading to another color on a line below or above. It may be worth noting that I only have one eye, and it's not a very good one - 20/100 visual acuity with about a 15deg. visual field.
- cam_l 13y agoAmazing, it had the exact polar opposite effect for my eyes. I often have trouble keeping my place in black and white text. I find it like trying to focus on a single conversation in a pub but I end up hearing everyone at once. If you don't mind me postulating, I wonder whether this difference is something intrinsic to the focussing effect of binocular vision, or if your field of view has maybe trained your brain to be more urgently perceptive to peripheral vision? then again, maybe its just colour perception.. or different strokes (and thanks, I just learnt about binocular summation.. fascinating)
- 13y ago
- mistercow 13y agoI don't think they're claiming this as a "speed reading" product in the traditional sense. They're saying it increases reading speed when reading the way most people do, which is line by line. It's certainly not likely to be useful for the kind of reading where you need to scan. But for fiction and other writing that is meant to be read linearly, the claims they're making seem plausible. What it doesn't help with is transposing from adjacent lines when reading the middle of a column, which happens to me all the time. The middle of the column is always black, so there's not much of a cue to keep you on the same line. In making my workaround to get a similar effect in calibre, I made a variation I much prefer which cycles red->green->blue, so that column centers are always easy to separate.
- marincounty 13y agoThat's a good idea. I have the same problem with fiction, for some reason--except for Nabokov. His books are written so well, each line just flows on to the next.
- mistercow 13y agoIf you're curious, this is what the end result looks like: http://i.imgur.com/NURV2N3.png http://i.imgur.com/NURV2N3.png, and if you use calibre, here's the CSS: https://gist.github.com/osuushi/6461324 https://gist.github.com/osuushi/6461324 You can change the font size and line height by a little bit without needing to adjust anything (since the color gradient is continuous vertically, it is a bit tolerand), but if you make a dramatic change, you'll need to adjust the background height from 72px to the height of three text lines.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gizmo686 13y agoFor large blobs of text, I wrap around to the wrong line often enough to be annoying. However, I found that highlighting my spot and re-highlighting every 5 lines or so solves this problem. Regarding your scanning approach. An idea I've had is to format each word based on how common it is.
- jotm 13y agoI was actually surprised at how good it was for linear reading - i.e. reading everything without skipping or missing any line. I'd use it for things like contracts and important tutorials/ebooks, where every word counts. But I agree that it sucks for quick scans - the different colors just add another layer of complexity for our brain to process...
- rejuvenile 13y agoPerhaps you would benefit from a scheme where each word were assigned a standardized color based on its hash.