That kind of preconceived notion isn't doing you any favors. I'll agree with you most of the time (DS was actually the first, and so far only game I played with

That kind of preconceived notion isn't doing you any favors. I'll agree with you most of the time (DS was actually the first, and so far only game I played with a controller), but just like keyboard + mouse is inherently a better control scheme for FPS or RTS games, a controller is simply a better option for a game like Dark Souls. That is the beauty of combat in Dark Souls: it's not mindless button mashing, and it's not about precision aiming. It's about timing, reading your opponent, thinking ahead, and getting the right rhythm - it's more like dancing than combat, really. On top of that each weapon feels different to the point where you choose to use the weapon that feels right for you, rather than based on stats. It's a bit difficult to explain why, but that connection is a lot harder to achieve on keyboard+mouse.