24 ms·
If Apple's hardware implementation is as good as my two year old Motorola Atrix, their customers will love the fingerprint reader. But I, for one, would never e
by leephillips 13y ago
If Apple's hardware implementation is as good as my two year old Motorola Atrix, their customers will love the fingerprint reader. But I, for one, would never entrust all my passwords to Apple's closed source software, especially given their record in the area of software quality control.
- epistasis 13y agoI currently do trust a good portion of my passwords to OS X's Keychain app, because based on my knowledge I'm fine with their record of software QC. What am I missing?
- TheRealWatson 13y agoJust look at the recent Developer site snafu. Or look at all the times their simple alarm clock choked on New Year's Day or leap years. Or even that hilarious bug where typing File:/// would crash almost all OSX and iOS apps.
- mturmon 13y agoReflexive HN "yes, but..." skepticism?
- jonknee 13y agoKeychain isn't an iCloud product like this password manager is. iCloud has been a QC fail since back when it was called iTools (in 2000!).
- leephillips 13y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4916627 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4916627
- epistasis 13y agoThank you for a thorough reply. IMHO, these bugs do not differ in severity or frequency when compared other closed source software vendors or from open source projects. The iCloud aspect does bother me quite a bit though, particularly when combined with likely NSA backdoors.
- leephillips 13y agoThe Finder bug I linked to actually deleted the source file before checking that it was moved successfully to the destination. The unix "mv" command predates the Finder by 30 years or so, and gets it right, of course. This is an elementary, student-level blunder that made it in to the Finder, the center of the user's interaction with the system. A lot of people lost a lot of data as this bug remained uncorrected for months. There were similar bugs in Mail, getting IMAP semantics wrong and deleting messages. Anyone who offers an assessment of Apple's software quality control at least needs to take this history into account. I'm sure that there are open source projects out there that are just as bad. I don't use those. The ones I do use, like mutt, don't contain this level of blunder. It's not that we should expect software to be free of bugs. It's just that the nature of these Apple bugs suggest a cavalier attitude to software quality and a severe lack of testing. Combine this with closed source and a critical security function, and you have an explosive mixture.
- mixmastamyk 13y ago... and government surveillance.