5 ms·
This oddly sounds like a death knell for Windows. I am not seeing anything here that is not in the LAMP / OSS stack as standard (graphite, nagios / Munin) If
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
This oddly sounds like a death knell for Windows. I am not seeing anything here that is not in the LAMP / OSS stack as standard (graphite, nagios / Munin)
If we rephrase the blog post as "we could not find any good tools in the Windows devops space so we wrote them" and add it to the departure of the only CEO willing to dance on stage chanting developers developers developers and Windows is not an ecosystem but a hub with a few brave outlying satellites.
I am impressed by the stacke change folks and their story and skills but it feels like amazing stories of software skill written for one company and never released in the open - it just leaves no legacy
- jc4p 13y agoWe (can I say we? I don't work on Windows stack stuff at here but whatever) are actually one of the biggest open source contributors in the .NET world, granted that's just my opinion and I don't have data behind it, but here's a list of things we've open sourced: http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2012/02/stack-exchange-open-source-projects/ http://blog.stackoverflow.com/2012/02/stack-exchange-open-so... MiniProfiler is my favorite one, and now exists in .NET, Ruby and Node.js due to my insanely smart co-workers.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoPlease don't take it as a criticism of your work - but the fact that one small company (<100?) that does OSS as a side effect (plus recruitment retention effort) can be one of the largest OSS contributors in the dotnet ecosystem says its not a vibrant and thriving ecosystem. SE has a very high reputation as far as I can tell so its not a quality issue - it is in this case a problem of quantity. As someone commented the idea is to focus on Azure and mobile - but that is no substitute for lots and lots of developers in a culture of releasing stuff outside their immediate company and so driving each other to new heights
- CodeCube 13y agoThe snowball has been growing here for the last few years. The .NET community was historically not very "open" ... but ever since nuget and github, attitudes have definitely been improving.
- avenger123 13y agoI definitely agree. The change has definitely slowed the tide of people wanting to move away from the platform. ASP.NET MVC has definitely been a big factor with this on the web development side.
- pnathan 13y agoIn my experience, Windows tooling for serious admin work is either terrible or massively expensive/enterprise. For instance, a key problem I had in a prior gig was that I needed to automatically log into a Windows machine, run a job, and then log out. Pretty bog standard; didn't need careful error recovery or anything particularly sophisticated. In Linux, you configure your SSH keys, then ssh automatedjob@server -c "./run-my-thing", and that's that. I literally could not find any identical analog in Windows besides telnet (if anyone knows of a solution here that approximates the Linux one for simplicity, I'd love to know about it). Today I'd probably just requisition a copy of a Windows SSH server and be done with the sorry mess. Better yet, throw Windows out and go full Linux. ;-)
- toyg 13y agoGoogle PsExec.
- dtauzell 13y agoYou can use remote powershell scripts to do the same. Configuring permissions is different, but is doable.
- mfenniak 13y agoA decent approach to doing this in the Windows world would be to use PsExec.exe (http://technet.microsoft.com/en-ca/sysinternals/bb897553.aspx http://technet.microsoft.com/en-ca/sysinternals/bb897553.asp...).
- pnathan 13y agoAh, PsExec. Yes, I reviewed that. However, the issue with PsExec has to do with credentials. If you don't bother with the user/password, it impersonates your account, which has certain restrictions[1]. That was not feasible due to most interesting things living on network drives. If you do bother with the username/password, you have to store those somewhere (remember, automated system). So now instead of running psexec directly, you have to have a tool that grabs the password file, hopefully decrypts it, then runs psexec. Also, iirc, using the psexec interface from Linux in a Linux->Windows connection does not work (a wrinkle in the original story is that it was a Linux->Windows connection). [1] http://windowsitpro.com/systems-management/psexec http://windowsitpro.com/systems-management/psexec
- thomaslangston 13y agoI can see how a developer outside of the Microsoft development stack could see it that way, but it is misinformed. Windows will die, to make way for Azure and Windows Phone. The Microsoft development ecosystem is strong (C# in top 10 of TIOBE index). It has open source released by Microsoft (ASP.NET MVC), 3rd parties (Mono by Xamarin), and the community (opensourcewindows.org). Microsoft includes open source libraries (jQuery) in their projects. StackExchange's software will leave a legacy. From the article: "In order to create more, and open source it we need help. So we are looking a full time developer with ops experience to join our SRE team."
- stevenjmurawski 13y agoThat's actually a very good point and a major downside to the open source tools. My whole work experience (and that of many sysadmins) is in primarily Windows shops. Since many of the OSS tools don't work or require hacks to make them work on Windows. As far as what we do at Stack, a lot of our code gets released. Not the core q&a engine, but our logging framework (StackExchange.Exceptional), a profiler (MiniProfiler), and some other stuff. On the sysadmin side, we are active in developing Desired State Configuration modules and contribute those to the PowerShell.org DSC repo on GitHub. Part of the job description for our SRE developer includes the fact that much of what we develop in house will be targeted to be open sourced.
- Joeri 13y agoThe miniprofiler was such an inspiration that i built the same thing for the PHP / ExtJS single page app that i work on. Now i can call up a floating window at any time listing all the recent network requests in the session, formatted much more appropriately than the browser's network view, and the database queries run for those requests, with timing and memory size info. Incredibly convenient while developing or debugging, and i doubt it would have happened if i hadn't seen the miniprofiler first.
- mjibson 13y agoYou should consider porting that to the official miniprofiler standard (https://github.com/miniprofiler/ui https://github.com/miniprofiler/ui). We want ports in other languages, and php would be welcome. You just have to make the backend, frontend is done and documented above.