2 ms·
The system has almost always worked as intended: the Government is formed in the House, which has the monopoly on questions of supply. Because the House is sing
by jacques_chester 13y ago
The system has almost always worked as intended: the Government is formed in the House, which has the monopoly on questions of supply. Because the House is single-member electorates, there has been a clear majority in every election except for 2, including this outgoing Parliament.
The Senate doesn't form the government and cannot originate supply bills, but otherwise has coequal legislative powers. It is elected on a proportional basis.
The system works well because a government can normally form quickly and govern stably, but in order to pass legislation it must give consideration to minority parties in the Senate. You get an Executive that can execute but which must nevertheless be prepared to compromise.
- jsmeaton 13y agoGood points, thanks for that. I guess I have thought about the minority government a little too much when it is an anomaly. I have no problems with the senate. I vote for minority parties (Sex Party last election and this one) because I want protection from the government when required.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI basically miss the Democrats. It's a pity that Stott-Despoja killed them by zagging left.
- nl 13y ago"The Democrats died because they zagging left" narrative is one I've heard before, but it doesn't match the facts. The fall of the Democrat vote mirrors the rise of the Greens vote, and the Greens are way more left leaning than the Democrats ever were. I think their demise had more to do with internal infighting and the Andrew Bartlett drunk in the senate debacle. But yes, I miss them too - they were basically a sensible party who wouldn't do stupid things.
- jacques_chester 13y agoWhen she took the party left, the Greens were already outflanking them. Zagging left cost them the votes they got from Liberal voters. And that was that.