3 ms·
I think one of the most important takeaways from this article is that you can fix this problem, for your own family, now. Homeschooling is legal in all 50 US st
by benaiah 13y ago
I think one of the most important takeaways from this article is that
you can fix this problem, for your own family, now. Homeschooling is
legal in all 50 US states and in a number of other countries [1] - Gray
mentions it in the article as an alternative. It works, and it's not
as impossible as you likely think.
Historically, homeschooling is probably the most common form of
education - the modern style of compulsory, state-run education traces
back to the Prussian education system of the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries.
Anecdotally, I can attest to its strength: I'm a second-generation
homeschooled student, currently pursuing a BS in Computer Science. I
graduated with a 3.95 GPA, got a 96th percentile SAT score, and made
it to the top level (Finalist) of the National Merit Scholarship
program. I'm using a scholarship I got because of that to go through
school.
Without homeschooling, I doubt I would have got into computers and
programming. I had the freedom and the time to pursue what I wanted to
do - it didn't feel like school, because it wasn't, but it was just
as, perhaps more, important than my standard academics. I started
teaching myself programming when I was 12, essentially on my own. I
started by just creating games, but eventually got bored of that and
moved into programming more general-purpose stuff. I basically taught
myself, with oversight to make sure I was actually doing it, through
the middle school - high school level.
The oldest of my brothers will also be graduating soon. He's totally
different from me - loves the outdoors and wants to go into
smoke-jumping. He dislikes academics, book-learning, and the technical
side of computers, for the most part. Certainly doesn't pursue those
things for fun. He was 86th percentile on his SATs.
We were both (along with our six other younger siblings) taught by our
mom, who has very little education beyond a high school diploma (don't
get me wrong - she's very smart, just not academically
well-credentialed). She taught us alone, while living in a remote part
of a remote state. Our social interaction was almost entirely in the
church or the occasional homeschooling group. I'm a bit introverted,
but my brother is an extrovert, and as socially well-adjusted as they
come. Academically, we're both well prepared for life.
I know anecdotes aren't data, but I'm simply trying to make the point
that it is reasonable and effective to teach your children at home. It
doesn't take a college degree, teacher training, or a state program
(our homeschool was entirely private). It takes love and hard work -
but it provides a safe environment, cultures a love of learning, and
gives academic excellence: all tasks that the public schools have
proven themselves incapable of in most cases.
[1]: For more info on the legality of homeschooling, see
http://hslda.com http://hslda.com
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoWell you might be some kind of child prodigy or something but I admonish you to take your impressive brain and set it upon basic statistics. If you do, I think you will see that you are describing (i.e. your experience) is anomalous phenomena. Most home schoolers are out there solving Fermat's Last Conjecture at age 8. Autodidacts (even alleged ones) in this kind of discussion always try to project their Einstein level of genius on to the rest of the population to make some point about how education should be. I think it misses pretty obvious points.
- benaiah 13y agoYou're missing my point - I'm no genius, just a bit academically oriented. My brother is the complete opposite - yet he still is far above what the public schools are pushing out. My younger siblings seem to be turning out the same way. And I can personally attest to many other families that have had similar results. You want statistics, here they are: http://www.hslda.org/docs/news/200908100.asp http://www.hslda.org/docs/news/200908100.asp Homeschooled students score into the 84th-89th percentile on average. Statistically, it's unambiguously better at educating children. My comment was anecdotal on purpose, to try to show that, even in an extreme case (remote location, little social contact, mom had no college degree, no state homeschooling assistance) it still produces vastly better results than the public schools.