5 ms·
1. There is no one-size-fits-all plan that could possibly work for education. Everyone is different (duh) Why is that? All able-bodied humans have brains, mou
by rwmj 13y ago
1. There is no one-size-fits-all plan that could possibly work for education. Everyone is different (duh)
Why is that? All able-bodied humans have brains, mouths, eyes, arms etc all of which work in much the same way. If you are making clothing, you don't say "everyone is different", you make clothes based on the same pattern in a relatively small range of sizes.
For people who have specific disabilities, we should make adjustments, but I don't understand why a single way of teaching would not work for most people. Leaving aside whether schools are the best way of teaching.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIf you are making clothing, you don't say "everyone is different", you make clothes based on the same pattern in a relatively small range of sizes. Then why do the rich buy custom-tailored clothes?
- anigbrowl 13y agoBecause they can pay the substantial premium involved. Collectively, our interest in having as many people as possible moderately well-educated rather than just having a few who are outstandingly well-educated imposes constraints.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoour interest in having as many people as possible moderately well-educated rather than just having a few who are outstandingly well-educated I am compelled to note that our existing socioeconomic, and thus educational, systems operate pretty much the other way around: the revealed judgment of capitalism is that it's better to have a small elite of outstandingly well-educated rich people who can confidently exploit the mob of mostly ignorant masses.
- penrod 13y agoWhy do you think that an educational system run by central government and funded by taxes represents the revealed judgement of capitalism?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoTwo reasons: 1) Because the same effect and the same processes are displayed at the post-secondary level where capitalist forces operate more strongly than social-democratic ones. 2) Because the capitalists control the government, at this point, so government action is a good indicator of what the capitalist class thinks is best.
- RougeFemme 13y agoAnd there will be many people for whom those clothes don't really fit (feel, appearance, etc.). A lot of people will simply make do. But many other will alter the clothing or switch to tailor-made clothing. . .or a different pattern with a different range of sizes.
- GuiA 13y agoThis is a misleading and irrelevant comparison. Yes, the vast majority of the population has 2 arms, 2 legs, etc. that allow enable clothes manufacturers to follow the same template. But this definitely does not imply that this conclusion is extensible to education. Have you ever worked in a software development company? You've probably noticed that some of your coworkers work better by being isolated and solving things on their own. Others prefer teaming up with a more experienced developer to guide their work. Some need a very detailed spec upfront, while others are fine filling in the holes as they go along. Would you force the guy who thrives while doing pair programming to work on his own? Sure, he might get some work done, but he won't be as happy nor as productive as he is pair programming. And the kicker is that those things change throughout people's careers. Education is exactly the same. You can force everyone in the same mold, but all it will lead to is people performing sub optimally and becoming frustrated. Should education ignore that? --- It's even worth it to take a step back and ask ourselves what the goal of school education should be. The average parent or teacher will probably answer that it is to develop the child's skills and knowledge in a way that will enable him to attend a good college, to secure a good job, and to live their life comfortably. The more we advance in society, the more we realize that this definition was perhaps sufficient 50 years ago (when it was very common and accepted to stop your studies after high school), but it is becoming less and less so. As our society starts to be comfortable with notions such as minimum basic income, that many jobs can and should be automated, that there will inevitably be more able-minded able-bodied adults than there are jobs available in the future and so on, we need to revisit what the purpose of education from ages ~3-18 should be. Things we probably want education "of the future" to be about: - creating citizens that have the means and the tools to instruct themselves and understand the world and society around them - enabling the children and teenagers to build & live a fulfilling and constructive adult life (we might have to accept at some point that some people are fine playing the saxophone 10 hours a day, while some are fine programming 10 hours a day - one is not necessarily better than the other) - building the skills to relate to your peers and help them to work towards the previous 2 points. Having worked in educational settings (think boarding school style, with everyday life mixed with instruction) where teenagers would be in regular contact with younger children (for example helping them during programming workshops etc.), I've noticed how much good it does to everyone involved. The younger kids love having someone just a tiny bit older than they are helping them out, and a lot of teenagers appreciate being handed some responsibilities. The current school system is very much a one way street (teachers teach and enforce rules, students sit down and listen), and it's far from ideal.
- penrod 13y agoThere may indeed be a Platonic ideal of the one-size-fits-all school, but does not mean it is discoverable by central planners, especially central planners subject to the political incentives of the education establishment. So even though "Everyone is different" may be a canard, it may still be the case that the only practical way to improve schools is through a distributed process of trial and error on a diverse set of teaching methods.
- wmeredith 13y agoHoly hell, if you think people brains all work in the same way, you live in a different world than mine.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoFor people who have specific disabilities, we should make adjustments, but I don't understand why a single way of teaching would not work for most people. Most Africans have an IQ in the 80s, barely above mentally retarded. Most of them can barely be trained to even go through the motions of algebra, let alone use it to solve problems in new situations. "College material" kids need to graduate high school with a mastery of algebra so they can learn calculus, which they will be expected to use unbidden to solve novel problems they encounter in other areas. It seems unlikely to me that the vocational training of the dull can be combined with the education of the near-genius. It is like trying to teach carpentry and structural engineering at the same time. Kids also have a gigantic range of self control. About 1 in 20 are profoundly delayed, being an average of 3 years behind "normal" in planning and self control. (This is called ADHD to pathologize it, but nothing that common can possibly be a true disorder.) So a typical freshman high school classroom will have pne student who can barely keep their shit together well enough to glue macaroni to construction paper. And will have one student, usually a girl, who operates on a fully adult level. And then there are the variations in memory. One student learns the entire course in 20 hours, while another has to grind out practice for 150 hours. There is simply no way for a single process to handle the range of human variation well. Even the body is like this. My ideal bicycle could permanently cripple another normal person of the same height. Ditto for shoes.
- jacalata 13y agouh, do you care to give a citation for that 'most africans' claim? Are you talking about people living in Africa, or about African-Americans?
- aperrien 13y ago> Most Africans have an IQ in the 80s, barely above mentally retarded. Most of them can barely be trained to even go through the motions of algebra, let alone use it to solve problems in new situations. What evidence do you have for this claim?
- batemanesque 13y agoare you fucking serious?
- aestra 13y ago>If you are making clothing, you don't say "everyone is different", you make clothes based on the same pattern in a relatively small range of sizes. Oh wow, you must have a common body shape/type. That range of sizes is actually kinda large, and there is "specialty" size ranges, for example, plus size, petite, big and tall. Bras especially have a giant range of sizes, and I still know woman who have to get custom made bras, and these are woman with natural breasts. I personally don't fit into off the shelf clothing, period. I've never seen a pair of pants that fit me, I just make due with what is closest, and I've gotten used to constantly adjusting my pants, it is second nature to me.