3 ms·
It is easy to tell if there is a shortage of ANY commodity, including workers, from the price. This is one of the most basic principles of capitalism. Similarly
by gaius 13y ago
It is easy to tell if there is a shortage of ANY commodity, including workers, from the price. This is one of the most basic principles of capitalism. Similarly it is easy to tell if there is an oversupply, the price goes down... Which matches the observations of the state of the industry (allowing for inflation)?
- AnIrishDuck 13y agoThis is not true. There are many different types of information encoded in a market clearing price (supply of inputs, the supply of inputs to their inputs, utility of the output, economies of scale, etc). You can't say that e.g. a rise in the price of pencils means it's "easy to tell" there's a shortage of pencils. It could mean that: 1) more people are getting better utility from pencils. 2) pencils are getting harder to produce at the current scale. 3) an input supply to pencil construction is rising in price Applying these lessons back to the market for developers, it's pretty easy to see parallels to ALL three of the above scenarios. Which explains the rising price. Unless you're using the word "shortage" to mean "you can't get what you want at the price you want", in which case the statement is almost tautologically true.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gaius 13y agoThat is the way it is being used in this context, as in companies saying "I can't get an experienced developer for the price of a new graduate".
- EliRivers 13y agoThis is one of the most basic principles of capitalism. And, like many basic economic principles, only works in the artificial environment of a fictional, deliberately simplified economy. House prices, for example, have a very strong dependency on the cost (and availability) of credit; people will spend as much money as the bank is willing to lend them. Turn on credit, price of houses goes up. Close off credit, price of houses goes down. This is but one example of many; the extraordinarily simple model of a commodity price, "supply and demand", is not inherently wrong, but is so simple that to rely on it alone in the complex economy we have is wrong.
- don_draper 13y agoI don't know what you are talking about. If there is a shortage in housing, prices go up; if there is an oversupply, prices go down. Credit affects what people can afford and plays a factor, but the basic rules of economics are very much in play with housing.
- EliRivers 13y agoI don't know what you are talking about. I'm talking about the fact that to apply the extraordinarily simple supply and demand model to the price of houses, and expect it to work, is wrong. Other factors are more important. If we were talking about something very cheap and fungible, it would be far more applicable. We're talking about houses. The majority of people cannot afford to buy a house. They don't have enough money. If there was no credit, we'd see a simple supply/demand model at work; I could take 20 percent off the cost of houses, and most people still wouldn't be able to buy them because they don't have enough money, but a few more would be able to, so the demand (or rather, the number of people who want one and can now buy one) would increase. However, there is credit. If I added 20 percent to the price and also arranged to lend people enough money to buy the newly expensive houses, they would sell. If I doubled house prices and lent people the money, they'd still sell. The price of houses is so dependent on the availability of credit that it swamps the simple supply and demand model. Credit doesn't just play a factor; it's the majority of it. They're also a veblen good; the simple supply and demand idea that as prices go up, the demand will drop, isn't just wrong - it's the complete opposite. As prices go up, people want them more; they fear that if they don't buy one now, it'll cost them more in the future ("don't miss the boat" is what often gets trotted out during the housing booms) and/or they think of it as some kind of investment and think they'll make more money since they're going up. The simple model that prices going up leads to demand going down is inverted. This works as they go down in price too; as prices drop, demand drops. Nobody wants to borrow money against something that will soon be worth less than they owe on it. Dropping prices cause their own positive feedback, every drop pushing demand lower, in turn dropping prices further and amplifying the effect; classic boom and bust behaviour. Houses are a veblen good, dependent on the availability of credit to buy. Simple supply and demand is utterly swamped. Look at the last housing boom (and indeed, the ones before it). Was there a massive reduction in the number of houses available? No; in fact, many housing companies were building them as fast as they could and the supply was increasing even as prices bubbled beyond sanity. Did hordes of people who had been living on the streets suddenly decide they wanted to live in houses? No. It was people suddenly able to buy one because someone was willing to lend them the money.
- skylan_q 13y agoAnd as far as I'm concerned, there's an oversupply as long as I'm competing for any job with anyone.