3 ms·
Again: that's quite correct, but the issue is that my view on compulsory schooling (at least, as we currently have it) has held up for another ten years after t
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
Again: that's quite correct, but the issue is that my view on compulsory schooling (at least, as we currently have it) has held up for another ten years after that and even proven persuasive to my parents.
Read the rest of the comment. I dropped out of high school at 16, then went to university at 18, graduated university with honors, and have now worked in the tech industry and started graduate school at an elite institution. And I honestly don't think I could have done any of it if I'd stayed in high school.
On top of my own example, my fiancee is one of the people the article mentions as being brilliant, obedient, excellent little students who find themselves completely and utterly burned-out by the whole process.
- candybar 13y agoThe system isn't designed to maximize your personal well-being. Your extrapolation from "this was good for me" to "we should have everyone do it" is troubling.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoExcept that's the opposite of the inference I made. My reasoning is, "If I'm an exception, then other people might be too, so the system broadly should be less uniform." Whereas you seem to be defending a system that focuses, above all else, on uniformity. The system isn't designed to maximize your personal well-being. That would imply the system gives a damn about well-being of anyone, whatsoever, at all, so it's pretty obviously wrong.
- candybar 13y agoBy that standard, you're an exception that the system successfully accommodated. So what's the problem? I'm also going to guess that you've taken advantage of help from tons of people that the system has successfully placed around you to help you. I may not have needed high school education, but it's quite unlikely that I haven't benefited dramatically from a system that gives everyone high school education. At some point, you have to stop whining from a personal sense of being wronged and start asking how you can help.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoBy that standard, you're an exception that the system successfully accommodated. No, I'm an exception who the system made miserable, at extra cost and burden to itself, for 10 years until its rules finally allowed me to leave. I spent an actual post elsewhere specifically making suggestions for what I think would make a better system for everyone, not just myself. It starts with: 1) Let people make choices for themselves. 2) Hit them with the natural consequences of their own choices as soon as possible. Don't make any effort to delay consequences; instead, hasten them. 2a) It's ok to soften the consequences for children when they make a mistake. What psychological studies show is that sure and consistent consequences are better at training behavior than more extreme consequences that arrive unsurely and inconsistently. 3) Actually attempt to reason with people, including children. Children are foolish, but not stupid. The more you reason with them, the more they learn to use reason with people. The less you reason them, the more they learn to manipulate and exploit people. 4) Make sure your kids know what the adult world really is. They don't have to like it, since most adults don't, and knowing that it sucks earlier on will help them develop the moral fiber to fix it. 5) Teach your kids ("your" referring to any parent or teacher or adult in general) useful stuff that will help them when they become adults.
- candybar 13y agoThis isn't even remotely coherent from a policy perspective. You couldn't even handle schooling as a child because somehow you weren't handled in some special way and couldn't do what you wanted to do, but now you think somehow all parents must act in a specific way that you prescribe? What if they refuse? Why should they follow any of this? Maybe they are all special too? So your "system" is hoping that parents follow some random set of rules that you came up with, having, let me guess, zero parenting experience? Do you really feel that behind all this lies your incredible concern for the world's children?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIt's not even a system of rules. It's a basic principle: children need to become adults, so make them get on with it. Would you like me to post a mathematically formalized educational policy next, or will you perhaps switch to conversing rather than attacking?