3 ms·
However MIT didn't achieve its current ratio without significantly watering down the core requirements everyone has to pass. This started before the '80s, and
by hga 13y ago
However MIT didn't achieve its current ratio without significantly watering down the core requirements everyone has to pass. This started before the '80s, and it didn't ruin the Institute's reputation, but it had some clear effects.
On the other hand, there is only one MIT, and the intense self-selection that occurs before anyone applies has allowed it to get away with all sorts of stupid admissions tricks going back many decades. E.g. for a long time it didn't have a professional running the office.
- rayiner 13y ago"Watering down" also presupposes some sort of "neutral" baseline. Point 3 from the article: "Early in the curriculum freshmen learned about various areas of research, which introduced them to the broad potential impact of the field. New classes focused on how computer science could impact society. “Technology Consulting in the Community,” for example, provided opportunities for students to help non-profits solve real-world technical problems." That's not "watering down" to me. That's providing students with useful context about their chosen field and giving them hands-on experience.
- hga 13y agoI was only talking about what happened at MIT; the brutal class of 2004 4 year graduation result suggests there might not have been significant watering down in CMU's CS department.
- hga 13y agoForgot to add: For much of MIT's core curriculum there is a "neutral" baseline, the calculus, the AP BC sequence in the 1st term, and what's beyond that in the 2nd term, and calculus based mechanics and E&M. In the case of 1st term calculus, that's been well established for decades (AP wasn't offered in my high school, and the 1st term of the calculus I the fall of 1979 covered the current BC topics).
- rayiner 13y agoSo this will be heresy to some, but here goes: Calculus, mechanics, E&M, etc, are important. No doubt. But the typical first year engineering curriculum, which revolves around these subjects, is needlessly decoupled from what engineers actually do for a living. I was an aerospace major, and it wasn't until my third or fourth year that we actually got some idea of what it was to like to be an aerospace engineer! And that was only because I did some jet turbine design competitions as electives! Now, imagine you're a woman entering such a program. You're not sure if you belong in the program to begin with, because after all how many women aerospace engineers do you know? Then you spend your entire first year down in the weeds doing a bunch of math, and at the end of it you don't have any better of an idea as to whether this is something you can do for a living. If you're a guy, you face the same challenges, but at least you have the comfort of knowing that it's a path well-trodden for people like yourself. You can look to your professor or someone you know in industry and say "well he did it and got through it and likes his job." Once you get into industry, of course, it's not like whether you got a 95 or an 85 on the deformable bodies exam determines whether you're going to contribute the most to your team. Those skills are important, but they're just a part of the skill set that makes for an effective engineer. And we don't teach any of those skills in the first-year curriculum nor do we reinforce to students the fact that those other skills will be highly valued once they enter the workforce. So what you see as "watering down" the curriculum, I see as excising the "onions in the varnish" to use pg's terminology. The first year of engineering school shouldn't be an exercise in rewarding the people who "get" the material most naturally, which is what it often turns into. It should be teaching fundamental skills and helping students develop a big-picture view of what the profession entails. That means teaching calculus and E&M, sure, but I think it should also encompass things like the projects highlighted in the article (hands-on exercises working in teams), and also include teaching skills like communications and teamwork that are in the real world every bit important as the mathematical skills.
- hga 13y agoI would only consider it heresy if you insisted MIT (and Caltech) change their approach, there's room in the world for many variations. Although MIT has a strong communications requirement which is generally satisfied with one communications intensive course per year, so freshmen will normally get started on that (I assume freshman advisers enforce this).
- Anechoic 13y agobut it had some clear effects Such as?
- tzs 13y agoHow about Caltech's approach? They didn't change their admission standards. Instead, they concentrated heavily on getting more qualified women to apply, and on getting those that applied and were accepted to come. Essentially, they recruited women into the application process the way schools with effective sports teams recruited star high school athletes (except there were no special scholarships or thinly disguised bribes). Once the application hit the admission committee, though, it was treated like all the others.
- hga 13y agoI really don't know. It's even more of a special case than MIT, being the world's top science school and less than 1/4 of MIT's size. So filling out a freshman class of ~250 students with truly qualified women is going to be easier. Last time I checked they hadn't relaxed their requirements, upped them in fact from 1979, you must know single variable calculus vs. having a chance to learn it there (AP is much more widespread), and you're asked to start on Apostol, although you can later take an applied track. And the math requirement is longer, including e.g. deferential equations. From everything I've gathered it's quite a different place, and if you get in there's more support (it's been in all seriousness compared to Hogwarts compete with dorm room cleanup service, minus of course the Deatheaters and impossible teachers), which you can much more easily do at its scale.