6 ms·
Seems to me, if you're building a building primarily out of glass, you'd want to study the impact of the glare. There is a hotel in Las Vegas that has a similar
by moron4hire 13y ago
Seems to me, if you're building a building primarily out of glass, you'd want to study the impact of the glare. There is a hotel in Las Vegas that has a similar problem. How can these building projects get approved, through so many people, and nobody once stops to think about the glare problem?
- mrcharles 13y agoThe hotel in Vegas was built with a special film on the glass to reduce the glare by 70%. So they were obviously studying it/thinking about it. But if 70% is not enough, imagine if they had actually done nothing? http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/vdara-visitor-death-ray-scorched-hair http://www.reviewjournal.com/news/vdara-visitor-death-ray-sc...
- sschueller 13y agoEspecially if the building is going to be curved!
- mikeash 13y agoAs I pointed out in another thread about this story, the basic concept has been around since at least Ancient Greece, so, how stupid do you have to be to construct a giant curved glass structure and not consider that it might burn things?
- jacobparker 13y ago- Is that a serious question? - Have you ever been part of a group that made a (complicated) mistake? You gain nothing by deluding yourself about the intelligence of an imaginary person (there is no "you") Try being less negative.
- mikeash 13y agoYes, it's a serious question. My point is that this is not a "complicated" mistake. It's a very, very simple mistake. You're building a curved, reflective surface. First question should be, "what happens when the sun hits it?" Edit: as another commenter pointed out, this isn't even the first time this architect has designed a building that burns things by focusing the sun: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6327766 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6327766 Still think my question is bad? Still think this is a "complicated" mistake?
- jacobparker 13y agoWhy do you think that they didn't think about it? That's pretty silly. I'm guessing that you haven't built tall buildings before (I certainly haven't) but it seems perfectly plausible to me that precautions were taken (coating/shape/etc.) but for various unexpected reasons they were insufficient. Smart people make big things and big things can have big mistakes. It's sad that its so easy for some people to invent unintelligent straw-men to mock in internet comments.
- mikeash 13y agoThere's simply no room for the scenario you're proposing. The math of curved reflectors is reasonably simple. What kind of "unexpected reasons" could possibly cause this problem? Maybe this guy did think about it. Maybe he's not stupid? But that's worse for him, because it means he knew what would happen and didn't care. This is on about the same level as dropping a piano from the top of the building and crushing whatever was below at the time. It's so basic that there's no way to say that it was unforeseeable, so either the person dropping the piano failed to think about gravity, or they didn't care about the damage they did.
- mbq 13y agoFun fact: this hotel, Vdara, and 20 Fenchurch Street 'fryscraper' were both designed by the same architect, Rafael Viñoly.
- jameshart 13y agoIt's less of a systemic problem with architects in general, more of a specific issue for one architect in particular: Rafael Viñoly (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rafael_Vi%C3%B1oly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rafael_Vi%C3%B1oly). He designed the Vdara hotel in Vegas that had a concave facade which melted sunloungers; and he's also responsible for the "Walkie Talkie" building in London which we're discussing here. It's almost as if he has a blindspot when it comes to this problem. Maybe he looked at one of his own buildings too long.
- gaius 13y agoNo, it is a systemic problem. If a civil engineer routinely designed building that bits fell off and destroyed parked cars, he'd lose his license to practice! Where's the Guild of Architects when you need them?
- option_greek 13y agoShouldn't the building require a review by the engineers after it is designed by the architect ?
- willyt 13y agoYes, in fact the cladding system will have been designed by specialist facade engineers, so they are probably at least partly to blame for this.
- willyt 13y agoWhat, you mean like the civil engineer who designed the wobbly bridge? [0] Even though the phenomenon of synchronised footsteps causing large oscillations due to positive feedback is well enough known that there is another bridge in London built over 150 years earlier which has a sign on it saying 'Soldiers marching across this bridge must break step'. I don't like the 'walkie talkie' and I'm not a fan of gesture architects like Vinoly, Libeskind, Ghery etc. But, there are plenty of other far less obtuse critiques of this kind of architecture than 'GOD you forgot to model the solar rays on the 3rd of September 2013, you IDIOT!!!'. People do make mistakes, including engineers. And, by the way, the engineer who designed the wobbly bridge is still very highly regarded in the profession. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Bridge,_London http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Bridge,_London Edit: corrected grammar and moved sentence to clarify.
- VLM 13y agoI've noticed that architects, at least below median architects, generally ignore the effect of sunlight on their designs. You'd think their profession would have noticed its importance at some point in the last twenty five centuries, but its apparently beneath them to care. This is a huge problem in many office buildings I've worked in. Lets align the desks so no one can see anything due to the glare in the afternoon (LOL better yet if no blinds/shades for artistic stylistic reasons) Hmm, putting a big monitor in the conference room? Eh who cares if no one can see it due to the sun. It would be like mech eng pretending column buckling doesn't exist, or programmers pretending users never make data entry errors.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThe days of the Vitruvian virtues have long since passed, friend. It doesn't matter if a building is useful. What matters is that it is a monument to cooperative egocentricity: the architect's and the commissioner's.
- mikeash 13y ago"It would be like... programmers pretending users never make data entry errors." I think I've spotted a problem!
- jessaustin 13y agoI've noticed that architects, at least below median architects, generally ignore... It's my experience that most architects, and certainly most "below median" architects, only ever design one building. Everything they design is a variation on the same theme, whether it's a bank or a house or a library (and certainly if it's the ninth house they've designed this year). Their theme might evolve slowly over time, but it's rare to find an architect capable of producing actually-new work based only on the client's wishes and the requirements of construction. This is why you're best off finding an architect whose buildings you like rather than trying desperately to convince any particular architect to change her style. So, if most feasible designs do not have this light-focusing property, most architects will never run into the problem. However, an uncreative architect who does somehow produce this effect, may be expected to do so repeatedly. Hmmm, that seems to accord with the record here.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kamkha 13y agoThe situation is even more amazing than you think. That Las Vegas hotel you mention was designed by the same firm [1][2]. [1] http://www.rvapc.com/works/707-20-fenchurch-street http://www.rvapc.com/works/707-20-fenchurch-street [2] http://www.rvapc.com/works/index/691-vdara-hotel--spa-at-citycenter-las-vegas http://www.rvapc.com/works/index/691-vdara-hotel--spa-at-cit...