3 ms·
A certain amount of arrogance can be a useful thing and a lot of really smart people are also arrogant, but I would be very careful about using it as a sign of
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
A certain amount of arrogance can be a useful thing and a lot of really smart people are also arrogant, but I would be very careful about using it as a sign of people who are likely to have good ideas, or who deserve any sort of deference. There are much better things to go by, and much worse things to mock.
How about we leaving mocking people to other folks, then? Quite frankly I could care less if Wolfram gets along with his scientific peers, is a genius, is an idiot, is nice to strangers, or kicks his dog around at night. Let's just assume he is an intelligent person acting as best he can. If one of us gets to know him, and thinks he has some kind of personality problem, then by all means take him out and have a talk.
This is not giving people the benefit of the doubt. Even if Wolfram is all the bad things people are saying here, it doesn't matter. If you can't find it in your heart to give somebody the benefit of the doubt, just treat them decently. Even arrogant jerks can be treated with respect.
Am I missing something here? Because it sounding a lot to me like you're making the case "yeah, but he's a really bad jerk, and it isn't so bad to pick on those"
But that can't be right, can it? Because labels like "really bad jerk" can easily be stretched to fit lots of people.
I'm done here. I had no intention of defending Wolfram, only common sense. Perhaps tomorrow there will be some new really bad person that we can throw stones at. But we'll be sure first that they're really bad.
- michael_nielsen 17y agoThe people who care the most are people in fields adjacent to what Wolfram works on. They have an excellent reason to care: Wolfram has appropriated many things they've been saying far longer than he. Since their livelihood depends on their reputation for discovery, it's easy to see why they get annoyed and upset.
- arakyd 17y agoCriticizing people for all sorts of valid reasons and treating them decently are not mutually exclusive. You don't have to know someone personally in order to give a fair critique of their published ideas, or to know that the reason they sued you was stupid. Not everything is a personal attack (and you seem to take criticism of Wolfram more personally than he does. Note that this is an observation, and not intended as a personal attack on you!). Again, I'm only defending the criticisms that I've read, which do not include Hecker's. They seem fair to me.