3 ms·
This conversation is done. Feel free to reply to this in any way you like, I'm not going to bother replying again. I am confident that anyone passing can make
by btilly 13y ago
This conversation is done. Feel free to reply to this in any way you like, I'm not going to bother replying again. I am confident that anyone passing can make their own mind up about our discussion.
For review, here are the basic facts.
You have repeatedly failed to acknowledge that you can get definitive yes/no answers from questions of the type, "What does this theory predict for this situation?" You have repeatedly failed to acknowledge that this type of reasoning is part of the process of doing physics.
You have repeatedly sidetracked to lectures on falsification where you ascribe all sorts of random beliefs to me that I do not, in fact, possess. There is a certain irony to you lecturing on falsification and the behavior of scientists, while refusing the acknowledge that the example of Fred Hoyle never accepting the Big Bang throws a wrench in your description. No, it is worse. You claimed that Fred Hoyle "gave way before falsifiable evidence" when, in fact, few knew that evidence better than he, and he never "gave way". (Instead he continued to adhere to steady state models which had tunable parameters that could continue to explain the evidence. A good Popperian would say that such tunable models cannot be part of science. At which point any historian of science should give a big belly laugh because they are.)
Now you say that, I'm accustomed to having discussions with people who can't be bothered to examine their own ideas. Is that because they can't be bothered to examine their own ideas, or because you fail to recognize that they have?
I will leave you with some interesting examples to ponder.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_anomaly http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pioneer_anomaly for a well-known experiment which appeared to falsify basic theories of physics for over a decade before the source of experimental error was definitively tracked down. When experiments can be reconciled indefinitely with theory by assuming experimental error, what experiment can conclusively falsify theory?
Does this actually happen? I give you the example of Barbara McClintock. From the 1930s until the 1970s she carried on a line of research that falsified the developing genetic theory. As a result she was marginalized and her work generally ignored until, as a result of other developments, it became apparent in the 1970s that she was right. Then she was awarded the Nobel in Medicine for some of her discoveries from the 1950s. (See http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/medicine/laureates/1983/press.html http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/medicine/laureates/19... for the press release. The final paragraph is an acknowledgement of her situation.)
If scientists actually worked through falsification, then they should have been all over her reproducible experiments decades earlier. That they didn't, stands as falsification of the theory that scientists proceed through falsification!
But anyways, we're done. Hopefully at some point you reconsider your overly simplistic view of actual science. But I have reached my tolerance for continuing this discussion.