2 ms·
Because unless they're democratic, they're no true Scotsman right? I guess my problem is that whenever examples are provided which contradict the model as you
by westicle 13y ago
Because unless they're democratic, they're no true Scotsman right?
I guess my problem is that whenever examples are provided which contradict the model as you proposed it you decide to "clarify" the definitions so as to exclude those examples. Maybe that's the argument you originally intended to make, but it's not actually what you said.
- blah32497 13y agoActually you just aren't reading carefully. "No advanced society (past a certain GDP) has slipped back into tyranny" The only reason I need to clarify things is because when I say "advanced society past a certain GDP" you think China and early 20th century dictatorships are great example. Then you pretend that in the original post you were talking about modern Japan and Germany, which given the context made no sense The only clarification I made that sorta moved the goal posts is excluding oil rich countries from my argument, which frankly is a corner case.