3 ms·
> The Amish I've met (where I grew up in northern Michigan) didn't seem controlled by anybody. How do they follow the rules? How does one know whether to run
by rdtsc 13y ago
> The Amish I've met (where I grew up in northern Michigan) didn't seem controlled by anybody.
How do they follow the rules? How does one know whether to run pneumatic tool or electric tools in their workshop. To have a cell phone or not. I don't think those are individual decision also doubt everyone automatically arrives to those decision by themselves. So whoever makes those rules, controls them.
One can say that about any religion that has a pervasive set of rules (eat this on this day, abstain from wearing these colors, make sure to not mix this with that food) is about controlling the individuals. Of course growing up with it, it is internalized.
> It seemed like a lot of internal discipline, and they were very community-minded, but it didn't seem cult-y at all.
Oh yeah I enjoyed spending time with them. They seemed very nice to us visitors. Culti-sh is rather relative. They do shun people. That is a cultish trait if you wish. But otherwise they are just as cultish as other major religions perhaps that prescribe random rules about food, clothes, behavior, sex, life in general.
> To me, their restrictions don't seem arbitrary at all.
They are to me. I can't with a straight face say that a half a mil CNC machine workshop operated by an Amish girl in a bonnet is "ok" while a light bulb in the house is not "ok".
- wpietri 13y agoOk. So the stuff about abuse and control is just speculation on your part? I think you should be clear about that when making accusations. Regarding the restrictions, anything where one doesn't understand what's going on seems arbitrary. The elements and their properties look pretty arbitrary until you get cozy with a periodical table and a chemistry textbook. These are real people, people who won't be speaking for themselves here on HN. I'm uncomfortable with the way you're taking your ignorance and using it to justify calling them crazy, abusive, and arbitrary.
- rdtsc 13y ago> Regarding the restrictions, anything where one doesn't understand what's going on seems arbitrary. Just to double check you are justifying modifying simple electrical appliances such as blenders with pneumatic versions, using a diesel generator to charge batteries behind the house and using said batteries, tearing tires off of tractors and putting metal wheels, as somehow non-arbitrary and logical > The elements and their properties look pretty arbitrary until you get cozy with a periodical table and a chemistry textbook. So their reasons and logic for this is just as clear as atomic numbers and electron shells? It should be easy to explain then in a couple of paragraphs. You should have started with that probably as that would have saved quite a few keystroke. > These are real people, people who won't be speaking for themselves here on HN. I'm uncomfortable with the way you're taking your ignorance and using it to justify calling them crazy, abusive, and arbitrary. Yes they are real people and I also enjoy visiting them and spending time with them. They are more friendly (at least to visitors) than most of the other people I meet. That doesn't mean they are not crazy in their approach to technology. And apart from you calling me ignorant (which I may very well be) you still haven't convinced me of why what they do makes sense.
- wpietri 13y ago> their reasons and logic for this is just as clear as atomic numbers and electron shells? Either this is willful misunderstanding or you're too wound up to really pay attention to what I'm saying. Either way, I'm not seeing the point of further discussion.
- barry-cotter 13y agoHow do they follow the rules? How does one know whether to run pneumatic tool or electric tools in their workshop. To have a cell phone or not. I don't think those are individual decision also doubt everyone automatically arrives to those decision by themselves. So whoever makes those rules, controls them. They're not individual decisions but they're made by communities a hell of a lot more democratic than the one I grew up in. Amish, Mennonite, Old Order, they are all part of quite small religious congregations without professional clergy. These congregations decide their various policies on new technology themselves after seeing them and discussing them. Different congregations can agree to common sets of rules and standards, those that do are in communion. It's a lot more democratic than representative democracy.