3 ms·
> Thirdly, Amish practices are ultimately driven by religious belief: the technological, environmental, social, and cultural consequences are secondary. They o
by baddox 13y ago
> Thirdly, Amish practices are ultimately driven by religious belief: the technological, environmental, social, and cultural consequences are secondary. They often don't have logical reasons for their policies.
I don't think this is fair. Their choice to refrain from certain technologies is religious in nature, of course, but it comes through the filter of not wanting to be distracted by the rest of the world. They do not believe that there is a divine order that leads directly to the seemingly arbitrary list of can-haves and can't-haves, and as far as I know, they don't even believe that their way of life is necessary for salvation or condemn the rest of Christianity.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoExactly. As Kevin even admits later in the article, their list of allowed vs. not is determined chiefly by the observed side-effects on already existing relationships, attitudes, etc, which they put high importance on.
- baddox 13y agoYes. Their communities are naturally limited in size (since they meet in their own homes and barns), so they are probably very responsive to the needs of the specific community. On top of that, everything is voluntary, and rule-breaking is handled non-violently.
- mbrock 13y agoFunniest thing is the assumption that anybody else has "logical" reasons for their habits. The Amish have an actual decision making procedure, the rest of us just flock to every shiny thing.