6 ms·
> [...] use a propane powered fork lift with metal wheels (no rubber so you can't drive it on the road) to cart around stacks of heavy metal as they manufacture
by rdtsc 13y ago
> [...] use a propane powered fork lift with metal wheels (no rubber so you can't drive it on the road) to cart around stacks of heavy metal as they manufacture very precise milled metal parts for pneumatic motors and for kerosene cooking stoves, an Amish favorite.
That is impressive but that is just insanity. I visited an Amish parish in central Ohio. It wasn't just visiting the gift shop. It was a long story but we ended up sharing a meal and spending the day with them. They are great and warm people. Very good food. Women are reserved and never really talked to us much. The place was fascinating in how clean and pristine it was. Now going back to technology -- yeah they are crazy. I don't have any other way to put it.
See I don't mind artificial handicaps. Like say, ok, let's see if I can program a web server in assembler for fun, or use an editor without syntax highlighting with the delete button disables, or spend the weekend without making any left turns. Those can be fun learning experience or just fun things, goofing around.
But, structuring the a whole life around arbitrary restrictions (can use pneumatic tools but not electrical, can use a car but have to paint it black, can't own a car but oh, you can hire a taxi, can own a tractor but has to have metal wheels, can't use electricity for light but can use it for power tools in the shop) I see it more about abuse and control of minds than anything.
This is especially interesting to see if you look at other countries. Countries where there is pervasive poverty . They would love to get their hands on new tractors, electricity, cell phones, better education and I wonder what would they think about these groups of people in a developed country going out of their way to avoid all those things.
- wpietri 13y agoWho do you think is doing the abusing here? The Amish I've met (where I grew up in northern Michigan) didn't seem controlled by anybody. It seemed like a lot of internal discipline, and they were very community-minded, but it didn't seem cult-y at all. Even though I'm a technologist through and through, I have a lot of respect for what they're up to. I am also very careful about what technology I let into my life; there can be subtle poorly understood effects. E.g., we've been using artificial light for generations, but it has been linked recently with depression and breast cancer. To me, their restrictions don't seem arbitrary at all. I think they are rooted in different values than mine, but I've learned to respect that. For those who want more, by the way, NPR did a nice piece today on Amish technology adoption: http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2013/09/02/217287028/amish-community-not-anti-technology-just-more-thoughful http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2013/09/02/217287...
- rdtsc 13y ago> The Amish I've met (where I grew up in northern Michigan) didn't seem controlled by anybody. How do they follow the rules? How does one know whether to run pneumatic tool or electric tools in their workshop. To have a cell phone or not. I don't think those are individual decision also doubt everyone automatically arrives to those decision by themselves. So whoever makes those rules, controls them. One can say that about any religion that has a pervasive set of rules (eat this on this day, abstain from wearing these colors, make sure to not mix this with that food) is about controlling the individuals. Of course growing up with it, it is internalized. > It seemed like a lot of internal discipline, and they were very community-minded, but it didn't seem cult-y at all. Oh yeah I enjoyed spending time with them. They seemed very nice to us visitors. Culti-sh is rather relative. They do shun people. That is a cultish trait if you wish. But otherwise they are just as cultish as other major religions perhaps that prescribe random rules about food, clothes, behavior, sex, life in general. > To me, their restrictions don't seem arbitrary at all. They are to me. I can't with a straight face say that a half a mil CNC machine workshop operated by an Amish girl in a bonnet is "ok" while a light bulb in the house is not "ok".
- wpietri 13y agoOk. So the stuff about abuse and control is just speculation on your part? I think you should be clear about that when making accusations. Regarding the restrictions, anything where one doesn't understand what's going on seems arbitrary. The elements and their properties look pretty arbitrary until you get cozy with a periodical table and a chemistry textbook. These are real people, people who won't be speaking for themselves here on HN. I'm uncomfortable with the way you're taking your ignorance and using it to justify calling them crazy, abusive, and arbitrary.
- rdtsc 13y ago> Regarding the restrictions, anything where one doesn't understand what's going on seems arbitrary. Just to double check you are justifying modifying simple electrical appliances such as blenders with pneumatic versions, using a diesel generator to charge batteries behind the house and using said batteries, tearing tires off of tractors and putting metal wheels, as somehow non-arbitrary and logical > The elements and their properties look pretty arbitrary until you get cozy with a periodical table and a chemistry textbook. So their reasons and logic for this is just as clear as atomic numbers and electron shells? It should be easy to explain then in a couple of paragraphs. You should have started with that probably as that would have saved quite a few keystroke. > These are real people, people who won't be speaking for themselves here on HN. I'm uncomfortable with the way you're taking your ignorance and using it to justify calling them crazy, abusive, and arbitrary. Yes they are real people and I also enjoy visiting them and spending time with them. They are more friendly (at least to visitors) than most of the other people I meet. That doesn't mean they are not crazy in their approach to technology. And apart from you calling me ignorant (which I may very well be) you still haven't convinced me of why what they do makes sense.
- peeters 13y ago> But, structuring the a whole life around arbitrary restrictions (can use pneumatic tools but not electrical, can use a car but have to paint it black, can't own a car but oh, you can hire a taxi, can own a tractor but has to have metal wheels, can't use electricity for light but can use it for power tools in the shop) Arbitrary? The entire article was about showing the nuances and reasoning for the very things you cite. Electricity is not OK if it's on the grid, because it creates dependencies on the outside world. If you're dismissing the "handicaps" as arbitrary, I fear you've missed the entire point of the article. And it's never been about handicapping anyway. These people want to be as productive as possible. Do some reading about Mennonites (similar philosophies) in Russia; they were some of the most industrious and cutting edge farmers in the nation. It's always been about preventing harm to the community from new technology, not about deliberately making their work more difficult.
- rdtsc 13y ago> Electricity is not OK if it's on the grid, because it creates dependencies on the outside world. So do cell phones, taxi drivers to take your kids to school every morning, and half million dollar computerized precision CNC machines. GMO corn? > These people want to be as productive as possible. They are taking regular Chinese mass produced blenders and sticking hand crafted pneumatic motors in them. Or tractors and then cut their tires out and replace with metal wheels. I can't see how that makes them more productive. If anything that makes them less productive, no? Isn't that the other justification for their way of life -- don't become too productive, it will hurt you, and ruin your way of life? > It's always been about preventing harm to the community from new technology, Unless preventing harm from technology becomes the main identity and the main occupation of the community then well, one can ask, why have the community? > Do some reading about Mennonites (similar philosophies) in Russia; they were some of the most industrious and cutting edge farmers in the nation. So were many German and Dutch farmers if you talk about the turn of the century and before. At least compared to many British immigrant farmers. I would also agree that in extreme conditions (far north, in Siberia, mountains) technology might not be reliable or as usable and sometimes just using dog sleds or simpler methods can work better.
- 13y ago
- AlisdairSH 13y ago"...structuring the a whole life around arbitrary restrictions..." Couldn't the same be said of any other group of people? We all draw boundaries around what is acceptable or not. Some people don't want cable television. Some like to live car-free. Others choose vegetarianism or veganism. The Amish just draw that line someplace we consider extreme. At the end of the day, if they're happy, that's all that matters.