3 ms·
“Just as practicing professionals such as doctors, accountants, and nurses are licensed, so should software engineers,” Thornton says. “The public needs to be a
by angersock 13y ago
“Just as practicing professionals such as doctors, accountants, and nurses are licensed, so should software engineers,” Thornton says. “The public needs to be able to rely on some sort of credential when choosing a contractor to write software.”
Yep, and thank God America's healthcare is so affordable because of these licensing requirements!
What a horrid idea.
EDIT:
Here's the deal. I'm a mechanical engineer by training, and could've after several years of paying dues gotten my Professional Engineer cert. There are technical fields where I demand that the products I consume (especially those which service thousands of people every day, as is the case with public infrastructure) have a very strong line of qualification.
The fact is that >>99% of software (as it is consumed today) does not require anything near the formal qualifications of civil or structural or chemical engineering.
If you want a really poignant reminder of how having professional engineers with quality control and certification can result in bad progress, go look at what's become of NASA and Armadillo Aerospace.
We are so lucky to be in a field where our ability to ship working code is valued above our ability to get off whoever the current power broker is (and this includes investors).
Let's not willfully throw away that windfall.
EDIT2:
If we expect to conduct business as has become the norm these days--move fast, break things, learn, repeat--and as has done so well for us as an industry, doing anything which artificially limits the supply of potential hands is bad. Doing anything which prevents people from trying new things with minimum investment is bad.
They don't understand us, and they're greedy bastards, so Something Must Be Done (and this is not only for .gov folks--the professional groups have a lot riding on being seen as useful. Jane and Bob the Bad Coders stand a lot to gain by collecting dues for the American Society of Software Engineers).
Actually, that's kind of funny. American Society of Software Engineers. ASSEs. Huh.
- wwkeyboard 13y agoThat being said we've had many times more deaths from bad software than from bad spacecraft(http://www.cs.tau.ac.il/~nachumd/horror.html http://www.cs.tau.ac.il/~nachumd/horror.html vs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_accidents_and_incidents http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_acc...). I understand your point that you might write software that has few consequences if it fails, but thats not always the case.
- wwkeyboard 13y agoEdit1: A poorly written app could impact the ability to call 911. Even by draining the battery unexpectedly.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoThe solution for this is to solve it in the domains where it is necessary. If you want to write or adopt software for use in a critical system in aerospace then you need to be a licensed aerospace engineer, etc. There is absolutely no need to license web developers or those who write the usual line of business software etc.
- zhemao 13y ago> Only those whose programs might “endanger the public health or safety, security, property, or the economy will need to be tested.” I don't think the people pushing for licensing disagree with you that web developers don't need a license.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoAre you sure? The description you just gave is unreasonably broad. What does "security, property or the economy" even mean, and what justifies their inclusion?
- wwkeyboard 13y agoYes for the domain knowledge, but what about the software? Do you expect an aerospace or biomedical engineer to understand also how to write safety-of-life system?
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoWhy is that an unreasonable expectation if their job is to write such a thing? If you want to write software for aircraft then I don't see it as unreasonable that you be expected to understand both software and aircraft.
- 13y ago
- unono 13y agoSpot on. To add a point, licensing will shift the blame from corporations and their management to workers. This will mean that the blame won't be placed on management cheaping out on processes to ensure safety, but instead the 'bad apple' developer. This is bad for both consumers and workers. Licensing in all industries, especially in medicine and law needs to be abolished ASAP. it has devastated many lives (it's too costly to get multiple opinions) and robbed the middle class in every town across America.
- wwkeyboard 13y agoExactly, why can't I open an appendectomy kiosk at the mall!?!
- unono 13y agoBecause the consumer won't buy from you if you don't have a good track record. If a big company with a good brand name like Boeing or Airbus hired you for that, they might buy it. A company with reputation on the line will be more likely to invest in quality control than your local hospital (which usually refuses to publish any statistics or prices).
- wwkeyboard 13y agoBut where does that track record come from? It sounds like you are now defending the protectionism your previous comment was decrying.
- unono 13y agoWhere does a typical carpenter, web developer, entreprenuer, hedge fund manager's reputation come from? Word of mouth from previous clients. In the beginning a company with needs hires you and your reputation builds over time. As I said above, I think Boeing does a fine job of minimizing errors. The AMA, teaching hospitals and local hospitals don't.