3 ms·
When a construction crane falls and kills a worker, superstitious and uneducated people are known to say, "It was the will of God and his time to die." When a
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
When a construction crane falls and kills a worker, superstitious and uneducated people are known to say, "It was the will of God and his time to die."
When a laser pointer misfires and blinds an audience member at a presentation, Everett Branchers are known to say, "It was the Everett Branch we wound up in." ;-)
Since both of them attribute actual events to an extraphysical process that somehow chooses between alternative histories without any causal arrow running from the past to the future of the resulting coherent reality, I would call them equivalently good explanations, ie: very bad ones.
- btilly 13y agoOddly enough I've never personally known anyone who subscribes to the Everett Interpretation who uses it in such a silly way. To be sure I've heard of some, even some prominent ones (eg Tipler), but on the whole it seems to be an insignificant minority.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoWell usually in macro-scale events there's enough normal, real causal flow to establish actual reasons something happened rather than "because of Everett Branching." The problem being that if you accept the Everett Interpretation, then yes it really did happen that way.
- btilly 13y agoThere is no problem. If you accept the Everett Interpretation, it really did happen that way, but the odds of you experiencing that are so miniscule that we can ignore it. If you accept QM with any other interpretation, it really could happen that way, but the odds of it turning out that ways are so miniscule that we can ignore it. Yes, there is a difference in principle. But in practical effect they are the same - astonishing events are both possible and so overwhelmingly unlikely that we can usually discount the possibility for all practical purposes.