5 ms·
Ugh, once again Marco succeeds in making Apple's way look like the only way. Here's two reasons why Marco and especially that hack Gruber are both fantastically
by bane 13y ago
Ugh, once again Marco succeeds in making Apple's way look like the only way. Here's two reasons why Marco and especially that hack Gruber are both fantastically deluded:
1) Nintendo is the Disney of Video Games. Lots of companies make cartoons & there's tons of theme parks, but there's only 1 Disney. It's a seal of quality, of fun, of playability. Nintendo's reputation, and the consumer mindshare is in this.
You fill yours and your kid's shelves with Disney books, movies, and Nintendo video games and other assorted merch. A $500 very breakable phone with a $100 a month of data services for my 9 year old? I don't think so. A $130 handheld with a few games he's earned from doing chores that he can beat around, drop and otherwise drag and kick around is where it's at. Sure you see the occasional bored kid at a family dinner using their mom's phone to play angry birds. But you see 20x as many with their Nintendo xDS playing Mario Brothers.
Nintendo generally makes lots of money by using slightly older technology to make this year's great new gaming experience. They've survived generations of very competitive onslaught. They've never targeted the high end gamer...from the beginning.
"Nintendo needs the profits of the high end" is quite simply, incorrect. Nintendo profits from pretty much every unit of everything they move. And on top of moving games and systems they have a substantial merchandising business probably second to only Disney.
The only surprise is that Nintendo hasn't been able to get into theme parks and cartoons in a bigger way. A Disney/Nintendo cross licensing for characters would be amazing. Bring your kids to Walt Disney <insert park>, your daughter gets to meet all her princesses and your son gets to hang out with Samus and Mario.
2) "But but but", Marco argues, "people are getting used to paying <$10 for a game". Yeah, but those games suck compared to a new Mario title. But let's say that suddenly amazing $4 games started coming out.
Let's play a game, given that kids abuse systems so badly and selection of Apple handhelds is...limited. Would I rather buy a free/cheap Android phone for my kid to abuse or an expensive and fragile iPhone? I can guarantee it would be the one with the lower replacement cost, especially after the first couple phone go in the toilet or down the stairs.
But let's be serious, there's zero possibility that Nintendo will go the way of Sega in the next generation or two. They dominate handhelds in a way Microsoft used to dominate the desktop business and the WiiU, while a technological disappointment in some ways was a carefully calculated system designed to ensure that the big N never lost a dollar on any part of their vertically integrated gaming empire that they sold. There's no such thing as "loss leader" at Nintendo.
And let's face it, phone gaming frankly sucks compared to holding a DS and working a d-pad.
- edit -
for anybody to get what Nintendo is about should read up on Gunpei Yokoi's "Lateral Thinking of Withered Technology" (枯れた技術の水平思考) It makes analysis like this really seem very uninformed about the company.
- Apocryphon 13y agoThe problem I see is twofold. Like Disney, Nintendo is in danger of recycling its old franchises again and again. How much innovation has there been to the Mario franchise? Do we really need another hundred or so Pokemon? Like Apple, Nintendo has seen great success by adopting the Blue Ocean Strategy with the Wii, but now is expected by the public to repeat that success with further innovation. Innovation is hard, and WiiU isn't very innovative. Neither of these are insurmountable challenges, partly because the public (either kids or adults) is full of casual gamers who don't really care for a lot of innovative in either their games or their hardware. But it's a bit disappointing.
- jonnathanson 13y ago"1) Nintendo is the Disney of Video Games. Lots of companies make cartoons & there's tons of theme parks, but there's only 1 Disney. It's a seal of quality, of fun, of playability. Nintendo's reputation, and the consumer mindshare is in this." For many decades, I'll grant you, this would have been an almost perfect analogy. Nintendo's brands, characters, and franchises transcended every console generation and consistently drove critics and audiences crazy with anticipation and delight. Mario was the Mickey Mouse of gaming; he and his fellow characters were licenses to print money. But key to the analogy is that Nintendo used to push the envelope of game design in the same way that Disney pushed the envelope on the animated narrative (and the musical, and the theme park, and so on). The hardware was important, but it was always somewhat incidental. Mario, Link, Donkey Kong, or Yoshi would have grown stale a long time ago if their successive sequels hadn't completely rethought the very fundamentals of gameplay in their respective genres. You're correct in stating that Nintendo "never targeted the high-end gamer," but for most of Nintendo's history, such a gamer didn't really exist -- at least not in the console space. The particular effect of Sony's, Microsoft's, and later Apple's entries into the gaming business was to segment the market (intentionally or otherwise). Nintendo's brands still appeal across genres, across age groups, etc., but they've grown increasingly limited in reach, due to the segmentation of the market by hardware and platform. "they dominate handhelds in a way Microsoft used to dominate the desktop business" And where is the desktop business now? A very credible argument could be made that the days of dedicated, handheld gaming devices are numbered. (In fact, a lot of consumers no longer draw distinctions between "handheld gaming" as a distinct genre delineated by specialized hardware, and "handheld gaming" as seen on mobile devices). Indeed, Nintendo's core audience seems to be the very audience most readily cannibalized by mobile-device gaming: primarily, younger gamers without a lot of need for specialized, hardcore hardware. I'll grant you that there's so many things you can do on a DS (or similar device) that simply can't be done on an iPhone. But these days, the gameplay envelope is increasingly being pushed on the iOS side -- not the DS side. Innovative gameplay is Nintendo's lifeblood, and Nintendo needs to be where the most potential for innovation lies. "And on top of moving games and systems they have a substantial merchandising business probably second to only Disney." It may seem that way. But "non-game merchandise" represents a $19.2 million business for Nintendo -- approximately 0.2% of its annual sales in 2012. (Source: http://www.nintendogal.com/2012/04/27/nintendo-releases-financials-for-fiscal-year-2012/ http://www.nintendogal.com/2012/04/27/nintendo-releases-fina...) I agree completely that Nintendo had -- and may still have -- Disney-esque potential in the gaming space. But its long-term horizon is cloudy, and it may need a pivot of some sort. Marco's suggestions may or may not represent the ideal strategy (and indeed, I see many of the same limitations in them that you do). But some serious strategic rethinking is in order.