4 ms·
I imagine culturally wasting that money and remaining homeless will be less prominent over time. You have a much more optimistic view of how culture evolves th
by pdonis 13y ago
I imagine culturally wasting that money and remaining homeless will be less prominent over time.
You have a much more optimistic view of how culture evolves than I do.
Right now, there is a hyper-consumerist culture of spending everything you have and then some on immediate pleasure, which isn't sustainable regardless of what fiscal organizing of society you have.
But instituting BI doesn't help this problem, because the main incentive people have for not spending everything they receive is the uncertainty of future income. If everyone thinks they are getting BI forever no matter what they do, they have less incentive to save, not more.
It would be helpful if everyone understood that BI is all that anybody gets--i.e., that BI replaces all the current government services that are given to people, like Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps, section 8 housing, etc. In other words, if everyone understood that it is their responsibility to use BI wisely. But the only way to enforce that understanding would be to let people suffer the negative consequences of using BI unwisely. You spent all your BI on junk food and liquor, and then you get sick and can't afford to pay for health care? Fine, then you don't receive care.
I doubt that BI would be as popular a proposal as it is if that aspect were included. But without it, I don't see how BI fixes the cultural issues you speak of (which I agree are genuine issues).
- zanny 13y agoI don't think we are operating on a platform where a BI could be actually implemented. Too many intrenched interests (among which are pretty much every single megacorporation that uses wage slavery to keep employees poor) that have too much lobbing money in a political process that is so exceedingly corrupt. And beyond that, you have mainstream media hound dogs at the beck and call of politicians to spread lies and propaganda about any proposal to ruin its public opinion. I'm just saying if we did it (we won't) it would have to be a hard slap in the face to wasteful spenders of it. The thing is, people can survive and rebound from 2 weeks homeless because they wasted their BI check. But when you don't have a check in 2 weeks to give it another go, you just end up down a spiral into destitution and the bottom dregs of society.
- pdonis 13y agoif we did it (we won't) it would have to be a hard slap in the face to wasteful spenders of it I would say that even if we did do it, it wouldn't have this feature.