4 ms·
There is no protection to uplift you from poverty if the value of flesh bodies performing unskilled tasks isn't worth what it costs to keep you alive. And how
by pdonis 13y ago
There is no protection to uplift you from poverty if the value of flesh bodies performing unskilled tasks isn't worth what it costs to keep you alive.
And how does BI fix this? Now instead of paying people for doing less work than it costs to keep them alive, you're paying people for doing no work. That makes the problem worse, not better.
The only way to fix this problem is to have the people do more valuable tasks, so that what they are doing actually is worth more, and therefore merits higher pay. BI does nothing towards achieving that, and in fact probably does the opposite, on net.
you don't have to fear exploitation of the workforce if people are employed to meet their wants and not their needs
This is a serious misstatement, because if there are people who are creating less value than they are receiving in BI (which is what your statements imply), there must also be people who are creating more value than they are receiving through BI. That must be true because, for BI to work at all, the total value being created must be at least as much as the value of BI for one person times the number of people in the society. Otherwise the whole system doesn't work, because there isn't enough value being created to fund it.
So consider the position of a person who is creating more value than the value of BI per person, and then sees a significant portion of that value taken away from him and given to people who are creating less value than the value of BI per person. Why, exactly, would that person not have a strong incentive to either (a) create less value, since it's not going to him anyway; or (b) figure out a way to game the system so it seems like he's creating less value than he actually is, and pocketing the difference--i.e., exploiting the people who are creating less value than he is?
I'm sure there are plenty of people who would not choose (a) or (b) in this situation; but I think there are also plenty who would. And it wouldn't take too many of them to destroy the system.