10 ms·
Drug Agents Use Vast Phone Trove Eclipsing N.S.A.’s
- uptown 13y ago"The government pays AT&T to place its employees in drug-fighting units around the country. Those employees sit alongside Drug Enforcement Administration agents and local detectives and supply them with the phone data from as far back as 1987." "Unlike the N.S.A. data, the Hemisphere data includes information on the locations of callers." "Some four billion call records are added to the database every day" No wonder phone number portability got pushed through.
- raverbashing 13y agoPortability makes it easier for people This is a side effect and, as other people told it, completely not needed. Even easier than that, people switch SIM cards but keep the same phone (this may not be very common in the US, still, it happens)
- bandushrew 13y agoman, that makes sense. nice call.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIt's funny, we thought they went to all that trouble for our benefit. We're a bunch of rubes.
- nzealand 13y agoEven if you switch phone numbers, using Hemisphere they can determine your new number. They look for a new phone number calling all your old contacts.
- uptown 13y agoAbsolutely. But allowing/encouraging people to keep a single identifier sure makes things easier, and cuts down on your database joins.
- superuser2 13y agoDo you really think the DBA for a project that doesn't official exist gets to write consumer protection policy? Can you imagine any nontechnical organization doing something as complicated as passing a law just to cut down on database joins? Seriously?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- revelation 13y agoThis "Protect the Program" stuff sounds like another "Parallel construction" debacle. They are not talking about hiding the program from the public, they are talking about getting the information elsewhere after you used Hemisphere. Basically, this is a private backyard deal the DEA made with AT&T. Apparently our laws have deteriorated to the point where AT&T lawyers believe they can do this legally.
- leokun 13y agoIt can't just be AT&T, it must be regional bells, the other major carriers, small companies, everyone.
- greglindahl 13y ago?? There are only 2 regional bells now, and one of them is called AT&T.
- greenyoda 13y agoThe article notes that: "Representatives from Verizon, Sprint and T-Mobile all declined to comment on Sunday in response to questions about whether their companies were aware of Hemisphere or participated in that program or similar ones." If they were not participating in Hemisphere or similar programs, I'd expect them to be quick to say so.
- otoburb 13y agoIf they were asked to comment on Sunday (on a weekend), then it's probably more likely that they wanted to confer with their legal departments before denying with any confidence. This is especially in light of the recent public/media PR confusion with technology companies around PRISM.
- greenyoda 13y agoThe article didn't address the question of why AT&T has phone records going back so many years. I doubt that five year old data about a customer would be useful for marketing, considering that they have the most recent data. Nor is old data useful for billing once the time period for contesting a phone bill has elapsed. Network capacity planning could be done with anonymized or aggregated data. So it would seem that the only reason why they hang on to all this data is because the government asks them to, or because they can make money selling it to the government (or both). Now, think about what adverse effects such old data could have on justice. For example, let's say a friend of mine from school, who I spent a lot of time talking to on the phone a decade ago, decided this year to become a drug dealer. The government could start investigating me based on this stale data, despite not having any reasonable suspicion that I was involved in any crime. I think that what we really need is a privacy-oriented phone company built on the model of DuckDuckGo, which doesn't keep any data about customers beyond what's necessary for billing purposes. But maybe the U.S. already has laws that would make such an ethical phone company illegal.
- rdl 13y agoI wonder if you could do it as an MVNO.
- greenyoda 13y agoIf you operated an MVNO (Mobile Virtual Network Operator), wouldn't your traffic still be going over AT&T's or some other carrier's network? They'd have access to the information whether you wanted them to or not.
- rdl 13y agoI don't know if they keep billing data for MVNO customers. And, a $500mm/yr MVNO would have the power to negotiate contractual terms which regular individual or business customers wouldn't; not like showing up with pitchforks at exec houses in the middle of the night when violated, but with huge payments required at least.
- ganeumann 13y agoThe government pays AT&T to place its employees in drug-fighting units around the country. Those employees sit alongside Drug Enforcement Administration agents and local detectives If the government pays your salary and you are embedded in the DEA, you are a government employee. Saying these people work for AT&T is patently absurd.
- Amadou 13y agoExactly. People get so worked up about the technical distinctions, ones that are mostly drawn by the IRS for tax purposes, that they confuse the form for the function. It is no different than Booz Hamilton "contractors" working on site at NSA and other TLAs. If the money comes from the government and you take direction from the government, even indirectly, you are an agent of the government.
- rdl 13y agoIt seems pretty clear that the mobile operators are the biggest commercial organization threats to personal liberty. Their only real competition is the banks.
- jlund 13y agoCash is really easy to use and is accepted everywhere. There's no similarly elegant solution for mobile connectivity if you want to stop revealing metadata information.
- greenyoda 13y agoWell, not really everywhere. If you tried to buy an airline ticket with cash, you'd be subject to a lot of scrutiny.
- djf1 13y agoDoesn't negate your point, but I checked out of curiosity, and at least with American Airlines, it is easy to buy an airline ticket with cash. http://www.aa.com/i18n/reservations/paymentOptions/cashPayments.jsp http://www.aa.com/i18n/reservations/paymentOptions/cashPayme...
- dredmorbius 13y ago"Legal tender for all debts, public and private".
- Amadou 13y ago> "Legal tender for all debts, public and private". Yes, debts being the operative term here. You don't incur a debt until you receive the product. Airline tickets are paid for in advance so the customer never incurs a debt.
- femto 13y agoGiven the number of network connected machines that cash passes though (ATMs, ticket machines, counting machines, ...), I'd assume that such machines would be routinely scanning the serial number of each note. Couple that with an account number, or the CCTV that is usually pointed at any cash handling machine, and I'd posit that the anonymity of cash is eroding.
- hawkharris 13y agoIf you haven't already seen The House I Live In, I recommend watching the documentary online. It will change the way you think about drugs and the United States' prison system. The movie doesn't focus specifically on technology, but it explores the by-any-means-necessary approach to law enforcement that helps facilitate things such as the Hemisphere Project mentioned in the story. Trailer: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0atL1HSwi8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0atL1HSwi8
- D9u 13y agoI recently read an article about prisoners who had cell phones from which they posted to their Facebook pages, replete with images of their drugs and snack stashes, even facilitating communications between inmates in different prisons. It was only after investigative journalists brought the situation to the attention of regulatory agencies that the prisons clamped down on the security breaches within the prisons. http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/tennessee-inmates-post-photos-partying-drugs-cells-article-1.1334686 http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/tennessee-inmates-post...
- vinceguidry 13y agoThey didn't clamp down on anything. All they did was make an example of them. I bet the other inmates 'helped'. They still have access to cell phones and Facebook, they just are more careful now about this sort of stupidity.
- seiji 13y agoAnother day, another peek behind the veil of large scale (institutional and codified) data abuse. We don't have to put up with them poking their fingers in our lives for much longer. We can build around them. We can make them irrelevant. It'll take a more concerted effort than building social networks for cats (where you spend four years of your life posturing about "changing the world" and "being successful" then the next day you cash out for big acquihire fake-success bucks). Stop studying $FAD_OF_THE_WEEK and go back to your math and ML fundamentals. Play around with it. Build good things. Then build bigger good things. Build good things for good people.
- mpyne 13y agoDavid Simon pointed out something like this when PRISM itself was first leaked. The courts and law enforcement have combined for some pretty incredible types of surveillance and investigation possibilities, and have done so for years and years.
- minor_nitwit 13y agoYet another reason to legalize drugs.
- D9u 13y agoIs there any doubt as to the fascist nature of the USA now? Call it "corporate cronyism," or "corporate fascism," but whatever it's called, it's no land of the free anymore.
- sanderjd 13y agoWell, unfortunately the word "fascist" isn't particularly meaningful anymore. But there certainly isn't any doubt that Fourth Amendment protections for documents in peoples' homes haven't been considered to be extended to digital communications moving through various service providers' pipes, and that various government agencies have been having a field day with surveillance data they've been able to legally justify collecting based on that lack of Constitutional protection. It seems largely like a widespread failure to create language protecting digital privacy in the same spirit as analog privacy was originally protected. Maybe that's fascism, but it seems less useful to use words without agreed upon meanings.
- D9u 13y agoMy bad for using sensational terminology, but the heart of the matter remains. The privatization and collusion between government and private entities at the expense of We the People has brought the USA to a point where it's obviously become the land of the corporation and the home of the wage-slave. Lobbyists with vast funding avail their corporate sponsors of representation which is denied to those who lack such deep-pockets. Only those with similar vast funding are able to attain high level elected positions within our government, from whence they enact legislation which furthers the divide between the plebiscite and the proletariat, which falls right into line with Marxist "liberal-democratic" ideology, where the government becomes the tool of the Bourgeoisie at the expense of the Proles and the Plebes. This socioeconomic stratification is quite visible in today's USA, and programs such as "Hemisphere" exemplify this situation. I too find the exclusion of electronic communications from 4th Amendment protections to be an egregious failure of our Constitutional checks and balances, yet due to my own limited understanding of the situation I have always considered our electronic communications to be analogous to the "... papers and effects..." outlined in the 4th Amendment, but my motivations are different from those who have been appointed to interpret our legal structures. The very notion of "Too big to fail/jail" is yet another example of holding those with vast resources to a different standard when compared to the average Joe Public who worries about how he's going to continue to feed his family as well as keep an acceptable roof over their head. Where it leaves us is at an increasingly disadvantageous position, unless we are of the Bourgeoisie and able to purchase our way through the system on par with big banks who launder cartel drug profits with impunity; where political appointees can perjure themselves before Congress with impunity; and where every day words are redefined by our public servants as they maneuver their way through the system with similar impunity as relates to their questionable acts.
- downandout 13y agoFrom the document: Protecting the Hemisphere program is a formidable challenge. We have taken the following steps to try and keep the program under the radar... The fact that our government creates and then goes to such great lengths to hide programs that it knows the public (and most likely the courts) will vehemently object to shows the level of contempt that government officials and employees have for the very people they were hired to serve. I don't know that it can be fixed, but it is a very serious problem.
- willvarfar 13y agoMaybe they don't want drug pushers and users to know they have this either?
- gaius 13y agoSecurity through obscurity?
- aroman 13y ago…actually works outside of theory. We're not talking cryptosystems here, we're talking about intelligence and counterintelligence. You don't call a spy's disguise security through obscurity. Note that I'm not condoning mass government surveilance, only objecting to its criticism on the grounds of "security through obsecurity".
- sliverstorm 13y agoEven real-world cryptography can benefit from security through obscurity. It's all a time game- how fast can my attackers attack my security, how much time do I need to buy. If security through obscurity buys you time, why not?
- bad_user 13y ago"Buys you time" for what? For fixing it? Why not do it right in the first place? The danger in this line of thought is that security breaches only have to happen once for real damage to ensue. For software companies, when it happens, I always expect to see a clear explanation for why it did happen and in case of stupid architectural problems, I tend to avoid that company in the future. Of course there's a difference between software and real world undercover operations performed by government agencies. Placing an agent undercover is both a gamble and a race against the clock. The government knows the risks involved, the agent knows the risks involved, human casualties can happen but that's part of the contract so to speak. Nobody willingly enters such operations without knowing the risks involved. But if you're gambling with customer's data, be prepared to explain that to the angry customers when the shit hits the fan.
- rl3 13y ago"Unlike the N.S.A. data, the Hemisphere data includes information on the locations of callers." Unlike the publicly known N.S.A. data. Also, as if call status matters.
- cantrevealname 13y agoTake a look at what happened when the drug dealers were doing the exact same thing: In a police raid, Cali cocaine cartel leader José Santacruz Londono was found to have assembled a database that contained both the office and residential telephone numbers of U.S. diplomats and agents based in Colombia, along with the entire call log for the phone company in Cali, which was leaked by employees of the utility. A $1.5 million IBM AS400 mainframe was loaded with custom-written data-mining software. It cross-referenced the Cali phone exchange's traffic with the phone numbers of American personnel and Colombian intelligence and law enforcement officials. The computer was essentially conducting a perpetual internal mole-hunt of the cartel's organizational chart. Santacruz could see if any of his lieutenants were spilling the beans. They were. A top Colombian narcotics security adviser says the system fingered at least a dozen informants -- and that they were swiftly assassinated by the cartel. Ref: http://www.mail-archive.com/eristocracy@merrymeet.com/msg00087.html http://www.mail-archive.com/eristocracy@merrymeet.com/msg000... Longer story here: http://cocaine.org/cokecrime/index.html http://cocaine.org/cokecrime/index.html
- raldi 13y agoThat story can't possibly be true -- he would have only had access to metadata, and I've been told many times that metadata surveillance is completely harmless.
- benologist 13y agoThe existence of the data would be enough to infer a relationship that shouldn't exist at all.
- so_whaaaat 13y agoI think you missed the boat on some of that delicious sarcasm, there, pal. Just a friendly reminder, folks: always remember to close your sarcasm tags. Some people only understand well-formed XML.
- mkohlmyr 13y agowoosh
- frank_boyd 13y agoThis story alone is reason enough to seriously start working on a program and schedule for: - legalizing drugs and - selling them in a controlled environment, - taxed and - accompanied by a heavy investment in related education in schools nationwide ...instead of throwing billions at killing our most basic rights. The example of Portugal: http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/evaluating-drug-decriminalization-in-portugal-12-years-later-a-891060.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/evaluating-drug-d...
- mapt 13y agoWe already have "related education" mandated as curricula in several different grades in every school system in the country. It's not uncommonly ridiculous propaganda, with blatant urban legends dramatized for your FUD, which is widely rejected by the student body. What we need is a non-criminalized mental health system that actually functions (addiction neural wiring being a subset of mental illnesses that can be acquired through the victim's actions), and a poverty / diminished capacity safety net that tries to redress problems in the way of marginalized people rejoining civil society. Essentially everything else would self-resolve after legalization.
- tantalor 13y agoThe connection to counternarcotics is a distraction from the real story here. Legalizing drugs changes nothing. The article points this program was used in routine law enforcement, e.g., bomb threats. I'd like to know more about the "administrative subpoena" process. How often are innocent people's phone logs dumped? Why not just install cameras in the TVs and be done with it?
- GabrielF00 13y agoIf you look at slide 18, it looks like 96% of requests were for drug cases.
- ajb 13y ago"Crucially, they said, the phone data is stored by AT&T, and not by the government as in the N.S.A. program" The irony of this, is that it's exactly the tactic used by drug dealers. In order to avoid the risk of possessing illegal substances, they coerce drug addicts to hold their stash. The courts call this 'constructive possession'.
- Zigurd 13y agoWhen they say it goies back to at least 1987, I think they are referring to the Daytona database of call detail records (CDRs). That project was active in the 80's, but it goes back much farther, and it may contain most of the CDRs ever created. In it's early stages, punched cards, and later magnetic tapes, were trucked to Bell Labs and subsequently AT&T Labs, where the Daytona system was operated. In it's heyday it was the biggest database on Earth. There may be a successor to Daytona by now, and "all the CDRs, ever" is not as impressive as it once was, but it is likely that joint telco/government projects like Daytona have been collecting and analyzing call data since there was call data to analyze. I would not be surprised if they are still using Daytona's query language.
- coldcode 13y agoI wonder if this system has a search capability or it strictly limited to phone # searches. I also wonder if tech to speech works well enough to convert all these calls to text.
- superuser2 13y agoHN and the internet community reacted with consistent and vigorous outrage towards Facebook and Google for complying with subpoenas, and over unconfirmed rumors and suspicions that they were selling user data to 3rd parties (not just ad targeting internally). We had boycotts and alternatives to try to move off these services. Where's the boycott of the PSTN? Why aren't we angry at AT&T for actually embedding staff in the government? Why aren't we encouraging people to switch off their services?
- Groxx 13y agoProbably because telcoms are already considered the worst offenders, and assumed to be evil? No change to the status quo = no uproar.
- Bulkington 13y agoKey term: administrative subpoena. Judges, we don't need no stinkin' judges. http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/08/administrative-subpoenas/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/08/administrative-subp... For the P. Simon inclined, rather than just pointing to the obvious slope we've slipped down since Nixon: Whoah God only knows, God makes his plan The information's unavailable to the mortal man We're workin' our jobs, collect our pay Believe we're gliding down the highway, when in fact we're slip sliding away... http://www.lyricsfreak.com/s/simon+and+garfunkel/slip+sliding+away_20124691.html http://www.lyricsfreak.com/s/simon+and+garfunkel/slip+slidin...