4 ms·
However it's not a DRM free streaming model. So it's not much healthier than other types of restrictions - it's still DRM. Some truly DRM free streaming should
by shmerl 13y ago
However it's not a DRM free streaming model. So it's not much healthier than other types of restrictions - it's still DRM. Some truly DRM free streaming should emerge in the face of all these Netflix-like DRMed barbed-wired gardens. Streaming should be a convenience, not a way to restrict copying. Others brought Steam as an example - for Steam, there is competing GOG which is DRM free and proves the point that DRM free gaming without regional restrictions and other such junk can be successful. So what is there for Netflix?
Also, I didn't get his point about the music industry. Most music is easily available DRM free, unlike video.
- michaelwww 13y ago>I didn't get his point about the music industry Maybe this will help: https://www.eff.org/wp/riaa-v-people-five-years-later https://www.eff.org/wp/riaa-v-people-five-years-later
- shmerl 13y agoAh, this. Yes, RIAA are a strange bunch. They managed to get rid of DRM in sold music, but now fulfill their paranoid fear of piracy through DMCA takedowns and lawsuits. Which makes one think that they dropped DRM not out of common sense like could be expected.
- methodin 13y agoI don't think most people expect DRM-free content when paying for a subscription model - I know I don't. I'm paying for the right to access that content when I want as long as it's available but I am under no assumption that I assume the right to take that content with me and do with it what I please. That type of content is completely different than what this streaming model represents. Netflix is surely on a better trajectory here than other providers, no?
- shmerl 13y agoIt's not better as long as there is DRM in it. Why can't you expect to get the content with you? You can expect paying for titles some one time fee. Not unlike music and games. Streaming is just a way of accessing it from the "cloud" without the need to download it first. But why should it prevent you from downloading if you want to back it up, take it with you somewhere where you have no access to the cloud and so on? There is no good reason for "subscription model" in the digital world which restricts your ability to copy. Buy and use, that's what it's supposed to be.
- smtddr 13y ago>But why should it prevent you from downloading if you want to back it up, take it with you somewhere where you have no access to the cloud and so on? That's the real problem; that internet is not accessible & free everywhere. I think DRM is fine as long as I can access my media anytime & anywhere on all my devices. Netflix pretty much fits this requirement aside from the hack of Linux+Netflix. The issue that internet isn't available to every human being or costs a ridiculous amount of money is a problem that needs to be fixed. I want to be able to say "Everyone has internet these days" and really mean it for all people of the world. We need to make it impossible for anyone to make the argument "but what if I don't have internet access?".
- shmerl 13y ago> I think DRM is fine as long as I can access my media anytime & anywhere on all my devices. I think DRM is never OK. Not only because of privacy and ethical issues, but because if you can't fully control the content and the service which issues DRM closes down you would simply lose everything you paid for. It should be a deal breaker. Then pirating that content will be the only option to get it back. This Xkcd applies to video pretty much the same way as to audio for which it was made: http://xkcd.com/488 http://xkcd.com/488
- smtddr 13y agoUnless we're talking about Win8-BIOS-TPM stuff(which I don't clearly understand just yet), I don't think proper(non-remote-controllable) DRM is a privacy concern. I'm not sure how it's an ethical concern either. But, I do think that if the DRM servers and/or media streaming servers are going offline and making the content disappear forever they should allow it to just be downloaded without DRM for free - since turning off the servers implies they're done making money off it(?).
- shmerl 13y agoWhen Netflix (or any other DRMed code) runs on your machine, it runs as a black box for you. Why isn't that a privacy concern and why should it ever be trusted? It's unethical because it's an overreaching preemptive policing, but it's a long subject. > do think that if the DRM servers and/or media streaming servers are going offline and making the content disappear forever they should allow it to just be downloaded without DRM for free They may be "should" allow it, but they will never do at that point. They have more important problems to care about when they close down. So it's our obligation as responsible users to demand DRM free content from them right away, and avoid those who refuse to sell such.
- nemothekid 13y agoIts hard to say if we'll ever get DRM free streaming. Unlike the music industry, the tv/film industry isn't being crippled by piracy - in fact the tv/film industry only seems to be getting bigger. Simply put, there is no motivation for DRM streaming and DRM still remains a way for studios to keep control on who and when is licensing their content. Talking to some media execs, I was surprised to learn the reason most DRM is implemented is because for some content deal, the contract stated (which was written 6-8 years ago), said the player must have DRM. Now that the content landscape is getting even more fierce (with networks like CBS cancelling service to TimeWarner) no one wants to risk renegotiating anything. Now what motivation does Netflix have to remove their DRM? They want you on their platform, so they can collect your data. The next Netflix that even has a chance of running it legal will probably incorporate ads into their monthly pay product like Hulu does, which isn't at all surprising considering a huge chunk of revenue for these guys comes from advertising. I'm not hopeful about DRM-free streaming. The tv/film industry is much different from the music industry. From a consumer POV, the biggest difference is streaming wins over downloading. There is less of a demand for DRM free content because people simply aren't looking to copy their mp3s to their iPod/Zune/MP3 Player of choice. The Film industry has a much tighter control on how the content is delivered.
- shmerl 13y ago>Now what motivation does Netflix have to remove their DRM? They want you on their platform, so they can collect your data. If they don't even hide their intentions in abusing DRM to violate their users' privacy, it should only strengthen the reasons to avoid Netfilx like services. I'm hopeful for DRM free digital video. It will take one distributor to break this sick trend. Netflix isn't the one with guts to do it.
- yalogin 13y agoRegular people do not give a fuck about DRM. They just want to watch good content. As long as the DRM is non-obtrusive it does not matter. Why is it important to have DRM free content?
- shmerl 13y ago"Regular" people give away their private info to Facebook as well. Most do this kind of stuff because they don't realize the implications, not because they think that it's really OK to do that. Sure, some might not care at all, but most simply have no clue. Unobtrusive DRM is actually even worse than obtrusive one, precisely because people might think that it's acceptable. It's like having hidden cameras in people's houses, and them getting comfortable with it, because they don't see it.
- yalogin 13y agoWhat has sharing personal information on facebook got to do with DRM? What does an informed person have against DRM if it lets him use the content anyway they want to consume it (e.g. netflix)? I am just trying to understand what the complaint specifically is.
- shmerl 13y ago> What has sharing personal information on facebook got to do with DRM? It was a comment on "regular" people. I.e. their acceptance of Facebook's disrespect to their privacy often comes from them being clueless. Same thing with acceptance of DRM which you brought above. People don't think. > What does an informed person have against DRM Informed person doesn't trust DRM, and doesn't proliferate it by supporting distributors who push it on people. See the whole discussion above. No point to repeat the explanations.
- Apocryphon 13y agoIsn't Steam, another great success story about a business model that prevents piracy, a distributor that uses DRM?