3 ms·
Your arguments for a BIG apply equally well to a BJG, if not more so. If the basic jobs include socially beneficial activities, BJG provides an even greater in
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Your arguments for a BIG apply equally well to a BJG, if not more so.
If the basic jobs include socially beneficial activities, BJG provides an even greater incentive for those activities than a BIG.
A BJG is also a cash transfer, but with a single qualification process. Show up, do work, get paid. This reduces waste because you gain the product of people's work. With a BIG, Waste = transfers + admin overhead + disincentivized work. With BJG, Waste = transfers + admin overhead + disincentivized work - product of basic jobs.
Similarly, the BJG would eliminate poverty and ensure a life-long minimum earning level.
As for your hypothetical future where human labor is unnecessary, we'll switch to a BIG when we get there.
The preference for a Basic Income over a Basic Job is a moral one - most of the proponents of Basic Income believe people should be able to subsist on the fruits of other's labor if they choose not to work.
- vasilipupkin 13y agoBasic Job is worse because some individuals cannot get jobs simply because they are not productive enough - forcing them upon employees would be worse for the economy than giving them an income to live on
- ihateloggingin 13y agoThey don't, actually. "socially beneficial activities that are not compensated" -- doesn't apply equally well. "most efficiently delivered through a direct cash transfer, rather than through a means-tested or other qualification-based process" -- doesn't apply equally well. "no minimum wage would be necessary to reduce poverty" -- doesn't apply equally well. "ensuring a life-long minimum earnings level for individuals" -- doesn't apply equally well. "the economy itself will not be able to adapt in creating new labor opportunities" -- doesn't apply equally well. Amazingly, that's each and every point. Not a single one applies equally well.
- olalonde 13y agoI think your assumption that government can provide guaranteed (productive) jobs to everyone at any time is dead wrong. This sounds much more like a communist nightmare then BIG does as it would almost certainly introduce a massive dysfunctional bureaucracy to manage all those jobs.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI don't expect all the jobs to be productive. Some will, some won't. The productive jobs will generate returns, while the unproductive ones (e.g., digging and refilling holes) will merely serve as a disincentive for people to use the BJG. The disincentive is important - the goal of the BJG is that ideally, no one will use it. Unlike a BIG, laziness is no longer an option.