4 ms·
>I believe with basic guarantee many people who are unemployed would start working. Social security in many countries mean that it's rational to either work man
by dnautics 13y ago
>I believe with basic guarantee many people who are unemployed would start working. Social security in many countries mean that it's rational to either work many hours per week or work zero hours per week. Basic income means that every hour worked or dollar earned increases your standard of living, thus creating a higher incentive to work.
I am what in the US you would consider a "strong libertarian" - and I would say, I would be in favor of instituting a basic income if we got rid of the minimum wage.
- innguest 13y agoSeconded. I'm also a believer in basic income as an otherwise staunch libertarian, purely based on how much sense it makes.
- ballard 13y agoUnder-the-table arrangements are like the majority of BitTorrent traffic, economies that occur despite rules because there is net utility. People still pay taxes and still license (not own) retail movies.
- incompatible 13y agoA basic income would hardly be libertarian. Although I also tend to libertarian, I do see a role for government in addressing cases of market failure, or where the market fails to meet certain moral standards. An example would be if somebody working in the best job they can find doesn't earn enough to pay for basic accommodation and food. The government would provide the safety net in this case. However there must still be some incentive for people in this situation to try and find better work (or perhaps move to a better location). Otherwise, you have people simply taking whatever job they find the most enjoyable, living off the government subsidy, and leaving other less desirable jobs unfilled(paying slightly better, so according to the market more important, but leaving the employee no better off due to the government subsidy.) It's particularly silly with the current system that you can legally work for nothing, be a volunteer or an unpaid intern, but you can't work for $1 per hour. If you make low paid work illegal, you make the low paid unemployed. Perhaps some day all of this "scarcity economics" will be moot, if we could invent the star-trek style replicator, I suspect "work" would move to a volunteer model.
- neltnerb 13y agoA basic income is libertarian in that it allows individuals to actually participate in the free market as rational actors, and puts control over use into the hands of many individuals instead of in the hands of the government. I think eliminating the minimum wage is reasonable combined with a guaranteed stipend. However, I think you will find that "undesirable" jobs are (rightfully) paid quite well. Possibly even better than now since this system would better balance the power between employers and employees. http://bit.ly/16o33Bp http://bit.ly/16o33Bp
- ihateloggingin 13y agoAh, but it's not libertarian in the sense of total sovereignty for owners. The workers would start to backtalk!
- saraid216 13y ago> Otherwise, you have people simply taking whatever job they find the most enjoyable, living off the government subsidy, and leaving other less desirable jobs unfilled What's wrong with this, honestly? If less desirable jobs go unfilled, I'd expect that people would find ways to mitigate the need for human beings in those jobs. Let's let the market figure out what those jobs are and if we can do such mitigation. That seems preferable to the current situation, where people such as yourself say that we need people to be placed into explicitly undesirable positions. Let's actually see this problem before we anticipate it.
- incompatible 13y ago> Let's actually see this problem before we anticipate it. The problem has always existed. It's the reason that people need to be paid for most jobs, since they won't do them just for fun. If people know that they'll be paid a decent amount for doing any job at all, then there will be a lot of recreational activities which are thinly disguised to look like jobs.
- krfsm 13y ago
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI'm a Groucho-Marxist, so I refuse to be a member of any club that will have me, however it is nice to find something I agree with you on :)
- telephonetemp 13y agoSpeaking of Groucho-Marxism: http://sniggle.net/Manifesti/groucho.php http://sniggle.net/Manifesti/groucho.php.
- shawndumas 13y agoI am what most would call a conservative and if what was being offered was a complete elimination of all social services, entitlements, and government largess, then count me in. I would much rather a BI than having this menacingly powerful centralized vote buying machine.