3 ms·
Other than adding the fear of famine, I'm not sure how different that is from today. Fear of disease? Check. Both realistic (as in, the huge fraction with no
by VLM 13y ago
Other than adding the fear of famine, I'm not sure how different that is from today.
Fear of disease? Check. Both realistic (as in, the huge fraction with no/minimal health insurance or any dental at all). And unrealistic, like fearmongering politicians (as in, send lots of money to X or we'll all die of some made up thing)
Bouts of warfare, check. Both actual for kids in .mil, and imaginary daydreams of terrorism.
Inferior diet? Check.
The personal hygiene thing, I donno about. I'm not so foul but seems like many people are allergic to soap and water, and others who think smelling like an ashtray is a perfume.
- btilly 13y agoSorry, but if you think that we have equivalent fear of disease then and now, you don't know what life was like then. How many people did you personally know who died of disease as a kid? I knew one. (Cancer.) But this was a period where people would have 8 kids in the hope that 2-3 of them would survive to adulthood. And disease was the big killer.
- VLM 13y agoNow your whole family is merely bankrupt and homeless if you need medical care, unless you are one of the lucky fraction with insurance or live in a civilized country. I lived without medical insurance for awhile in my 20s. Its not some picnic.
- btilly 13y agoI remember running across estimates that in Europe in the 1700s, 20-30% of the population was permanently displaced, and a large portion of those were bound to die unpleasant deaths. (Starvation and death through violence both ranking high.) This was not considered exceptional - this was considered an inevitable and unexceptional fact of life that nobody could change. There would be good years. There were also bad. For bad consider that during the 1300s the population of much of Europe dropped by half due to climate changing the carrying capacity. (The Black Death didn't help either.) Despite a reproduction rate that was much higher than todays. I submit that your idea of "not some picnic" is MASSIVELY nicer than what was accepted as daily reality.
- foobarian 13y agoDon't forget about a significant chance of dying or losing limb from any simple cut.
- hfsktr 13y agoWhat I find amazing is how recently things like germs[1] were given real attention. I'd heard about Ignaz Semmelweis from a book I read and to think less than 200 years ago you would go to a hospital and they didn't bother to wash their hands between patients? Now maybe it was just the hospital in Vienna, but I imagine many were like that. Just the things that are taken for granted as common sense now before they were. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germ_theory_of_disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germ_theory_of_disease
- btilly 13y agoIt is worse than that. Ignaz Semmelweis did not come to broader attention. It was not until Joseph Lister (the Lister in "Listerine") independently discovered this and popularized it that the English speaking world became aware of how they were killing people. I have encountered mention of memoirs from US surgeons who were most distressed to have learned, shortly after the Civil War, how their failure to take simple sanitation measures was responsible for the death of many of their patients through gangrene. Within living memory we had a similar shock from antibiotics. I remember an older professor telling me about a doctor he knew who had been unable to save his brother, but would have been able to do so a few years later. I am sure there are still things out there like this. Heck, I lost my nephew because my sister followed her doctor's instructions to have him sleep on his stomach...less than 6 months before the American Academy of Pediatrics switched the recommendation to putting babies on their backs to reduce the odds of SIDS. If you've taken a parenting course in the last 20 years, sleeping babies on their back probably just seems like common sense to you.
- dredmorbius 13y agoThe amount of progress in knowledge and technology in the past 200-250 years or so (pretty much all of the Industrial Revolution) really is staggering. Take someone from 1750, drop him in the world of 1500, and things would have been pretty familiar. Move 250 years in the other direction and he'd be hard-pressed to make heads or tails of anything (assuming you're taking someone from a part of the developed world -- for the developing world, the changes would be less pronounced, but still likely significant).
- rsynnott 13y ago> Other than adding the fear of famine Er, that's a pretty huge other. > Fear of disease? Check. Both realistic (as in, the huge fraction with no/minimal health insurance or any dental at all). As far as the developed world goes, that's largely restricted to the US. And, of course, most of the diseases that killed people back then can be treated with a few euro worth of penicillin. > Bouts of warfare, check. Both actual for kids in .mil, and imaginary daydreams of terrorism. It's highly unlikely that the neighbouring lord will burn your village in the developed world today, however. > Inferior diet? Check. Not really on the same level. Even those who got enough food often had severe malnutrition issues. Nowadays, some people have poor diets; in the developed world this is largely a function of personal choice.