5 ms·
Platonic Solids - Why Five?
- gus_massa 13y agoIn 4D there are 6, the five expected ones and an additional strange version of the octahedron. In 5D and more, there are only 3, the equivalents of the tetrahedron, cube and octahedron.
- stephencanon 13y agoI wouldn't really call the 24-cell "a strange version" of the octahedron. It really isn't anything like any of the 3d Platonic solids. (It does have octahedral faces, though.)
- oscilloscope 13y agoHere's a 24-cell you can explore: http://fleetinbeing.net/hypersolid/examples/24cell.html http://fleetinbeing.net/hypersolid/examples/24cell.html It doesn't bring out the cells or faces, but it does show edges in parallel coordinates. Edges show up as multi-points in the plot below. Above is a 3-d projection of the 24-cell which you can click+drag to rotate.
- gregfjohnson 13y agoAs the article points out, it is easy to see that there are at most five platonic solids in 3 dimensions. One thing I've wondered about is why all five possibilities actually work. As an example, consider the icosahedron. You could imagine trying to build one as follows. Take five equilateral triangles, and attach them together so that they meet at one vertex and the respective sides adjacent to the vertices are shared. This gives you a sort of cap-like shape consisting of the five triangles. How, attach more triangles to the cap as above. This will create a strip of 10 triangles around the "equator". Then, keep adding more triangles. This step will end up creating another cap at the bottom of the icosahedron. The question is, why do things inevitably match up on the bottom if you fill things in this way? You can do the same construction with 3, 4, or 5 triangles, 3 squares, or 3 pentagons, and in all cases things line up exactly to give you a complete polyhedron.
- T-hawk 13y agoOne answer: Things don't inevitably match up on the bottom. The tetrahedron is the counterexample. Constructing it based around one vertex as you describe (call it the north pole) does not result in a matching cap around the south pole. Of course, the gap around the south pole is still congruent to the three original triangles. It must be by the rules of Platonic solids, because the other three vertices must each behave identically to the original north pole, meaning the south-pole-centered triangle must be identical to the other triangles. Here's a more general answer. The solid always has N-way radial symmetry when viewed from above any vertex, such as our north pole. All longitude lines at 360°/N intervals are identical from this method of construction. There is nothing to differentiate the triangle of your icosahedron on the 0° meridian from its counterpart at 72°, so they will all fall into the same relationship with the south pole. The polygons can't overlap the south pole from one direction while falling short from another. In the tetrahedron, the south pole gets overlapped equally from all three radial directions. In the other four solids, the edges and faces meet exactly at the south pole. I can't answer exactly why that last sentence is true. It reduces to, why does this construction method always produce symmetry across the equator for the four non-tetrahedron solids? Your strip of 10 triangles on the icosahedron: if that is indeed equatorial, then we have both latitudinal and longitudinal symmetry which renders your north and south hemispheres identical so things will match up. But why does that strip of 10 triangles end up centered on the equator? I do not have the answer to that, but maybe someone does.
- jfarmer 13y agoThis seems backwards to me. It's not as though things "line up" magically, but rather there's enough "wiggle room" to allow things line up. It's similar to me to saying that given three non-negative integers A, B, and C, you can form a triangle with side lengths A, B, and C if and only if the sum of any two numbers is greater than the third. "Why" this is the case is best understood by seeing what happens when it doesn't hold. Or, another way would be to take two line segments attached at the end, fix one, and rotate the other. As you rotate, draw a line between the endpoint of one segment and the other. The range of lengths of this third side is going to be the permissible range of lengths for any third side length and it's going to be "largest" when the two original line segments have a 180º angle between them (i.e., their sum). But I think for plenty of people this wouldn't suffice to answer the question "why." It could still seem like a "happy accident." This is always the tricky thing with why questions -- what constitutes an explanation for one person is entirely unsatisfactory to another.
- jonsen 13y agoYou could say the sixth is an infinitely large one made of regular hexagons.
- T-hawk 13y agoBy that method, there's eight. Also included would be the constructions of regular triangles meeting six at a vertex, and regular squares meeting four at a vertex.
- jonsen 13y agoYes, and the triangular infinihedron forms a dual pair with the hexagonal infinihedron. The quadratic infinihedron is its own dual, as the tetrahedron is. (Polyhedronal duality: Surface midpoints are vertices of the dual. Ex: The six surface midpoints of a cube are the six vertices of a regular octahedron; and vice versa.)
- nickzoic 13y agoIt occurs to me that (per the second argument) these have Schläfli symbol {s,m} = {6,3}, {3,6} and {4,4} ... for each of these, working out 1/s + 1/m - 1/2 = 1/E gives 1/E = 0 ... which makes sense (kind of) since those three cases are infinite regular tilings instead of regular polyhedra ... (EDIT: Just noticed jonsen's comment here too, "infinihedron" suddenly makes sense to me :-) )
- kazagistar 13y agoThat does not work, the sum of infinite zeroes is still zero.
- samatman 13y agoIt doesn't have to be infinitely large. It could simply be on a bounded manifold. And as another commenter noted, there are eight by this criterion.
- danbee 13y agoThe sixth is a teapot.
- ravich2_7183 13y agoThanks for posting. Now I get why Kepler was hell bent on trying to fit the orbits of the 5 known planets (at his time) with the 5 platonic solids [1]. This part of Kepler's life is very nicely depicted in Carl Sagan's Cosmos [2]. It seemed interesting when I watched it, but I didn't give it much thought back then. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johannes_Kepler#Mysterium_Cosmographicum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johannes_Kepler#Mysterium_Cosmo... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PLBA8DC67D52968201&feature=player_detailpage&v=ICHDl0olsS0#t=2007 https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PLBA8DC67D52968201&featur...