4 ms·
Having had to deal with a little COBOL now and then, I wonder whether English words are really what makes for readability. I am reminded of something that Jacqu
by cafard 13y ago
Having had to deal with a little COBOL now and then, I wonder whether English words are really what makes for readability. I am reminded of something that Jacques Barzun wrote long ago about English, that it is the density of the thought, not the length of the words, that makes for difficulty in reading.
- cam_l 13y agoTo enlarge on your (really good) point.. We also have the capacity in english to substantially reduce the overhead of thought density. We do this by using symbols or signifiers (words or phrases) which refer to oft repeated concepts, allowing us to build more complex meanings without having to consciously process every part. This idea of density of thought can be expressed more specifically as both uniqueness and complexity of thought. Conceptually, programming is communication, and all communication is essentially semantic. Though not being a programmer, I reckon the broader conceptual difficulties with programming are in the need for context, and with the necessity for specificity. Which, by the way, english is not that brilliant at either (just more flexible). It is instructive in the context of this discussion to remember that semantics rely as much on the experience and understanding of the listener, as on the speaker / writer.
- jloughry 13y agoI did something like that once for a truly awful machine-language-like system I had to work with at a bank: 8607,,,1 11547,15475,22002,22002 1316,1629,1,1649 3001,1316,3,30078 11528,22052,22002,22002 9301,0,1528,1528 31568,10001,800,107 8560,,,1568 8550,210,, 3001,,, 3100,1316,3,30089 11547,15475,22002,22002 3001,1316,3,30089 3001,1317,3,10000 8400,,, 8550,700,801, 3001,,, 9301,0,522,522 3000,1284,3,10001 8500,,3, 8500,,5, 1547,,1,-2301 Through the translator, the result looked like this: https://github.com/jloughry/BANCStar/blob/master/README.md https://github.com/jloughry/BANCStar/blob/master/README.md The arrows in the margin duplicated the handwritten notation developed by programmers to deal with the numeric machine code. If a colour printer had been available at the time, it would have duplicated the highlighter pens those programmers used too; instead I used boldface, italics, underlining, and condensed characters to accomplish the same thing.
- gruseom 13y agoThat's classic! You should make a post out of that link—it's great HN material.
- jloughry 13y agoDone. We'll see what kind of shreds the HN community tears it into. This ought to be fun. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6311717 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6311717
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]