5 ms·
It always amuses me when, in the "Why aren't there more female coders?" debate, people try to push the notion that women aren't genetically suited for programmi
by danso 13y ago
It always amuses me when, in the "Why aren't there more female coders?" debate, people try to push the notion that women aren't genetically suited for programming. Programming isn't the Navy SEALS, where no woman has yet been admitted into the club for any variety of reasons...women were among programming's pioneers.
- nawitus 13y agoYour argument is not sound. If women are less "genetically" suited for programming, then that fact doesn't imply that there are no women programmers or that women couldn't have been programming's pioneers.
- danso 13y agoYou're not characterizing the debate correctly. The argument has primarily been over whether pressures in society and in industry have been unfavorable to women. Those who don't think this is the case sometimes argue, "Perhaps the fault is within women themselves". If that were the case, then we would indeed expect fewer women in tech. Just as if we eliminated gender from Olympic sports, there would be very few women at all competing, and pretty much none on the medal stands (except in sports that are mostly female only). But that is not the case with computing. You have women among the elite of their male peers and not just elite, but pioneers. And they did this during a time, mind you, when women's equality was much, much less of a belief than it is now.
- nawitus 13y ago>You're not characterizing the debate correctly. I did not attempt to. I clarified that your argument wasn't sound. My comment was not about the "general discource". >You have women among the elite of their male peers and not just elite, but pioneers. Eh. If women are not "genetically suited" for programming, then there can still be women among the "elite programmers and pioneers". By the way, the fact that many women were pioneers in programming was not related to ability, it seems to be mostly an economical decision, as keypunch operators were often female.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIf women are not "genetically suited" for programming, then there can still be women among the "elite programmers and pioneers". Statistically, it becomes much less likely. the fact that many women were pioneers in programming was not related to ability, it seems to be mostly an economical decision Tell that to Ada.
- nawitus 13y ago>Statistically, it becomes much less likely. Yes, I agree with that claim. >Tell that to Ada. Why? I said "mostly", referring to the era of modern computing. In addition, Ada Lovelace wasn't a pioneeri in programming, she was confused about the subject.
- LaGrange 13y agoOne of my biggest fears is that we can actually make that into truth. Fashion is powerful, and it's easy to google out problems women with the P word before their names can have dating. And it wouldn't be without other costs (if the vision of society where the imagined genetic differences became true wasn't bad enough): increasing the variation between sexes would mean far more complicated genetic code. That would almost certainly have hard to predict, weird costs. So far it doesn't seem to be happening, so I'll put that together with Peter Watts' fear that sentience is a side-product that will get optimized out, but still, it's a fear.
- Tichy 13y agoHow often is that "genetically unsuited" theory really pushed, though? I think it might be more a myth than reality ("people always try to argue with genetics").
- jacalata 13y agoI've seen it here, for example from half a dozen people just the other day, appearing as "but who says that the current representation of women in programming isn't the exact level it should be based on biological interest and ability? Where's the evidence that there is a societal pressure pushing women away and not just innate aversion to the field?"
- Tichy 13y agoI'll have to take your word for it - I missed that, and HN search doesn't turn up anything (looking for the phrase "innate aversion", sorted by date: https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/all&q=innate+aversion&sortby=create_ts+desc https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/all&q=innate+aversio... )
- jacalata 13y agoI paraphrased from memory, sorry - I was thinking of this thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6254218 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6254218
- aestra 13y agoWoman arent Navy SEALs for "any varity of reason?" No. Women arent Navy SEALs cause its against the law. http://www.navy.com/careers/special-operations/seals.html http://www.navy.com/careers/special-operations/seals.html "By law, only men are eligible to apply for the SEAL program"