4 ms·
"That changes things quite a bit. No reasonable person would believe the NSA authorized this. " Except that's not what the NSA would have to prove. The linked
by DannyBee 13y ago
"That changes things quite a bit. No reasonable person would believe the NSA authorized this.
"
Except that's not what the NSA would have to prove.
The linked law is actually quite clear here. It says " in a manner reasonably calculated to convey the impression".
They would not have to prove a reasonable person would believe the NSA authorized it, they only have to prove that the person making the shirt used the seal "in a manner reasonably calculated to convey the impression that such use is approved". ISTM the whole purpose of the shirt and it's parody is to convey the impression that such use was approved. The fact that it's a parody does not change that, it only changes whether the receiver is likely to view it as a joke.
In short, I don't believe a court would use a standard based on how the receiver viewed it, but instead how the shirt creator was trying to use the seal.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIf they are trying to use it in parody, then they are trying to use it in parody, not to convey that such use is approved. In fact, by the fact that it is intended to be a joke, it is explicitly not trying to convey that such use is approved, unless the NSA is well known for producing comedy items for public consumption.