4 ms·
When people in conversation say something that is trivially true, they generally mean something deeper. For example, consider the phrase, "It is what it is": h
by wpietri 13y ago
When people in conversation say something that is trivially true, they generally mean something deeper.
For example, consider the phrase, "It is what it is": http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/it_is_what_it_is http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/it_is_what_it_is
Logically, it's an obvious tautology. Idiomatically, it means, "This circumstance is simply a fact and must be accepted or dealt with as it exists."
So lightyrs was A) trying to say something substantive about the EFF, or B) making an incredibly obvious statement about the literal meaning "indisputable", which etfb clearly was using hyperbolically for effect. I think the charitable thing to do is to assume A, which is what siddboots did.
- lightyrs 13y agoYou seem to have come the closest to my actual meaning, while still missing a point of subtlety that perhaps I did not convey. Given your dichotomy, my statement would fall under the banner of B, however, what I am really driving at is the fallacy of the inherent trust that we tend to place in institutions and political actors that are supposedly 'on our side'. This is a vector that can be exploited and as such, must be minimized at every opportunity. I am playing the role of skeptic here to contribute to a mainline of skepticism that may serve to ultimately enhance the authority that the EFF asserts when they claim to 'speak for us'. You say this is 'obvious', however, I would argue that it can never be obvious enough and that it is not actually as obvious as you might think. I am very often bewildered by the trust people are willing to place in institutions. I am disturbed by this trust — by this weakening of the foundations of authority. My comment came from these emotional and intellectual underpinnings.