3 ms·
Would you say all data structures and complexity questions are bullshit? Mrainteaser / estimation questions? Is all coding bullshit, or only on whiteboards? Onl
by michaelt 13y ago
Would you say all data structures and complexity questions are bullshit? Mrainteaser / estimation questions? Is all coding bullshit, or only on whiteboards? Only coding algorithms from college? Is asking someone to code 'fizz buzz' bullshit? I'm interested to hear where you consider the boundaries to lie.
Or have I misread your post, and you mean something else?
- neumann 13y agoIt depends on who you want to hire. 1. Do you want a team member who can plan, investigate and research unforeseen problems, brainstorm and contribute to the code? Then the one on whiteboards is bullshit UNLESS it is a brainstorming question - with a laptop next to it - and you are both working on the problem together - and ideally neither of you know the answer. 2. Or does you company have a clear knowledge of what lines of code are needed to be written for the next 5 years. Then sure, go ahead and do the whiteboard interview. Or just train a monkey, at least they are cute and cheap. A whiteboard interview typically just tests memory recall under a stressed situation. It might be what you need if you require a hacker for a Die Hard sequel where there is only 90seconds to figure out how to line up the encrypted polycube nano-algorithm before nuclear meltdown is initiated. Or if you require a monkey.
- zainny 13y agoI think there's a very simple rule anyone can and should follow to not fuck up interviews: Don't ask people to do things in the interview you wouldn't expect them to do in the job. Examples: (1) Do people in this job regularly write code on the whiteboard? Lack access to a search engine? No. Then don't do it in the interview. (2) Do people in the job design spice racks for blind people? No. Then don't ask them to do this in the interview. (3) Do people in the job regularly find themselves coding something on the level of fizz buzz? Yes? Go ahead and ask! (4) Do people in the job regularly find themselves writing code to traverse linked lists? Find loops in graphs? Yes? Go ahead and ask. Verify people have the skills they need to do the job you're hiring for. It really really is as simple as that.