5 ms·
I don't know the particulars of the claims, but I do know that: 1 - the wsj is barely distinguishable from anti-government propaganda, so they're worthless: an
by x0x0 13y ago
I don't know the particulars of the claims, but I do know that:
1 - the wsj is barely distinguishable from anti-government propaganda, so they're worthless: any claims they make need to be verified with first party sources before belief;
2 - this happened:
Pediatric gastroenterology specialists responding to the survey reported
more than 80 children with magnet ingestion. Most patients required
endoscopy to remove the magnets or surgery to repair damage to the bowels.
Twenty-six children had bowel perforation; three needed major surgery to
remove a section of damaged intestine. [1]
[1] http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/09/120904100844.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/09/120904100844.ht...
- alextingle 13y ago> I don't know the particulars of the claims... You confess that you don't know anything about the subject at hand, > but I do know that... the wsj is barely distinguishable from anti-government propaganda but you're happy to throw around an ad hominem attack on the site that published the story. Right.
- x0x0 13y agoad hominem : rolleyes : known liars make all their analyses useless: you can't tell what crucial facts they elided or what quotes they selectively quoted; it's worse than uninformative, because you have to question every fact presented and go dig, as I said, for a first-party source to verify.
- graeme 13y agoThe WSJ's rep, last time I checked, was a solid newsroom, and a insane, frothing at the mouth editorial team, with a strict wall between the two. Any evidence for the idea that the news section of the WSJ is corrupted so absolutely that they cannot be relied on in any story?
- azm 13y agoUnfortunately this is in the Opinion section which has been known to be reliably frothing at the mouth, anti-goverment, ayn randian propaganda machine.
- graeme 13y agoOh, that does make a very big difference. I think it's trite to say 'ad hominem' in cases like this. Ad hominem refers to the quality of the reasoning. Here, we depend on the WSJ for the facts as well. If they are an untrustworthy source, that's very relevant.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alextingle 13y ago> you have to question every fact presented and go dig Isn't that true of every assertion of "fact"? Perhaps it's because I'm British. Our press make no attempt to hide their political views.
- jbjohns 13y agoInterestingly you just quoted the very definition of ad hominem. What someone tends to say makes no statement about their current argument. You can choose to dismiss them out of hand because they tend to lie, but to claim that what they are currently saying is false because they are liars is a fallacy. Remember the boy who cried wolf? The take away from that story should be that every statement has to be evaluated in isolation.
- lisper 13y ago> What someone tends to say makes no statement about their current argument. Not so. If someone has lied in the past, that is evidence that their conscience permits them to lie, and so they are more likely to lie in the future. > The take away from that story should be that every statement has to be evaluated in isolation. Again no. The takeaway is that you should not lie, because if you do people will be less likely to believe you in the future.
- jbjohns 13y ago> Not so. If someone has lied in the past Fine. It makes no conclusive statement about their current argument. You still have to check it if you want to know if it's true or not. > The takeaway is that you should not lie, because if you do people will be less likely to believe you in the future. This is the over simplified view of the story. In my opinion, the subsequent attack on the village was 100% the fault of the others. The boy did his job and warned them of a wolf and they engaged in an ad hominem and dismissed his argument without even a cursory check. If they weren't willing or able to work with the boy then it's their fault again for giving him a job they didn't trust him to do.
- lisper 13y agoYou need to brush up on your Bayesian reasoning. In the story, the boy lies repeatedly before finally telling the truth once. If you do the math you will see that the villagers acted properly (or at least rationally). The Bayesian prior on P(wolf) is pretty small to begin with, and the posterior probability of P(wolf|boy-cries-wolf) gets smaller with every observation of ~wolf|boy-cries-wolf. You are being distracted by the fact that the data comes from a boy rather than an impersonal predictor like, say, some astrological sign. Your Bayesian prior on P(X|someone-says-X) is high, and that is as it should be. Evolution sees to it that people are basically honest. But evolution produces a lot of variation, including pathologies like lying. You're failing to update your estimate of P(Y-is-a-pathological-liar|Y-lied).
- redthrowaway 13y agore 2: So? Kids hurt themselves and swallow dumb things all the time. It's your job as a parent to keep those things away from them. It's not the government's job, and it's certainly not the manufacturer's job.
- HarryHirsch 13y agoProof by insistence? In a different time Upton Sinclair published The Jungle, and that book set the forces in motion that gave the country inspection of meat products and also the FDA. I do realize that there are problems with that public authority, nevermind that it is intentionally underfunded, but no public oversight of the food and drug supply would be even worse. We know that for a fact, because we have seen it.
- shrnky 13y ago- Their authority the problem. Increasingly authoritarian being the issue. - As they should be underfunded. Keeps their power in check.
- derleth 13y ago> As they should be underfunded. Keeps their power in check. No, changing laws keeps their power in check. Underfunding them simply makes them less effective and more arbitrary.
- sneak 13y agoThis is not a food or a drug.
- redthrowaway 13y agoThat's regulation ensuring products are safe when used as intended, not regulation ensuring products can't be used unsafely. It's a key difference. The government should ensure bottled water is free from E. coli. It shouldn't ensure you can't drown in it.
- fennecfoxen 13y ago2. The fact that this happened is in fact quite relevant to the product's regulation, but there are larger issues here about the way that the regulators actually interact with regulated entities (e.g. suits that a skeptic may worry are motivated by revenge, attempts to tear down the limited-liability structure underpinning the modern corporation's ability to interact effectively with the economy) 1. The WSJ, reporting on things which could affect Business in the general case, is opinionated, but - that notwithstanding - generally quite reliable, doubly so by news-organization standards. That's why they're still in business. That said, I am awed at some of the screed that makes it to their Review and Outlook opinion section (the pro-SOPA piece which was nearly slanderous in impugning the motives of the likes of Jimmy Wales comes to mind) and can express a modicum of sympathy. In the meantime, while you're consulting the government agencies in question for your "first-party sources", here is some third-party coverage, which is also opinionated but does have more citations. http://www.wlf.org/upload/legalstudies/legalbackgrounder/08-23-13MillarBiszko_LB.pdf http://www.wlf.org/upload/legalstudies/legalbackgrounder/08-...
- tracker1 13y agoA quick search of: kid swallow lego Returns about 1.9 million results on google, I'm guessing more kids swallow legos, where is the recall order there?
- spc476 13y agoTwo things: 1) Lego bricks are targeted at a specific age group (there's a reason why Duplo blocks are larger, and thus, targeted at a younger age group) 2) Lego bricks aren't attracted to each other and burrow through soft tissue to meet. Buckyballs, made of rare earth magnets, are attracted to each other and can cause tissue damage if two or more are swallowed. Granted, Lego bricks might cause irritation going through the digestive system, but not nearly cause the damage that rare earth magnets can.
- Qantourisc 13y ago2) Unless you have a gastric bypass they should be attracted to each-other in the stomach, before going anywhere where you can squeeze stuff, well assuming they where eaten during the same time. Also I think the sharp edges are a thread, if they go trough wrong, I think there is a risk of it ripping apart the gut. BUT I'm not a doctor. Of course there is the simple solution of not buying unsafe toys (or letting kids play unsupervised.)
- CatMtKing 13y agoThe stomach wall is a possible point of damage as well, with its many soft tissue folds...
- spc476 13y agoYou might think, but no, they might not necessarily attract each other in the stomach. An ex-girlfriend's kid ate two magnets (http://boston.conman.org/2006/01/12.1 http://boston.conman.org/2006/01/12.1) and they ended up separating, then attracting each other in different parts of the body (http://boston.conman.org/2006/01/20.1 http://boston.conman.org/2006/01/20.1).
- angersock 13y agoLinked report is cool, but a rough skimming doesn't peg it at 80 kids for this product, just these small neodymium magnets in general.