3 ms·
> The author's points about the iPad seem pretty accurate. I can't even imagine how I would go from having an iPad as a high school student to stumbling into pr
by zokier 13y ago
> The author's points about the iPad seem pretty accurate. I can't even imagine how I would go from having an iPad as a high school student to stumbling into programming.
Funny, I thought the exact opposite; I agreed on the general point, but found the arguments against iPad bit weak. First of all they were factually incorrect. As others have demonstrated there are plenty of apps that allow programming the iPad in a way that is at least comparable to TIBASIC. You don't need developer accounts or review processes to use those apps.
More importantly the author missed the part that iPad is essentially just a platform, a tabula rasa if I may say so. As it does not provide any educational features on its own (afaik) some apps need to be provided by the school. And those apps provide the discoverability aspect that is missing from a vanilla iPad. It is reasonable to think that school would provide/require an app (or a collection of apps) that would be an equal or surpass the features of a graphing calc, including the programming features.
Of course I'm not really sure what educational apps are currently available, if they are adequate. But if not, then that would actually be something that HNers could do something about.
- cpleppert 13y agoThe difference with TI's calculator was there was a social motivation/aspect to programming them. Everyone had them and it was very easy to get started.There are programming environments for the iPad but it is a lot harder to share programs as not everyone has one and even if they do they need another level of indirection to get the program. The calculator is also much more prevalent/easy to use in the classroom. My first program was a quadratic equation solver that everyone at my school used. I remember a couple people tried to imitate and improve on my program but I crushed them with new features and a better interface. I don't think I could do that with the iPad. The technology is also a lot more complex and daunting with the iPad. You have the paradox of choice in choosing how you want to program it. You can't easily share programs with others and TIBasic, just due to its simplicity and the lack of design knowledge and effort for the user interface is a lot easier for a kid to pick up and start using. One thing that isn't mentioned in the article is that if you wanted direct control over the screen you had to program in assembly; I don't even think they had programming language support for it at the time. It made it a lot harder to use than the regular TiBasic.
- mtdewcmu 13y agoYou also needed a special cable to upload software written in assembly onto the calculator. I started teaching myself Z80 assembly in order to program the TI-85, but I never got the cable, so I never got to try it.
- lightcatcher 13y ago>As others have demonstrated there are plenty of apps that allow programming the iPad in a way that is at least comparable to TIBASIC. Although the power to program exists on the iPad, the chance of "just stumbling into it" is very low. The magic of programming on the TI was that although the device had some value with no custom programs, someone with no programming experience could greatly increase the capabilities of the device with a little bit of code. Everyone at some point made the basic quadratic equation program. Some people would make more complicated programs and maybe even start to write games. Programs were also extremely easy to run on the calculators. The critical difference between the iPad and the TI-83 when it comes to programming is how much utility you get out of your first hour programming the device.
- zokier 13y ago> Although the power to program exists on the iPad, the chance of "just stumbling into it" is very low That would depend highly on what software is provided/required on the iPad by the school.