3 ms·
Sorry. Let me try to make it relevant: (1) I think it’s great to give kids general-purpose tools for unstructured hacking. There’s enormous pedagogical value f
by jacobolus 13y ago
Sorry. Let me try to make it relevant:
(1) I think it’s great to give kids general-purpose tools for unstructured hacking. There’s enormous pedagogical value for every person in learning to think procedurally, break things down into parts, debug algorithms, and explore mathematical systems. Every teacher should read Mindstorms.
(2) General purpose computers are nowadays really great for this, if the proper programming environments get set up on them. They have awesome screens for displaying neat graphics. They have reasonable keyboards for quickly typing in code and numbers and symbols. They have amazing CPUs and GPUs which can crunch numbers like nobody’s business.
(3) I think we should start kids programming at age 5-8 with a tool like Scratch or Logo or I dunno what, but something designed and tested on children, with good sets of materials and curricula set up to teach them to do exploratory programming.
(4) I think at some point students should be given tools which give them low-level access to hardware, like I dunno an Arduino or something. These things are getting to be $20-30 now, and it’s possible to use them for all sorts of nifty stuff and learn how to operate on constrained systems and twiddle bits in memory and whatever supposed advantage a TI calculator would offer, if that’s the goal.
(5) Many people don’t use tablet computers (or other computers) in math courses in school in a very pedagogically sound way, and a lot of software used in schools is terrible. (Giving access to open-ended exploratory systems is much better than giving access to one-purpose constrained tools.) This is too bad, because big color multitouch displays are really nice input/output devices for many purposes.
(6) It’s all well and good that the original author and many other people had a nice experience programming a TI calculator as a way to stave off boredom in math class, or whatever. But TI graphing calculators were overpriced and outdated and frankly pretty crappy relative to other devices people used 10 years ago, as long as we get the right software on those devices. By now it’s just ridiculous. Making people type BASIC into a calculator using tiny buttons and a little monochrome screen is not the right way to introduce mathematics, or programming, or anything else.
- dylangs1030 13y agoRegarding your 3), I think Python would be really good for this. Then they could graduate to C and lisp. Also, I strongly agree with your 6). A small, monochrome screen was very painful to look at on my TI-83 when I was in school. I hated it (I also programmed it, but didn't have nearly as much fun as the author..I didn't think it was that cool).
- jlgreco 13y ago(2) General purpose computers are nowadays really great for this, if the proper programming environments get set up on them. They have awesome screens for displaying neat graphics. They have reasonable keyboards for quickly typing in code and numbers and symbols. They have amazing CPUs and GPUs which can crunch numbers like nobody’s business. This has never really not been the case. The merits of calculator programming have always been despite (or arguably, because) of their technical inferiority.
- wowaname 13y agoIn response to point six, TI made it so you didn't have to type out "if" or "end" over and over; there are tokens for each of those calls, and remembering the number shortcuts in the menu is fairly easy. It is painful to only be able to read seven lines of code, sixteen characters apiece, at the same time, and the scrolling is horrible, but it does a pretty good job at what it's supposed to do. And there are plenty ways to extend or change the functionality of the calculator to make it easier to use and more customisable.
- angersock 13y agoThe 83 calculator was rugged, had great battery life, was programmable even in the simplest of ways, and basically kicked ass at its niche--remaining useful even through senior year of mechanical engineering at my college. I'm sorry it's not sexy and shiny, but the thing represents an excellent optimization for price, durability, speed, and utility. The fact is that the 83 is basically the AK47 of the calculator world--ugly, old, outdated, and utterly fantastic at what it sets out to do. You seem to overlook the fact that while we've got these great general-purpose tools for doing computation, the 83 is first and foremost a graphing calculator. It handles basic statistics quite well, handles graphing and intercepts okay, and as a bonus has a very simple and robust programming interface. Raspberry Pis and Arduinos and OLPCs are cool and all, but in terms of just giving kids the basic tools they need to solve adult problems soonest, they fail. EDIT: I'm not saying I think they still need to be $100 a pop--a design refresh to get them down to more modest prices wouldn't hurt, but still.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]