5 ms·
How Two Newspaper Reporters Helped Free an Innocent Man
- danso 13y agoSo the wrongly accused man was physically in jail at the reported time of the murder, and yet the system moved forward to imprison him for nearly two decades...because of this: > There was a lot at stake for the detectives, who said all eight defendants had confessed. Because all of them had implicated Daniel in the murders, if Daniel’s confession were to fall apart, the rest of the case would be in jeopardy. I think this is a sobering anecdote to remember when wondering why a bureaucratic decision has been made despite flying in the face of pure logic and science.
- md224 13y agoSeriously. > A check showed that, in fact, Daniel had been arrested for fighting in a park that night at about 6:45 p.m., and jail records showed he was released about 10 p.m. and the murders occurred at 8:43 p.m. That should've been the end of it. The. End. How did NO ONE involved in the mechanics of this case (the judge, lawyers, etc.) note this fact and immediately release him? Were they relying on the fallibility of police records? Did they say "oh, well, it says he was in jail but maybe the clock was off"? Is there a counter-fact being withheld here? I just seriously don't understand how something this clear-cut could've escaped everyone's attention. It hurts my brain.
- frogpelt 13y agoIt would probably help to live there and do the job of an investigator. I would imagine (since I don't live there or do the job) that they learn to see vey few people in certain neighborhoods as truly innocent. If you feel that all of the people you charge have gotten away with crimes in the past then it may not seem like a big deal to put them in prison. It may seem like you are cleaning up the neighborhood.
- cobrausn 13y agoSo, when a prosecutor / detective blatantly ignores contradictory evidence and end up putting an innocent person in jail, why do we not treat that as a crime? There are a number of obvious cynical answers to this, but seriously, does anyone know of prosecutors / detectives that have been charged in cases like this?
- rayiner 13y agoIt does happen, but its rare. You have to remember that the whole criminal justice system operates in the context of large numbers of guilty as fuck defendants who file endless appeals and petitions to get rock solid cases overturned. That's the rule, cases like Daniel's are the exception. So prosecutors and investigators have broad immunities, with high bars for overcoming them. Otherwise, they'd be constantly subject to litigation. Remember, this reporter got hundreds of letters from convicts and followed up on this one. Remember also that in real life, the facts aren't laid out for you like a newspaper article.
- cobrausn 13y agoWhen a review of a case finds that the prosecution knowingly withheld evidence that actually proved the client could not have been there, the facts pretty much speak for themselves. This should have led directly to criminal charges.
- rayiner 13y agoYou're focusing on one case instead of looking at the whole thing as a system. What's the standard of proof for establishing that it's knowing and not inadvertent? Who "finds" that the prosecution knowingly withheld evidence? You can't have official legal "findings" until you institute a law suit, so what's the bar for instituting a law suit and how do you set that bar high enough to keep prosecutors from being inundated with lawsuits by every criminal they put in jail? It's a cost-benefit analysis. What's the benefit of reducing the error rate of the system versus how much does it cost to achieve that reduction?
- m_myers 13y agoReminds me of the classic James Stewart film Call Northside 777 [1], about two Chicago men falsely imprisoned for a murder during Prohibition. The real-life case it was based on ([2]) hinged on a witness identification that occurred a day after the same witness had not recognized the suspect just after arrest; the police then recorded the suspect has having been arrested the second day and omitted the failure from the record. Both men stayed in prison until a newspaper reporter discovered the case, just as in this article; in fact, one of the men was not released until several years after the movie was made. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Call_Northside_777 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Call_Northside_777 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majczek_and_Marcinkiewicz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Majczek_and_Marcinkiewicz
- eCa 13y agoAnd "Hurricane" Carter: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubin_%22Hurricane%22_Carter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubin_%22Hurricane%22_Carter
- jere 13y agoI just listened to this last night: http://www.thestory.org/stories/2013-06/scott-hornoff http://www.thestory.org/stories/2013-06/scott-hornoff An innocent cop went to prison for 6 years until the murderer came forward with a confession. There was basically no evidence to put him away, but he was having an affair with the victim at the time, which made him suspect number one. The part that really upset me was that he was basically unemployable after he came out. He was awarded $600k in backpay when released, but $200k went to his lawyer and the rest to his ex-wife.
- lifeformed 13y agoI don't understand why people have to pay lawyers if they are found not guilty. At any time, I could be accused of anything at all, and regardless of being innocent, I lose boatloads of money from defending myself?
- sseveran 13y agoThats why most people plead guilty and don't go to court.
- aimhb 13y agoWhy would your lawyer even try to prove you innocent if it meant not getting a paycheck?
- lifeformed 13y agoI mean, have someone else pay for it. The accuser or the government.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nthj 13y agohttp://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_defender http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_defender
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kmfrk 13y agoAnother classic is Errol Morris's The Thin Blue line, which pioneered the reconstruction technique seen in many documentaries and non-fiction crime shows that followed.
- dredmorbius 13y agoAnyone know the content of the deleted comment?
- kmfrk 13y agoS/he was recommending Ken Burns's Central Park Five documentary that also reinvited scrutiny: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2380247/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2380247/.
- eksith 13y agoA sobering factoid : Cook County itself has had 92 known exonerations since 1989 – far more than any other county in the country — and, as we saw in 2001, it has a special affinity for false confessions. Nearly 40 percent of Cook County exonerations involved false confessions by the exonerated defendants (35 of 92), and an additional 16 percent were based on false confessions by codefendants. Can we start prohibiting confessions from admissible evidence now? I don't care how convincing the story is, unless the confession itself can lead to actual physical evidence, it should be completely discounted. Meanwhile, the prosecutor and the detectives involved are not charged with conspiracy.