3 ms·
IMO the solution is not keeping the top cryptographers, security experts, et al. out of the agency that is supposed to protect the country from the top cryptogr
by sliverstorm 13y ago
IMO the solution is not keeping the top cryptographers, security experts, et al. out of the agency that is supposed to protect the country from the top cryptographers and security experts from other countries. Seems like a flawed idea right from the start. You just need to make sure the people you hire are actually on your side.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoI disagree, the solution is more likely not doing anything morally questionable because the pool of talented people without morals is significantly shallower than the pool with, in my experience.
- john_b 13y agoThat may work in theory, but it's not always possible to know who's on your side. For an especially control-obsessed agency like the NSA that wants to know everything, this approach is completely unpalatable. Large institutions with sensitive information, whether public or private, generally don't know or trust their lower level employees (and a sysadmin is "lower level" in this context). They want solutions that prevent access by default. The NSA seems to have figured out that relying on sysadmins as a trusted party (a contracted trusted party, specifically) exposed a big hole in their ability to control things. It should have been obvious that contracting out a role that requires an extreme amount of trust was a bad idea, but large institutions often don't learn obvious lessons until someone makes them pay for their mistake.
- sliverstorm 13y agoI don't disagree with anything you've said about holes in security. I just think it's silly to say the solution is to hire stupider people.