10 ms·
Spy Kids
- 67726e 13y agoIf you get hit with a pay wall to read this article, just Google "spy_kids_nsa_surveillance_next_generation" and you should get the article as the first result. Then you can read it from there.
- cstross 13y agoIt's a development and expansion of my original argument, expressed here: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/08/snowden-leaks-the-real-take-ho.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/08/snowden-...
- DanI-S 13y agoThanks, Charles - for what is both an interesting take on the NSA's coming recruitment crisis and the best short range forecast of the evolution of Western culture I have yet to read.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoAs I noted on Reddit, at the very least you nailed your description of Gen Y. I was listening to featured-in-anime German-Japanese metal music just this morning ;-)!
- showerst 13y agoWe have HN whitelisted from the paywall, so if you click through from the link on this page you shouldn't see the paywall as long as you don't have any extensions that hide your referrer. If that's not the case, would you mind dropping me an email with your browser/version? tim.showers@foreignpolicy.com
- 67726e 13y agoMy mistake, the large subscription popup that appears on page load appeared to be a paywall to me. It does allow you to exit from it, though it had me a bit confused.
- showerst 13y agoAh, I can see how that would be confusing. That's a one time thing (cookie based, so if you clear or use private browsing you'll see it more often). Thanks for the update, HN traffic is valuable to us and often generates interesting discussion, so I want to ensure that the paywal is disabled for it =).
- ratsbane 13y agoI got the modal subscribe/login window also, though I don't immediately see anything to click to make it go away (without messing around in Firebug). The current browser I'm using is Firefox 23.0.1 on OS X. My UA string is Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10.7; rv:23.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/23.0 Thanks for speaking up. That's one of the great things about HN - primary sources standing by!
- wmeredith 13y agoYep. I got the same thing and just backed out.
- lifeformed 13y agoI thought that was the article itself for a moment... it was full screen and article shaped!
- shabble 13y agoWorks for me despite a global RefControl block, which is either a bug or feature :) (FF23+RefControl+NoScript+ABP)
- Amadou 13y agoThat's NoScript helping you out in this case.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoOne can only hope Charlie, one can only hope.
- finnh 13y agoCharlie's argument is that the vast majority of people growing up today will not have sufficient loyalty to "the state" to fill the ranks of the state's spy apparatus. While I find it persuasive that people's loyalty to institutions may be in decline, that population-wide generalization is not dispositive for the hiring ability of spy agencies. You don't need an entire generation of loyalists to fill out the NSA. You just need a couple percent, tops. And those people will always exist, helped along by talk-radio fear mongers who continually generate a stream of xenophobic, america-fuck-yeah types who will happily spy on their countrymen in exchange for that ever-elusive "secure job".
- ansible 13y agoAnd those people will always exist, helped along by talk-radio fear mongers who continually generate a stream of xenophobic, america-fuck-yeah types who will happily spy on their countrymen in exchange for that ever-elusive "secure job". I pity the fool who tries to build an effective agency out of those guys though. It will be a giant waste of money, and produce little of value to anyone. That's not to say that people won't try, however...
- echohack 13y agoYou mean the TSA?
- maxerickson 13y agoThey meant Uncle Sam.
- rev_null 13y agoI don't buy that the TSA is full of loyalists. I think it is mostly people who view it as a paycheck.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoFrom what I've read it seems that both Manning and Snowden were gung-ho patriots when they signed up. When they signed up. It seems in this end game the HR departments are better off picking the cynical, venal and power-hungry. At least they don't have the "disillusioned idealist" failure mode. But you may end up with a kakistocracy.
- ansible 13y agoThe USA, and by extension the three-letter agencies the implement it's policy has often been viewed as the World's policeman. If that's the case (and here we are about to stick our nose in Syria where it doesn't really belong), then it's time we started acting like real police. There's a whole bunch of rules for how police are supposed to act, how they determine suspects, how the collect evidence, and so on. It is well past time for the national agencies like the NSA to operate within clear (and public) guidelines similar to that. Then, if the NSA hires people who are loyal to the rules and the ideals of the work (rather than because of nationality or institutional loyalty), then it can operate effectively, without much fear of leakers like Snowden and Manning. I have no idea what it would take to reform these big institutions though. And I fear for the damage they (and those who oppose them) will cause before they are replaced by more effective agencies who are based around the old ideals of "Truth, Justice, and the American Way".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tsax 13y agoAh yes, "dog eat dog economic liberalism." And then people say Ayn Rand wrote caricatures. Infact, this phrase has been in decline, as it was used to buttress the industrial monopolization of the National Industrial Recovery Act in the New Deal as competition was considered harmful back in the 1930s.
- nakedrobot2 13y agoif you stop the page loading before it's finished, you can bypass that awful splash screen barrier.
- arethuza 13y agoAny time I think about loyalty to organisations or countries I am reminded of what E.M. Forster wrote in his essay "What I believe" in 1938: I hate the idea of causes, and if I had to choose between betraying my country and betraying my friend I hope I should have the guts to betray my country. Such a choice may scandalize the modern reader, and he may stretch out his patriotic hand to the telephone at once and ring up the police. It would not have shocked Dante, though. Dante places Brutus and Cassius in the lowest circle of Hell because they had chosen to betray their friend Julius Caesar rather than their country Rome. [NB It is also worth noting that Forster was an associate of the members of the infamous Soviet spy ring started at Cambridge - although this wouldn't become public until a long time after this essay was written.]
- finnh 13y agoThat's a great quote. I would hope that such a choice would not "scandalize" today's modern reader, as I don't think that nationalism is as strong today as it was in 1938. At least, not in the US. I hope. Which is basically Charlie's point, although he went ahead & worked it up into a theory ... a theory I don't think this foundation can quite support, per my post below.
- cafard 13y agoIt is also worth noting between the world wars Germany and Japan operated such that the rule of law, "country" if you will, counted for a good deal less than other loyalties. No doubt Forster was thinking of someone much more like himself, rather than of the assassins of Erzberger or of assorted Japanese Army putschists. The Weimar Republic, though, is probably a far better representation of a world run by the rules he proposes than the England of the late 1930s was.
- cynusx 13y agoThere are interesting thoughts in this article but talent is something that money can buy, ask the banks.
- hollerith 13y agoThe OP is about loyal talent, not talent alone, and banks do not acutely need loyalty in their employees to the degree that spy agencies do. For instance, they do not try to keep billion-dollar programs secret from the public.
- tonyg 13y agoPerhaps that's a matter of perspective: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libor_scandal http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libor_scandal
- hollerith 13y agoOK, but we're getting away from the subject of employee loyalty: the bank employees involved in the Libor scandal were probably motivated by personal enrichment, not by loyalty to their employer. It so happens that the employees' personal enrichment was aligned with the banks' corporate enrichment, which often happens (usually by design) in fields like finance or sales, but in a spy agency, it is not possible to align employee's personal interests with the interests of the organization broadly enough to get a similar effect. And I still maintain my larger point (implied in grandparent), that whether or not banks can find enough talent does not shed light on whether spy agencies can find enough loyal talent.
- tonyg 13y agoI was speaking narrowly to your point claiming that banks don't need loyalty like spy agencies do because they're not trying to hide billion-dollar programs. I'm suggesting they are in fact trying to hide billion-dollar programs, and need a kind of loyalty to facilitate this. Paying someone obscenely well seems like a nice way of buying a kind of loyalty. Certainly the upshot is behaviour equivalent to loyalty from the bank's perspective.
- tokenadult 13y agoI like Charles Stross essays for the interesting points they bring up, but I think this one is missing something. There will continue to be enough loyal-to-country people to staff the major intelligence agencies (and their contractors) in the major Western powers as long as there is some meaningful difference in governance and individual civil liberties between the West and the regions from which the West gathers intelligence. And there is. And there will be for a while. If eventually few people in the civilized, democratic countries of the West feel the need to spy on other countries, that will be mostly because those countries have become more civilized and more democratic--that is, more like the West. I have no desire for my daughter to live in a country where she can't obtain a full education, so there are at least a few countries in the world that have current policies that are absolutely opposed to my values, and, I think, the values of all civilized, rational persons. Over the years, there have also been national governments that have not flinched from exporting support to terrorist movements that seek to establish dictatorships where democracy is already established. (Yes, over the years, the United States itself has been in that category, but the United States seems largely to have learned from its comeuppance in some countries where it previously deposed elected leaders.) As long as there is fundamental international conflict based on core human values, there will still be people defending the best values by any means necessary. Charles Stross is based in Britain, and he talks about generational differences, but he doesn't go back even enough generations in Britain to notice that cultures can change in the direction of MORE loyalty to country as well as to less. The famous 1933 debate at Oxford about whether that year's students at Oxford would defend "king and country" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_King_and_Country_debate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_King_and_Country_debate (the answer that year was no) was followed up by a Britain that fought tenaciously for king and for country to defeat the Axis. I'm confident that there are plenty of Americans and will continue to be plenty of Americans who know enough history and understand enough about current world conditions to continue supporting United States governmental intelligence agencies and their contractors.
- cdonnellytx 13y agoThe problem here is that "the West" is one of the regions "from which the West gathers intelligence". The NSA and GCHQ are both spying on even other Western countries like Germany, to say nothing of spying on their own citizens.
- terranstyler 13y ago"Dog eat dog liberalism" is something quite different to what we have nowadays. I understand liberalism as something close to a free market. Now, western countries have everything but free markets. Here in Europe, social insurance and pension plans are state controlled and therefore monopolistic. Banks all over the world have legal privileges that wouldn't exist in free markets. Central banks are "calibrating" the interest rates everywhere in the world with India and Argentina already on the brink of hyperinflation. Yet we call the current system liberal (or capitalist) and we don't like the current system, therefore we call it dog-eat-dog liberalism and want to end capitalism. I wholeheartedly disagree with the author's point of view on this.
- Apocryphon 13y agoHe meant economically liberal, like neoliberal or even classical liberal. Laissez-faire.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- terranstyler 13y agoThat is what I think he meant. My point was that we don't have "3 generations of economic liberalism" (last paragraph) nor do we have anything even remotely close, see my first comment.
- cafard 13y agoMany countries have lost more secrets to money than to split or shifting loyalties. John Walker, Aldrich Ames, and Robert Hanson were in it for the cash (and in Hanson's case thrills). But there have always been cases of competing loyalties, sometimes sectional (think how much of the Old Army went over to the Confederacy), sometimes international--in the 20th Century commonly either communism or fascism. The main difference I see now is the ease of copying and publication.
- randomstring 13y agoThis article reads like something out of Asimov's The Foundation series. The author seems to suggest that secrets will be impossible in the future because no one will have any loyalty to one organization. Oh, and we can blame the Economy, the Internet, and Facebook for that.
- shabble 13y agoThe obvious solution is more technology! Neural Implants with TPM/DRM. Maybe we have it already, but your hippocampus doesn't think you have Need To Know. I know it's been written about, but I can't remember where.
- latj 13y agoDo I really have to log into something to read this article? Oh well, lots of other stuff to read...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aznjons 13y agoIn light of these predictions, I am more curious as to how governments will address this problem. I find it difficult that governments will easily give up on their surveillance goals. The question then becomes how will they work around the shifting generational trend that Charlie has identified? For example, will they leverage new analytical technology that enables them to employ a smaller number of people by automating tasks? For those of you who have read his Laundry Files novels, the SCORPION STARE network grants panopticon surveillance combined with lethal line-of-sight gorgonism emulation, which hypothetically enables automated control of a wide network of remote controlled camera weaponry to a few pilots instead of employing large numbers of people with guns. Maybe Charlie has predictions as to how governments will automate their surveillance systems or other new ways of maintaining their control in their supposed mission to protect the people in the face of less loyal prospective workers?
- shabble 13y agoYou might find "Rule 34"[1] has some interesting ideas for automation and control. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Rule-34-Charles-Stross/dp/0441020348/charlieswebsi-20 http://www.amazon.com/Rule-34-Charles-Stross/dp/0441020348/c...
- rdtsc 13y ago> The public perception of America [...] is diametrically opposed to the secretive practices of the surveillance state. [...] And when that happens, we see public servants who remain loyal to the abstract ideals conclude that the institution itself is committing treason. How amateurish and infantile of them. Yes finally Stross gets to the point but notice that the institution is not really committing treason, it only those misbehaved idealistic young morons who conclude that. I guess I shouldn't expect anything more from FP
- xerophtye 13y agoIs it just me, or is everyone just focusing on the "declining loyalty to state" trend? What about the observation that future kids are totally NOT the "spy material" ?? They aren't exactly anonymous beings. They'll ALL have a HUGE internet presence and a compulsive habit to photograph and document/publish EVERYTHING. And there really is nothing you can do about that. They'll be born into that environment and they will be like that from birth. So none of the generation Z ppl would be happy with the "abandon your internet-self for all eternity!" clause of the ToS of intelligence agencies.
- asdfre43 13y agoI know if I applied my chances of being hired would probably be <1%. But at the same time if they were desperate enough to hire my lot, well I'd know it's certainly more than a matter of being appealing or enthused with patriotism. And that scares me a lot more than anything I've been reading about. I don't want to be thinking about this stuff 24/7 for the rest of my life; who would compared to the vapid monetizing opportunities we see around here? But if we are at that point in time well perhaps that level of lifelong dedicated thinking is more than just a career option.